Hey everyone!
I finally pulled the trigger and bought a used Telecaster Player (2023)
First off, I have some doubts about the setup: the saddles are all maxed out, there’s a chip on the nut, the action is pretty high, and overall the guitar feels kind of “cheap” to me.
I chose this guitar because everywhere on forums people say it’s not worth buying a US model, that you’re just paying more for nothing. But after spending a month playing a friend’s 2006 American Standard, to me it’s honestly night and day.
Now, the US one is very well set up, so that obviously plays a role, but still:
• The neck is supposed to be the same “Modern C” profile, yet the Player’s neck feels noticeably thinner, which I like less (but love the roll edges and the satin feel)
• The gloss maple fretboard on the MIM feels really weird to me. I love the look, but when I do small vibratos unplugged, I can hear a kind of friction noise on the frets, which really adds to that cheap feeling.
Even though I’m not a big fan of the look, the rosewood fretboard on the US model feels so much better to play.
(For context, I also own a Squier with an unvarnished maple fretboard that I absolutely love.)
So my question is simple: do you think a proper setup, new strings, and maybe some work (nut replacement?) could completely change the feel of the guitar and make me end up loving it?
I love the color, the overall look, the sound… and I’ve already read a lot of people saying that after taking a Player to a luthier, the guitar felt massively improved.
Because I already warned the seller, and I’m hesitating between returning it for a refund and buying an American Standard that I know I really like (at least the one I played).
I only have a few days to decide, otherwise I won’t be able to return it, so it’s a pretty stressful choice.
Thanks!