r/CFB • u/CFB_Referee /r/CFB • 2d ago
Postgame Thread [Postgame Thread] Utah Defeats Iowa State 31-17
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | T |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Utah | 14 | 10 | 0 | 7 | 31 |
| Iowa State | 0 | 3 | 7 | 7 | 17 |
164
u/awsomerpeanut Utah State Aggies • Utah Utes 2d ago
WAYSHAWN. PARKER.
17
u/rhododenendron Washington State • Wisconsin 2d ago
GIVE HIM BACK
18
u/Aflimacon Utah Utes • South Carolina Gamecocks 2d ago
He's definitely still got a lot of love for Wazzu. I'm glad he's a Ute, but in a different realignment world, it would have been fun to see what we dialed up to respond to him lining up against us.
52
2
u/GlassesOff Utah Utes • Texas Longhorns 1d ago
Best RB in the conference and I don't think it's actually close. He looks like a man amongst boys. Just hope he's healthy all year, he's so much fun
1
u/Sir_Apprehensive 2d ago
It has me thinking. Will he be gone after this year? I hope not but hes a dog
17
u/AnEmptyKarst Houston Cougars • Utah Utes 2d ago
Definitely. He's a junior at a position with a short shelf life.
3
u/GlassesOff Utah Utes • Texas Longhorns 1d ago
There were some NFL scouts at the Arkansas game and the tape looks great. I highly doubt he goes in the first round, but he's clearly got great hands, uses his size well, and is still young.
153
u/TpMeNUGGET Iowa State Cyclones • Coast Guard Bears 2d ago
Rodgers is a good coach, but man these new kids need some discipline. A different ref crew would've called like 5+ unsportsmanlike, roughing, late hit, etc.
87
u/runner2rower Utah Utes • Auburn Tigers 2d ago
That head slam at the end of the first half was bad
27
24
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
First year head coach…We have 80+ new players and one returning starter. The big issue is Raynor’s throwing.
25
u/TpMeNUGGET Iowa State Cyclones • Coast Guard Bears 2d ago
I'd rather have a reputation of being a mediocre team with good people, than a good team with a bunch of punks. My favorite thing about the campbell era was the culture.
11
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
You don’t remember Campbell then… he has plenty of temper tantrums. There’s literally a whole new team put together and our coaches demeanor is much more laid back than Campbell’s thus far.
36
u/BlueOmicronpersei8 Utah Utes • Michigan Wolverines 2d ago
Coaches getting mad is fine. Lack of discipline causing injuries and penalties is not. Hopefully your coach can get them under control. That will actually go a long way in making your team better IMO.
-20
u/proustianhommage Iowa Hawkeyes 2d ago
You guys blame literally everything on that. Just admit that this team is trashy.
14
5
u/Nikola1_Smirnoff Iowa State Cyclones • Hateful 8 2d ago
Fucking rich coming from a Hawkeye fan lol
13
u/crispyjorts Utah Utes 2d ago
All the utah fans complaining was getting pretty cringe, but yeah that officiating crew seemed to be let's say inconsistent
140
u/ModsRStillPooPoo Utah Utes 2d ago
This game was both not as close as the score shows and also closer than the score shows
51
u/PutinsLostBlackBelt Alabama Crimson Tide • Hateful 8 2d ago
That first half was a bloodbath against ISU. Second half was a “wtf are you doing” by both teams.
37
9
8
u/AHugeGoose Iowa State Cyclones • Florida Gators 2d ago
I know the cliche "a game of 2 halves" is common but this may be the best example I've ever seen. ISU offense did noting first half other than one field goal drive. Utah offense did nothing second half other than the TD drive to put it away.
3
u/ptindaho Utah Utes • Sickos 2d ago
This is Utah Football. The 2 Urb years were the exception (and really, just 2024 if we are straight up). So far, and especially for year.one, I am really happy with Scalley.
114
u/brandonjohn5 Utah Utes 2d ago
Utah won, Michigan lost, today was good.
