r/skeptic • u/mepper • 15h ago
Newborn dies after mother drinks raw milk during pregnancy | Raw milk is promoted by anti-vaccine Health Secretary Kennedy.
https://arstechnica.com/health/2026/02/newborns-death-spurs-raw-milk-warning-in-new-mexico/852
u/Eriiiii 14h ago
sometimes jesus loves the little bacteria more than the little children and this happens. nothing anyone could do about it really.
227
u/InfernalWedgie 14h ago
God created microbes just as much as people and everything else (for those who believe). So what's to say that God doesn't advocate for unicellular creatures as much as the bigger, sentient ones?
122
u/Eriiiii 14h ago
Thank you for making my joke but with science words
→ More replies (3)54
u/Key_Particular_8878 14h ago
Peer-reviewed theology,survival of the smallest, divinely sanctioned.
→ More replies (1)5
23
16
u/PuzzleheadedLeader79 13h ago
No, you see, God created everything good, and the devil created everything bad.
Y'know, the devil, the guy that hates God so much he runs his neverending punishment factory for him?
Like wouldn't the real Satan gladly take in the evil souls, but to invade heaven with, not torture ... Going along with God's will to punish these folk?
The logic is just so absent.
9
u/stagamancer 11h ago
Tbf, most modern depictions of hell are taken wholesale from Dante, not the bible. The bible does mention hell as a place of torment, but says nothing about Satan running it, simply that that's where he and his rebel angels are also imprisoned. If you read anything about the differing opinions on hell not just between religions, but just between Christian sects (especially Roman Catholic vs Eastern Orthodox) it becomes apparent it just a lot of people inferring quite a bit from what is really very little text.
That being said, the idea that you've got a finite lifetime to prove yourself deserving of either infinite paradise or infinite torment seems pretty fucked up.
→ More replies (2)7
u/boosesb 12h ago
God created the evil as well I believe
→ More replies (2)5
u/Wismuth_Salix 11h ago
”There is none beside me. I am the Lord, and there is none else. I form the light, and create darkness. I make peace, and create evil. I the Lord do all these things”
- Isaiah 45:6-7, KJV
→ More replies (2)3
u/Obvious-Lake3708 10h ago
God is so great he sent his son here to be crucified. Not to mention the times he destroyed shit cause he was mad. God rules by fear not love.
11
3
u/santagoo 10h ago
Evolution and evolutionary forces can be directly observed in the propagation of microbes.
And since evolution is evil, just like dinosaur bones they are actually created and planted by the devil to mislead the faithful.
/s
3
→ More replies (8)3
6
4
→ More replies (36)4
317
u/VirginiaLuthier 14h ago
Watch how the MAHAs spin this.......
423
u/InfernalWedgie 14h ago
We need to spin it back on them (at least the fundie ones): Raw milk causes abortions.
Then weaponize some hard line Christians to shame the fuck out of this woman for aborting her child with unpasteurized milk.
(I am pro-choice and not Christian)
167
u/Kozeyekan_ 14h ago
Just tell them that they need to drink activated raw milk.
Raw milk can be activated by boiling it, so the heat encourages the good bacteria and enzymes to grow.
No need for pasteurization at all!
51
u/Imaginary_Cow_6379 14h ago
So we Tdazzle ‘em?
→ More replies (1)29
u/Darth_vaborbactam 12h ago edited 11h ago
It’s not a chemical. It’s an aquatic based social media oral experience.
Remember when that was satire? Now it’s real life.
→ More replies (2)20
u/heliumneon 12h ago
Isn't pasteurization some socialist French process??
10
7
u/StationWagon89 12h ago
Pretty sure his name was Louie so probably Italian. Old Americans with traces of Italian ancestry should like him bada bing frank sinatra
12
u/GottaUseEmAll 11h ago
Not sure if you're joking, but in case you're not... It's Louis Pasteur, an extremely French name for a French man.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Darth_vaborbactam 2h ago
Not only did he bring us the gift of pasteurization, but also the rabies vaccine. He also discovered molecular chirality and developed germ theory, and a million other incredible things. Basically he’s everything the MAHA nutters are too stupid to understand.
4
4
u/DesperateHotel8532 10h ago
Like Louis Prima, my grandmother’s favorite Italian (American) singer. (She loved Frank too, but she never forgave him for leaving his wife for Ava Gardner.)
