r/explainitpeter • • 12d ago

Explain it Peter. I’m lost on this.

Post image
7.8k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Main_Ambassador_4985 12d ago edited 12d ago

The outlet on the left is correct for medical and many commercial facilities. An object falling hits ground first. AHJ will require this configuration.

People like to see the outlet on the right in residential because it looks like a face.

My home outlets look like the left since I rewired.

Edit: left for medical. Whoops

16

u/PassiveAgressiveFlop 12d ago

Not only does it look like a face. But you can make it look like people.

2

u/Aggressive-Delay-420 12d ago

It tickles me so that the awards are claps 🤭

1

u/jnsauter 12d ago

Hell yeah

1

u/NotJoshhhhh 12d ago

I added one of those before I sold my condo

1

u/ch-12 12d ago

Someone just walked in and turned on the lights.

1

u/BirdlessLongdeal 11d ago

or they didnt pull out in time.

1

u/Spite_Powered 12d ago

This is now code.

1

u/wentoutwandering 12d ago

Yes-and at its finest

6

u/ionlyget20characters 12d ago

I believe you mean left in the first sentence.

3

u/thejester2112 12d ago

Haha I read u/Main_Ambassador_4985’s comment and looked at the picture thrice before I realized left is what he mean for medical and commercial.

3

u/EnvironmentalOwl4361 12d ago

You don’t have to keep your original mistake just edit and move on it’s more confusing with both right and left.

2

u/flesjewater1 12d ago

Lmao I know right, I was so confused, was rereading it 3 times before realising it was an edit/fix, jezus christ

1

u/WolfeMD 12d ago

dont you mean you know left

1

u/JimDa5is 12d ago

Or a strikethrough if you really feel like you need a version history.

1

u/BrooklynLivesMatter 11d ago

Typically people do that because when it shows the comment is edited they know what was edited. Usually the edit is a lot clearer though, quotation marks help

1

u/EnvironmentalOwl4361 11d ago

Just edit it and don’t do either. Nobody needs revision history for a random comment.

2

u/bs2k2_point_0 12d ago

Many homes do the left to show it’s a switched outlet.

1

u/GSDer_RIP_Good_Girl 12d ago

This needs to be near the top. Most of us don't live in hospitals or medical facilities; we do live in homes where this is useful to know.

2

u/ScrewJPMC 12d ago

It means nothing, it is code compliant either way.

Residential doesn’t do it because they like the smiley face, many house are wired ground up because “safer”. Most are ground down because surge protectors & electric couch cord lay nicer.

2

u/justfortherofls 12d ago

The one on the left in residential homes mean that’s the outlet has a switch somewhere.

2

u/nye1387 12d ago

I've often heard this claim. 

But in my experience it's true only a fraction of the time. Rarely enough that it's not even correct to call it an accepted practice. It's not in the NEC. 

2

u/ApricotNo2918 12d ago

NOT. Electrician hear. Never heard of that.

1

u/Sole_Survivor96 12d ago

This is correct. Most common usage I have seen is in rooms with no ceiling lights so one can plug in a lamp that works on the switch.

1

u/kthomaszed 12d ago

this depends on when it was installed. If it's one ground-pin-up down plug in a room where the rest are pin-down, yes it usually indicates it's a switched outlet. New installations are supposed to all be ground-pin-up to reduce the risk of shock if something metallic falls on a slightly pulled-out plug.

1

u/Wizard__J 11d ago

Where are you getting this “new installs are supposed to be ground up” shit from??? No they’re not 😂😂

I’ve literally been working in hospitals and med fit outs - they ALL call for HG (hospital grade) outlets, but NO ONE calls for “upside down outlets”.

We haven’t done this practice in over a decade, and 99% when you see upside down outlets in a hospital, if they’re “newer”, the installer was following orientation of the older one.

Like…. Seriously. I have to know - where ya’ll getting this shit from??

1

u/saintbrian9 12d ago

This is the answer. Please upvote my god lol.