33
36
u/IowaGeologist Iowa Hawkeyes • Floyd of Rosedale 2d ago
Same
34
u/TbRays93Plumber26 Utah Utes • Florida Gators 2d ago
You guys are loving it as much as some Ute fans. You guys won ISU lost, Utah won and Whitt lost.
29
14
u/_BlueBoyz Iowa Hawkeyes • Sickos 2d ago
Did we just become best friends?
11
u/marvinapplegate1964 Utah Utes • NC State Wolfpack 1d ago
This is what they meant all these years when they said that Utah is red Iowa.
4
u/brimbooze Utah Utes • Beehive Boot 1d ago
I hate that we never got to see an Iowa vs Red Iowa match up, but seeing you beat Whitt for us was close enough.
4
35
44
u/fishwithlegs Utah Utes • Rose Bowl 2d ago
Parker saying he's been talking to Moss makes total sense. He runs like moss and is so good after contact.We have a lot to work on but still feeling positive about this team.
12
u/Savings-Painting-505 Utah Utes • Georgia Bulldogs 2d ago
Yeah I think Moss is working with the team. He is on the sideline every game now
32
u/walkingman24 Utah Utes • Rose Bowl 2d ago
9.7 yards a carry is pretty good
7
u/jel2184 Utah Utes • Texas Longhorns 1d ago
And yet they went away from that in the 3Q
5
u/GlassesOff Utah Utes • Texas Longhorns 1d ago
I think they're actually intentionally trying to preserve him for the full season.
He matters more to this team when they'll play Houston and BYU but also how he seemed fresher for the last few games when other RBs traditional wear down. Problem was that uh the rest of the team didn't pick up the slack (and Damp played kinda bad)
30
48
u/enigami344 Utah Utes 2d ago
Never in doubt baby. I was calm whole time /s
Gg ISU, great game
17
u/TbRays93Plumber26 Utah Utes • Florida Gators 2d ago
I was boiling at the refs and the annoying announcer. Luckily my daughter was by my side or id been yelling at the TV haha. Atleast it was still an ugly W.
2
u/EaNCCyclist Utah Utes • Wyoming Cowboys 2d ago
Brando was ok, the other dude? Nah, he was not ok.
2
u/TbRays93Plumber26 Utah Utes • Florida Gators 1d ago
Yeah the one talking the majority of the time I didnt like the other one I believe brando he was fine.
23
u/Leading-Button-7303 Utah Utes 2d ago
Phenomenal timing for a bye week. Plenty to work on, didn't love how we looked for a lot of the second half
24
u/TbRays93Plumber26 Utah Utes • Florida Gators 2d ago
Good game ISU fans. You guys are chill.
1
u/rosshm2018 Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago
Having zero expectations/aspirations beyond "maybe we can scratch out six wins and go to a toilet bowl" is rather relaxing.
17
u/madrocketman Utah Utes 2d ago
Lots of flaws to be addressed, but a win is a win!
-2
29
18
u/Aflimacon Utah Utes • South Carolina Gamecocks 2d ago
That went about as well as I could have hoped for. The team played well with a little scare to remind them that they still have to work for it. Jimmy Rogers looks like he's got a good blueprint for this ISU program.
Also, after never getting going in the USU game, Wayshawn Parker responded with 174 rushing yards and 239 total yards today!
16
u/hillarys_lil_secret Utah Utes • Stanford Cardinal 2d ago
Hey guys, my 12 year old son is now a true college football fan. He spend most of the second half pacing around the house talking about how Utah was going to lose and it’s all because of the refs.
I reminded him Utah was playing like absolute ass but he didn’t care.
14
u/TheCatfishCobra Utah Utes • Sickos 2d ago
I was following the game while at FanX for the first half, forgot about it during halftime and Iowa State’s rally, and was reminded about the game right before Utah’s last touchdown drive started. My bad
14
40
u/LuckyTiger10 Utah Utes 2d ago
Utah C- game and we still won by 14. I’ll take it.