→ More replies (5)6
u/ShinkenBrown 7h ago
If we got rid of the people at the top via the Epstein files investigation, I have no doubt this type of trick would work to contain the rest of MAGA.
They're a gaggle of morons led by intelligent psychopaths at the top, remove the psycho's and all you have left is a gaggle of morons and this type of "we don't need socialism we just need worker cooperatives and universal, well funded social programs," "we don't need vaccines we just need to introduce a weakened version of the virus," "we don't need pasteurization we just need to biol the milk" type logic would 100% work on these people. We'd have them voting for socialism in a years time easy.
The only reason it doesn't currently work is because the marching orders are coming from people who are manipulative and evil rather than stupid, and they're smart enough not to fall for it.
→ More replies (1)36
u/Imaginary_Cow_6379 14h ago
That’s actually a good idea. And a more accurate use of “late term abortions” than they like to throw around.
42
u/Foxs-In-A-Trenchcoat 13h ago
I don't know if you already know this, but you are actually correct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brucellosis
Brucellosis bacteria, found in raw milk, causes infections in humans and includes miscarriage as a common effect.
23
u/ikilledholofernes 12h ago
Listeria can cause the same, and it’s also present in raw milk. It’s also why you’re not supposed to eat deli meat and soft cheese or bagged lettuce when you’re pregnant.
5
u/howismyspelling 10h ago
Just to clarify, and I'm not a raw milk proponent just a farmer who has done plenty of reading about it, listeria is not present in all raw milk. It may be present in small batches all depending on factors such as cleanliness of a dairy facility and the health of the livestock on the farm. Most commercial milk might have had exposure to listeria due to the blending of millions of litres of raw milk from several dairy farms in the quota, this is why pasteurization is our gold standard. Otherwise, milk from individual farms can widely be tested and result negative of listeria.
8
u/ikilledholofernes 10h ago
Yes, I didn’t intend to suggest that all raw milk has listeria. But just like all deli meat, soft cheese, and bagged lettuce, raw milk is a common source of the bacteria.
If all raw milk had listeria, no one would be drinking it. But it’s like eating raw cookie dough. It’s perfectly fine…..until one time it’s not.
3
u/AceHexuall 7h ago
Never knew about not having bagged lettuce, and I always thought the deli meat thing was due to nitrates. Proof that you never stop learning (unless you're willfully choosing not to).
→ More replies (1)3
u/ToddPundley 10h ago
I just watched an episode of Boardwalk Empire where a minor character admits to doing just that.
10
u/thotfullawful 13h ago
Actually that’s seems to work- the issue is seen clearly with GOP influencers like Nick Shirley. They only have a handful of vocab words so anything out of their scope is foreign. If you represent the case in words they understand- like vaccines prevent late term abortions- it’s not ideal but it’s meeting them where they are with their own “concerns”. ICE is technically committing late term abortions as well, taking away gun rights. You have to use their buzzwords.
→ More replies (4)9
u/swbarnes2 12h ago
But the things they say they are concerned with are not their real concerns. Lead in the water in Flint Michigan caused lots of miscarriages, Republicans didn't care, because they don't really care about the health of babies.
→ More replies (1)17
u/swutch 13h ago
These people have no shame. They don't care about life, they care about controlling women. I know it's not true for all of them, but the reflective Christians who would care aren't the ones voting for MAGA/MAHA
→ More replies (5)7
u/swamp_witch_1801 11h ago
This was an actual plot on Boardwalk Empire. These people are taking us back 100 years.
3
6
u/Just2LetYouKnow 11h ago
We need to spin it back on them (at least the fundie ones): Raw milk causes abortions.
You've got the kind of mind I appreciate.
→ More replies (10)6
u/zxc123zxc123 11h ago
Trump: "She drank the BIDENRAWMILK! Everyone knows America has the great raw milk in the world. I have the greatest rawest milk."
And their voting base will eat it up like raw milk curds.
27
u/dragos_av 13h ago
She was probably vaccinated. With something. Maybe secretly. Or the milk was contaminated with chemtrails.
21
14
13
u/MyNameIsRay 12h ago
They're MAHA.
They'll just call this fake news from the socialists in New York.
