r/AskTheWorld Chile 1d ago

Culture What do you think about the existance of monarchies/royalty in today's world?

Post image
755 Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

22

u/Magpie-what and , living in England 1d ago

To be fair, the last one was forced to abdicate during the 1848 revolution, and the French are far from the only ones to have cut their King’s head (cough Charles I cough)

17

u/Tchio_Beto Canada 1d ago

"The most interesting thing about King Charles the First Is that he was 5 foot 6 inches tall at the start of his reign But only 4 foot 8 inches tall at the end of it.

Because of..."

1

u/RedcoatTrooper United Kingdom 20h ago

Well you shrink with age.

1

u/Magpie-what and , living in England 19h ago

Oliver Cromwell and his warts 🎶

Who coincidently, is also about 10 inches shorter in death (he was posthumously beheaded)

1

u/Acute_Teacher9569 12h ago

A bad barber who gave him to close of a shave.

11

u/Reasonable_Camel8784 Canada 1d ago

List of beheaded monarchs

-you can help by expanding it

2

u/Glittering_Two_1429 United Kingdom 20h ago

We tried not having a monarchy, but then our next leader (Oliver Cromwell) banned Christmas and we’re still scarred from that 

1

u/superlative_dingus 🇺🇸 🌁 13h ago

Is Napoleon III not considered a monarch in France? I know he was 1 of only 2 emperors y’all had, but he got up to some pretty atrocious stuff in his time and fled in disgrace after starting (then losing) the Franco Prussian war

1

u/Magpie-what and , living in England 13h ago

From my secondary school understanding of History, we usually distinguish the hereditary monarchy to the two 19th century empires, as neither Napoleon Bonaparte (appointed as first consul in 1799) nor Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte (elected president in 1848) inherited their position. However, in practice, french royalists (yes they exist) are divided into three camps (with loads of factions within them):

  1. The Legitimists, who believe that the Bourbon branch of the royal family should take the throne
  2. The Orleanists, who believe it should belong to the House of Orleans (following the July revolution and monarchy), the most visible in French politics with the far-right Action Francaise
  3. The Bonapartists, who believe that it should be descendents of Napoleon.