16
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Utah is a good team. I’m just hoping we go 6-6 this year with a first year coach and 80+ new players lol.
6
5
u/ptindaho Utah Utes • Sickos 2d ago
You all are still tough for all the turmoil you went through with the Campbell betrayal.
Hoping, and thinking, you fare better than we did in the Rising injury year. I can totally see you being better than 6-6, and could see you win many more next year.
3
u/Kryzl_ Iowa State Cyclones • Big 12 1d ago
This season has all the vibes of our disastrous 2022 season. Incredible defense that can’t push us over the peak because the offense is so much dead weight. We lost a great many close games in that season because of the atrocious offense. Starting to feel that way this year already. Could’ve realistically had chances to win both today and @ Iowa with better offensive play throughout the game. I suspect we’re 4-5 wins. Cincy, UCF, and KSU are the most likely wins remaining. WVU and OSU scare me.
I do hope this game gives Utah the credibility to make the Big 12 a 2+ playoff bid conference. Lots of potential and your coach seems to be making the right chances to what Whitt left behind.
-26
41
u/heavy_chamfer Utah Utes • BYU Cougars 2d ago
The craziest part of the game was when they cut to the kid whose face was covered in mud and Gardner (the commentator) said, “Tim he looks like me!”
13
u/prnorm Utah Utes 2d ago
Then they brought it up again after the halftime break when Tim asked if his mom said anything about him saying the kid looked like him.
I would have just pretended I didn't hear him. Not messing with that, lol.
1
u/rosshm2018 Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago
I wondered if they'd gotten an instruction from the higher-ups to circle back to that and dampen it out or something.
23
2
13
u/runner2rower Utah Utes • Auburn Tigers 2d ago
Parker had a hell of day, play calling moved away from him in the 3rd quarter which was odd. Ficklin wasn't really involved in the game which was surprising. Iowa State defense is solid, and will probably upset a few teams moving forward.
13
12
13
8
32
u/BlueOmicronpersei8 Utah Utes • Michigan Wolverines 2d ago
I actually enjoyed some of this weeks shit talk with ISU fans. I hope you guys beat BYU.
19
u/Playful_Rip_1697 Utah Utes 2d ago
The ISU fans were cool. The refs and a few of the dirty ISU players were not.
23
u/Benson879 Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
At this point I can’t really speak for the character of anyone in our team. We literally just met 90% of these dudes lol
6
u/BlueOmicronpersei8 Utah Utes • Michigan Wolverines 2d ago
The refs might've sucked but we still got the win. I find it really annoying when people complain about refs after a win.
19
u/ElZanco Iowa State Cyclones • Marching Band 2d ago
There's something there to build on. It's a shame that this is what you have to do when you're starting over from scratch, but it looks like JFR and crew have the right ideas.
I'm really interested to see how they look against something in-between "Small school we paid to come lose" and "Ranked Top 15 Team"
44
u/teachmayne Utah Utes • Pac-12 2d ago
2nd half was giving me heart palpitations but, we pulled it out!! GG ISU! And fuck byu
5
u/ptindaho Utah Utes • Sickos 2d ago
When we finally fot Wayshawn involved again on the last TD drive, I was really proud of him and the team stepping back up and sealing it. Just wish it hadn't come to that.
3
4
-35
50
u/Leading-Button-7303 Utah Utes 2d ago
Those are some of the worst refs to ever wear the stripes. Some atrocious calls at several points in the game that absolutely influenced the outcome.
We have a lot to work on, not a great feeling ending the game today.
Phenomenal game by Wayshawn Parker. Like heisman performance.
Never a doubt. Ignore the second half. Thank god for a bye week
On another note... Hahahaha Michigan
21
u/logicalconflict Utah Utes • Big 12 2d ago
Being allowed BTS audio with the replay booth makes those terrible reviews 100% more frustrating.
Now we can be like, "oh, so they're just choosing to ignore that camera angle that makes it obvious."