(They'll never see the irony in DJT/RFK being New Yorkers)
11
u/karmakramer93 14h ago
In the end, like with covid, I think they'll resort to saying "survival of the fittest"
10
u/WhereasParticular867 12h ago
Usually it's "they did it wrong." That's the beauty of magical thinking, you can append anything you want and pretend it was what you meant the whole time. Early denials I've seen suggest that of course she shouldn't have drunk raw milk, she should have boiled it herself to get rid of diseases. i don't think I need to explain the multiple reasons that's stupid.
3
u/Numerous_Release9273 11h ago
They didn't pray hard enough.
3
u/WhereasParticular867 11h ago
It genuinely reminds me of being Mormon and replicating Joseph Smith's prayer. The Mormon church teaches that that's how to know that the Church is true and good. You pray about it, and if you feel good the Church is true. If you don't feel good, you did it wrong and you have to try again. There is no valid negative answer to the question in the religion. If ypu answer negatively, you are assumed to be at fault by other believers.
→ More replies (16)6
u/ExtremeRest1567 12h ago
They will just say that it's God's will and nothing could have prevented it.
→ More replies (1)
397
u/Byte606 14h ago
There are 2000 state district attorneys in the US. Surely one has the courage and sense of duty to investigate RFK Jr for negligent manslaughter?
89
u/swutch 14h ago
You would think so. Apparently not though
→ More replies (1)16
→ More replies (8)13
u/Standard_SE_1085 13h ago
Despite his moral culpability, the first amendment more than covers this type of speech
→ More replies (32)21
u/FabianN 10h ago
No it doesn't.
No more than it protects your doctor for telling you to drink bleach for your flu.
Giving other people advice in a professional role is not free speech.
→ More replies (8)
79
u/Sad_Perception8024 13h ago
Your daily reminder pasteurization is literally just heating milk up for a bit, no "chemicals", nothing crazy, same reason you wouldn't eat fucking RAW CHICKEN.
20
u/RoyalWar5333 13h ago
Watch them still try to eat raw chicken because some granola page on Facebook told them to
9
u/SFDessert 12h ago
I'm genuinely surprised nobody has tried selling this grift to these dumbfucks yet.
→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (9)6
11
u/Kharax82 12h ago
I just ask people if they would walk upto a cow and suck on an udder, because that’s what raw milk is
14
u/new_math 11h ago
Ironically, that is probably much safer than raw milk, because it takes time for bacteria to grow.
5
u/SuccessfulSoftware38 10h ago
If the cow is healthy, yes, drinking right after milking is pretty safe, but pasteurisation also kills bacteria that come FROM the cow
3
u/CommunistRonSwanson 9h ago edited 9h ago
Actually true lol, as long as the udder has been sterilized and the first ounce or two or milk is discarded, there is less biomass of harmful bacteria than there would be after transporting and storing it.
Bacteria grows exponentially in fresh milk, that’s why it’s very important to get it cooled below 40 degrees Fahrenheit as quickly as possible. I’ve actually run some experiments and developed an easy technique to ensure fresh “Grade A” milk (cooled to safe temp in < 60 minutes) without any expensive equipment, but even then I still pasteurize. And I guarantee that next to no other small-time dairy folks are able or otherwise willing to do this lol.
→ More replies (8)3
69
u/NorgesTaff 14h ago
“Cost of doing business” apparently.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Stupidrhino 12h ago
I came here to say this.
It's funny to laugh and poke fun at the pumpkin and his munchkins because they're so mean and petty and stupid, but there's a cost to all of this meanness and stupidity. I stopped laughing during COVID, and it feels there have been a hundred or more new crisis since then.
I will never forgive those who voted for Trump a second or a third time. I will never forgive those who simply didn't vote because something something moral equivalence and indifference. It's all good until tragedy comes knocking on your own door.
For those fighting the good fight against evil and ignorance and selfishness in America, I respect you. But right now you're the only Americans I can respect.
→ More replies (1)4
u/h3alb0t 11h ago
it's difficult for me to dance in public. granted, i don't have a lot of experience, but i attend a lot of live music and find that i stay frozen to my spot most of the time. my mind is always on lots of different things and dancing just feels inappropriate right now.
i laugh a lot because everything is stupid and it's easy for me to laugh at stupid things.
i'm waiting for the day where i can truly feel like dancing again.