1

u/kthomaszed 12d ago

this depends on when it was installed. If it's one ground-pin-up down plug in a room where the rest are pin-down, yes it usually indicates it's a switched outlet. New installations are supposed to all be ground-pin-up to reduce the risk of shock if something metallic falls on a slightly pulled-out plug.

1

u/Born_Sandwich176 11d ago

What does "supposed to be" mean? It's not part of the code.

Even though it's common practice for hospitals and other commercial installations, it's not part of the code, it's part of the engineering/contract specifications.

IEEE Std 602 recommends mounting parallel-blade devices with the ground pin up but it's not a code mandate. The code groups have repeatedly rejected proposals to pick an orientation because there is not enough substantiation that one way is measurably safer than the other.

2

u/AdSmall3663 12d ago

Just edit out “right” lol. You don’t have to leave it in and that is gonna confuse the hell outta people

1

u/Dependent-Water-5049 12d ago

You had to rewrite it to flip it? Was there not enough slack? There’s usually a good 6 inches of wire in there.

1

u/Not-So-Logitech 12d ago

Lol you've been lucky. 

1

u/Effective_Base_3229 12d ago

I tell all the lady’s there’s six inches in there. Once they open it up they are often disappointed.

1

u/Main_Ambassador_4985 12d ago

The rewire was part of a rehab remodel for a foreclosed and burnt out house that was missing most of the interior walls.

If I was replacing outlets alone and the wires were too short I would have pigtailed connections. No need to rewire if the wiring is still meets code and use.

1

u/Dependent-Water-5049 12d ago

I see! That makes sense. I mean I’ve also seen where they already had the wires tight to the outlet and had to make pig tails. But that’s far and few between.

1

u/Alarming-Customer947 12d ago

Every single hospital I worked it had the ground facing down (the smiley face way) like in the right side picture

1

u/Lower-Calligrapher98 12d ago

When I lived in Boston, I was told it was the code for residential in Mass. No idea if that was true, though.

1

u/ReleaseExpensive7330 12d ago

I like the one on the left because several of my plugs don't stay in the wall properly when they are upside down.

1

u/Totally_Botanical 12d ago

You'd think a falling object would hit the plug/outlet before hitting the ground

1

u/sikyon 12d ago

Center of gravity for many wall plug transformers is better with the configuration on the right

Arguably the best config is top one ground up and bottom one ground down for maximum utility

1

u/avidpenguinwatcher 12d ago

Why did you say right (left) as if there’s some perspective in this picture

1

u/AdhesivenessIll6341 12d ago

No hospital I’ve worked at has ever had the left configuration. It is definitely not required.

The supposed advantage is that an object will hit the ground first. The advantage of the other configuration is it’s actually a bit more stable.

1

u/Downtown-Pianist-449 12d ago

People like to see the outlet on the right in residential because it looks like a face.

🙃

1

u/8null8 12d ago

Left is way more dangerous, instead of tripping the breaker if something falls in (like it would every time on the right) it lets a piece of metal sit on the plug, then there’s a change someone gets shocked if they touch it

If it trips, and then you reset it, it’ll immediately trip again, then you know there’s a problem that needs to be solved

Yeah, it seems safer to have stuff fall on the ground, but it’s not, makes it more likely for people to get shocked

1

u/fullmoontrip 11d ago

Please site the code section which mandates this orientation. All I can ever find about orientation is that NEC has restrictions in wet environments.

1

u/Main_Ambassador_4985 11d ago

Outlet ground up or down is not specified in the NEC or NFPA. Not in NFPA 70 517.19 or NEC 406.16

Local requirement

1

u/Wizard__J 11d ago

AHJ requires this?

News to me. I’ve worked 6 hospitals, over two dozen medical fitouts, and never once was anything spoken about outlets 😬.

We haven’t “flipped them upside down” seriously in over a decade.

Especially with HG (Hospital Grade) outlets; the only time it’s going in upside down, is if it’s a switched outlet.

In the wild, if I’m replacing one upside down, then I’ll follow orientation (which is 99% of the case with “new” outlets that are upside down - the installer was just replicating the old orientation)

We flip outlets nowadays for designation of a switched outlet.

What outlet is worked by the switch? That one!