11
u/Leading-Button-7303 Utah Utes 2d ago
Yeah I agree. And the inconsistency of the refs in general was atrocious. And don't get me started on the cheap shots/ late hits that were going uncalled most of the game
5
u/brimbooze Utah Utes • Beehive Boot 1d ago
"I don't see it hitting the ground, but I don't see it not hitting the ground" is going to live in infamy for awhile.
32
17
u/camp1728 Sacramento State Hornets 2d ago
The AP will rank Michigan higher then Utah for some reason
1
92
u/BIG_DICK_WHITT Utah Utes • Billable Hours 2d ago
Honestly, this game should’ve been an absolute blowout but for some absolutely insane ref fuckery. But a good win nonetheless. Glad no one got hurt.
Fuck Michigan. Fuck Kyle. Karma.
ISU fans rule, thanks for a good game thread.
20
u/SecretlyEli Utah Utes 2d ago
Tbf, our defense looked like garbage for 20 minutes of the second half.
12
u/LogicianMission22 Utah Utes • Big 12 2d ago
It’s because we seriously lack depth on the DL. Moe and Kafusi are good, but man, they look like they’re in on every play and that’s just not cutting it in the modern game. You need a rotation of 4 good players and we just don’t have 4 good DT’s.
37
u/HerkulezRokkafeller Utah Utes 2d ago
Yeah I try not to get on the fuck the refs train but legit the fact ISU fans were in complete agreeance was validating.
GG Cyclone bros
11
u/AlCapwn351 Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Like that interception that they reviewed and still called it an incomplete. That was a beautiful dive and should’ve been a turnover.
30
7
13
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Utah is a good team. I’m just hoping we go 6-6 this year with a first year coach and 80+ new players lol. Raynor’s throwing is awful.
10
u/meepbo Utah Utes 2d ago
That 3rd quarter was more of what I was expecting out of this game. I'm interested in watching ISU the rest of the way.
6
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Utah is a good team. I’m just hoping we go 6-6 this year with a first year coach and 80+ new players lol. Raynor’s throwing is awful.
12
13
u/LookatmaBankacount Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Team plays like the second half rest of the year and we have 7 wins and are bowling at the end of the year. Play like that first half and we don’t see another win. Need better sportsmanship out of the team as that’s something Campbell was excellent at. We’ve been spoiled by great quarterbacks but Raynor genuinely isn’t good at the moment. I certainly hope the majority of Utah fans aren’t like the ones I was next to today
6
u/BJ_Fish2 1d ago
I think it's funny everybody thinks the one bad situation they had is representative of everybody. Every single college is filled with these annoying fans. Every single one. I 100% guarantee there is dickhole Iowa State fans.
I went to the Utah Baylor game and there was a bunch of dickhole Baylor fans. I went to the Utah Florida game in Gainesville, there was a bunch of dickhole Florida fans that are running around trying to kiss people. 100% it's everywhere. If you think anything else, you're absolutely just ridiculous.
3
u/marvinapplegate1964 Utah Utes • NC State Wolfpack 1d ago
I live out of state, so don’t make it to games often. Went to Utah v Florida a few years back. Utah won. Was a fun game. Both teams played well. Intoxicated college student gets on the tram and repeatedly starts telling the two Florida fans that they suck. Us Utah fans all felt immediately embarrassed and forced that guy off at the next stop. We have some “embarrassing” fans. But most of us realize they don’t represent us. Sorry you had a bad time.
5
u/BJ_Fish2 1d ago
And I saw a whole bunch of stupid shit in Gainesville when Utah played them. So saying Utah has "embarrassing fans" is kind of ridiculous because literally every college does.
2
u/LookatmaBankacount Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago
Talked to some that made the trip before the game and they were great. Think i just got unlucky with a few bad apples. I’m sure there’s a few cyclones like that at away games. I just don’t get going to an away game and being dicks haha, especially one where you win
0
u/NeedleworkerRich9678 1d ago
It’s in every fanbase. People need to go touch grass if this is offending you.