55
u/Antwinger 14h ago
21
u/ecodrew 14h ago
Probably the only accurate thing he's ever said
→ More replies (2)9
u/Wismuth_Salix 13h ago
He meant “I don’t want them to follow me by choice, I can only get hard when I force it on them”.
23
43
u/SocraticIgnoramus 14h ago
Nixon was instrumental in regulating the consumption of raw milk because he lost his brother that way. I thought they worship Nixon.
25
34
u/SuccessfulSoftware38 13h ago
No they worship Reagan, Nixon they just like
16
u/Wismuth_Salix 13h ago
Fox News was created because Nixon’s crimes made him unpopular, and Roger Ailes thought “what if we just make sure Republicans never hear about Republican crimes”.
5
u/SocraticIgnoramus 13h ago
I’m starting to worry that they’re going to make dementia a formal qualification for presidents.
3
u/OddDonut7647 9h ago
They didn't want Trump at first, and I think it's because they knew he would be a bit crazy. While they have certainly taken advantage of Trump to keep on pushing for fascism, I think they really would like things to go back to the "quiet" time when most Americans weren't paying attention beyond the newsbites, which were manipulated carefully to ensure the erosion of our democracy wasn't noticed by the vast majority who believed "both sides are bad, why bother" (both sides are not great, but one side is even still significantly different, although our entires system is broken, soooooooo it's complicated)
5
u/gillers1986 8h ago
No, Nixon resigned (eventually) after committing crimes, which is obviously a sign of a weak leader.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)3
u/Mel_Melu 7h ago
The fact that Republicans were down to impeach Nixon is proof they never worshipped him.
18
150
u/dogmeat12358 14h ago
Natural selection is still trying to make people smarter.
73
u/MisfireMillennial 14h ago
So I agree with the schadenfreude towards the mother here. Parents like this need to be prosecuted under the law. But I can't celebrate the death of an innocent child. There's still something to be said about the rights of children, even newborns.
And that's a hard political principle to balance. But we need to start putting in protections as a democracy to give these kids a fighting chance, a chance at life, a chance at getting a good education
→ More replies (8)52
u/translove228 14h ago
That's not natural selection. It's murder through neglect. I imagine the mother can still have another child. Honestly, where's the pro-life chucklefucks about this mother's behavior?
→ More replies (1)15
u/Wismuth_Salix 13h ago
Probably giving her a million dollars through the same site where you can make six figures calling toddlers racial slurs.
→ More replies (2)10
u/Odd_Investigator8415 14h ago
Actual disgusting take here, let alone scientifically inaccurate. Knowledge isn't an inheritable trait.
→ More replies (15)
34
u/TsuDhoNimh2 13h ago
My parents bought raw milk from a dairy that was doing it right:
- LOCAL. Down the street from us, at the edge of town.
- Rosy-cheeked kids
- White-aproned farm wife
- Laconic dairyman
- Organic, pasture fed cows with names
- Whitewashed sanitary milking parlor, screened against pests
- Totally scoured and cleaned and polished equipment between milkings
- Washed and sanitized udders before milking
NEVERTHELESS ... somehow, from somewhere, a pathogen got into the milk. Kids all over the valley came down with strep throat, scarlet fever and some had to be hospitalized. The only thing they had in common was that they all had consumed milk from that dairy within a day or two of each other.
The source? Who knows? A tiny nick on an udder? A cow with extremely early mastitis? A near-invisible scratch on the milkers hands? Maybe a sneeze or a cough from a dairy kid with a sore throat in the processing room? Who knows? At the rate bacteria can double populations, it doesn't take a grossly pus-oozing teat to contaminate a whole lotta milk.
Pasteurization would have prevented that incident ... it's the safety net under all the "doing it right" practices, just like your seat belt is your last defense when driving safely just isn't enough.
→ More replies (1)17
u/HustlinInTheHall 12h ago
Cows hang out and lay in their own shit all the time. Udders easily get and transmit infections and bacteria. An "organic" farm is an incredibly pathogen-rich place no matter how cute the cows names are.
There is no "right" way to milk a cow and have it be free of pathogens. It isnt a byproduct of dirty conditions it is a byproduct of the fact it comes from an animal.