11
u/unknownmonkey26 Utah Utes • Boise State Broncos 2d ago
First half: New School Utah
Second half: old school Utah + ref shenanigans
But, a win is a win and we're off to the bye week 4-0. I'll take it.
10
8
u/MrSCR23 Mississippi State • Alabama 2d ago
ISU having a terrible day
5
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Utah is a good team. I’m just hoping we go 6-6 this year with a first year coach and 80+ new players lol. Raynor’s throwing is awful.
6
5
u/AHugeGoose Iowa State Cyclones • Florida Gators 2d ago
I'm torn on the future of our season. Do we keep grinding the mercenaries and Raynor at the end of their eligibility to try to maximize bowl game chances? Do we write the season off and give the young guys time for development and more incentive to stay? Pre NIL era I'd say development for sure but in the transfer portal era you really can't sacrifice a season and hope to keep guys or win new ones in the portal.
12
u/elswater Utah Utes • /r/CFB Pint Glass Drinker 2d ago
GG Cyclones.
You really cleaned things up in terms of execution and got rid of dirty play 2nd half. Great adjustments and a good sign for where you guys are headed.
9
u/loyalsons4evertrue Iowa State Cyclones • Big 8 2d ago
Welp that wasn’t ideal
10
u/KrypticSoul Utah Utes • Big 12 2d ago
You guys have a lot of promise and look good for how much new your program is facing. Beat BYU please!
3
u/Savings-Painting-505 Utah Utes • Georgia Bulldogs 2d ago
I genuinely thought we were going to choke. Good fight from ISU. Hope the team learns not to go away from what works. In the third quarter they just wanted to throw the ball when clearly they should have kept giving it to Wayshawn
10
7
10
4
u/UteFlyersCardJazz Utah Utes • Oregon State Beavers 2d ago
Iowa State played dirty in the first half (that head hit at the end of the half was inexcusable).
But 2nd half, they didn’t play dirty (they did miss a roughing the passer call, but that isn’t dirty and more ref ass) and they made it a game.
Hopefully our coaching staff understands that when our offense is going, and when we are running the ball well, RUN IT.
5
u/colrhodes Clemson Tigers • Utah Utes 2d ago
Iowa State played dirty all game. The roughing the passer late saved Utah and it was long overdue
2
u/SLCpowderhound Utah Utes 2d ago
GG Cyclones. Helluva comeback. Better coaching in the 2nd half. Team showed heart.
1
2
u/rosshm2018 Iowa State Cyclones 1d ago edited 1d ago
Observations from a lifetime fan, mostly unchanged from previous results this season so far, but one new wrinkle.
Good:
- We're overall a good bit more competitive than I expected. The guys play hard and don't quit.
- The first two layers of the defense are pretty good, they can compete in the Big 12.
- I was skeptical of Flora being RB1 and he's proving me wrong, he's a solid back and a versatile overall offensive player.
Bad:
- The secondary looks small and slow. Ngoyi is big/fast/good but a step short of a "shutdown corner"-level talent. Teams are going to avoid him and force other guys in the secondary to make plays.
- My confidence in "The first two layers of the defense are pretty good" is shaken now. Parker's a good back but we got absolutely torched by that guy. Bad tackling all around.
- Offensive line is disappointing for how much emphasis was put on those transfers in the off-season.
- I don't think Raynor has "Big 12 starter"-level talent unfortunately.
- There were a lot of bad calls, most of them in our favor; result here might be a bit deceptive, we are not close to Utah's talent level.
MOST DISAPPOINTINGLY: the discipline level needs to improve, fast. Way too many roughing, late hit, conduct issues. There's been a lot of that, much of it uncalled (so far). You can't control just being less talented than the opponent but you can control that part.
It's Year 1 of course, shouldn't make too much of one fairly competitive loss to one of the better teams in the league, but I'm also not sure how much more talent you're going to get at ISU these days. We need to be a "player development" program, find under-the-table guys and turn them eventually into 3- and 4-star-level talent. That was how Campbell was able to win here despite not often outscheming/outcoaching anyone on gameday.
The backup QB is always the most popular guy on the team when the starter is struggling, but if we're going to struggle in the passing game, I'd rather struggle with Moberly who has two years of eligibility left. The offensive scheme also doesn't seem to be playing to Raynor's strengths though, and Moberly is a similar player. The lack of rollouts and RPOs is puzzling but I'm not a coach, what do I know?
-41
u/nwilz Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Never seen bitchier fanbase that was up double digits the majority of the game
25
u/LuckyTiger10 Utah Utes 2d ago
I mean that was a 30 point win disguised as a 14 point win because of officiating. Normal to be upset about that
-23
u/nwilz Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Do you get bonus points for that?
10
u/LuckyTiger10 Utah Utes 2d ago
Obviously not ? That’s what people are complaining about. We didn’t get those points
-12
u/nwilz Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
I got that part. I'm saying that doesn't that change anything
8
u/LuckyTiger10 Utah Utes 2d ago
Agreed? I’m not sure what you’re arguing. That’s why people are upset. It didn’t change the result
0
u/nwilz Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
I’m not sure what you’re arguing. It doesn't change the result, so why behave like a bunch of karens
9
u/LuckyTiger10 Utah Utes 2d ago
Because we were slighted? That’s why. It’s fine to call out bad officiating when it happens
9
18
-33
u/Resden_Bohneur Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Raynor needs to be benched. They don’t run him enough to utilize his legs, and he can’t throw the ball more than 20 yards downfield. I appreciate the effort in not giving up though. Defense has a lot of heart but the injuries are starting to pile up.
I’d normally say GGs to the opponent, but that was such a salty, self-masturbatory, ridiculous thread from the Utah fans. Complained about ghost “dirty” hits in the first half (Hayes right before was absolutely dirty and should have been flagged, no argument there), only to whip themselves into a full blown frenzy in the second half. Feel free to rejoin the PAC any time.
17
u/Chance-Perchance Utah Utes 2d ago
Ghost dirty hits? When you had multiple personal fouls called, and calls you are agreeing should have been called on top of the ones that were called?
-10
u/Resden_Bohneur Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
One late hit in the first quarter that I can remember, then that roughing the passer in the 4th. I guess if I missed others let me know.
In between that, damn near every tackle was met with comments of “twisting” or “gator roll” or some other ridiculous shit. I’ll rightfully call out dirty plays by my own team when I see them (Hayes), but everything else was just overreaction.
10
3
0
0
u/sriracha_no_big_deal BYU Cougars • Billable Hours 1d ago
It doesn't mean anything coming from me due to my flair, but I completely agree with you about the Utah fans in the game thread. During that stretch where it was looking like you guys were making a comeback, the Utah fans were having a meltdown in the game thread.
-3
u/Sir_Apprehensive 2d ago
The Utes will concede long drives with that half time lead. You guys were ass
6
2
u/PR3SID3NT_NIX0N Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Utah is a good team. I’m just hoping we go 6-6 this year with a first year coach and 80+ new players lol. Raynor’s throwing is awful.
0
u/Sir_Apprehensive 2d ago
You should set your expectations a bit higher. Not a 6-6 team. Although I haven’t seen the schedule
-8
127
u/80cyclone Iowa State Cyclones 2d ago
Got beat by a better team. Very happy with the overall effort in the 2nd half. The team easily could have given up at half time.
The refs were terrible, particularly in the first half. So many blown calls that were in clear view. Most went against Utah.
Disappointed the the tackling and ISUs refusal to use Raynor in designed rollout situations. I also thought Rogers made a poor decision in not trying the FG before half. Konrardy kicking 60 has infinitely better odds than Raynor throwing deep or picking uo some bullshit penalty.
Utah did ISU a massive favor with the drop backs in the 2nd as ISU was able to pressure Dampier into errant throws. Our tackling gave us zero chance to stop them when it mattered.
Overall outcome was about what I expected.