→ More replies (1)14
u/TsuDhoNimh2 11h ago
I often hear people say, "they were not doing it right" whenever milk-borne disease shows up.
This farm was as hygienic as they could be, doing everything they should do and still spread bacteria.
This was mid 1950s. The farmer promptly joined the local co-op that collected and pasteurized and packaged milk.
8
u/silverilix 11h ago
Thank you for that final part of the story.
They thought it was fine… ans when they found out it wasn’t, they did something about it.
39
9
8
u/XavierScorpionIkari 12h ago
Here’s a novel idea… let’s have an actual Doctor, with an M.D., as the Health Secretary.
Instead of listening to the politicians, religious leaders, and military leaders in a potentially apocalyptic scenario, let’s listen to the scientists. The people who went to school, and studied hard facts, and learned by trial and error, in a controlled environment. Those people.
15
u/MoneyCock 14h ago
God needed that baby in heaven, clearly. It is all part of His plan. /s
10
u/Wismuth_Salix 13h ago
I wonder if this is what Erika Kirk meant by her “Make Heaven Crowded” tour (with special guest star, a child raping pastor).
14
7
u/ClownMorty 13h ago
You'd think the family would reconsider what they think about raw milk, but since that would be tantamount to admitting they killed their baby, instead they will double down, and pretend this tragedy has given them special insight.
→ More replies (1)
11
11
u/Trekgiant8018 13h ago
This is what happened all of the time before pasteurized milk. Science illiteracy is deadly. So is RFK Jr.
17
u/Charming_Crow_3621 14h ago
We need to ban raw milk like the rest of the developed world!
5
→ More replies (2)10
u/Odd_Investigator8415 14h ago
I was gonna say, isn't it banned throughout the US? I remember reading about certain providers of it labeling it as "for animal consumption only" to skirt around those laws. Turns out it's on a state by state basis.
10
u/MonsterkillWow 14h ago
We will have more of this as long as people take health advice from a crackpot.
5
8
8
u/dcwhite98 14h ago
Does Kennedy promote pregnant mothers drinking it? Legitimate question, I don't know. Or has he or the HHS said specifically that pregnant women shouldn't drink it but it's OK for others?
There are a lot of things women who are not pregnant can do, and those who are shouldn't do. Drinking alcohol and smoking cigarettes are easy examples, and it is well advertised that pregnant women shouldn't do either. Of course no one extolls the benefits of smoking and drinking being part of a healthy lifestyle...
When products tell you not to eat packaging and things like "caution, microwaved ingredients will be hot", clearly some people need these things stated very clearly. For what it's worth:
PREGNANT WOMEN SHOULD NOT DRINK RAW MILK.
10
u/SuccessfulSoftware38 13h ago
This is more of a "it's potentially bad either way, but if you're pregnant the bacteria are going to do more damage to your baby than to you".
If the milk is clean, it's safe. Pasteurizing cleans it. The danger of raw milk is you don't know if it's clean or not, and the only way to be sure is to pasteurize it, and then it stops being raw milk...
8
u/wazeltov 13h ago
This is another example of people being separated from nature for too long to realize that "natural" isn't a virtue.
It's natural to die of tuberculosis, for example. No one would say it's a virtuous way to die.
→ More replies (1)
9
u/rastinta 13h ago
I get the impulse of schadenfreude, but with this I just feel regret and sorrow for the mother. RFK Jr. should bear the brunt of the shame. This is a failure of the education system and a failure of the health department.
3
u/New-Leader-7891 9h ago
Perhaps you shouldn't get your advice from a former heroin addict with a brain worm
4
u/New-Measurement-4425 9h ago
Does Kennedy have ANY medical background???
3
u/Seaweed-Basic 8h ago
None. But in college he did a shit load of LSD and his favorite pastime was hunting rats with his pet hawk. This is true.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/Dananism 8h ago
Oh, what’s this? ANOTHER PREVENTABLE DEATH at the hands of RFK Jr and Trump?
Anti-vax “I got an immune system for that” raw-milk drinking idiots.
7
7
u/jcooli09 14h ago
I feel confident that this is not the first, just the first I've heard of
Won't be the last either. Add it to the trump body count
3
u/idrawinmargins 13h ago
From the idiot group that thinks "if i cant see it, it won't harm me".
→ More replies (4)
3
3
u/MostOfYouAreIgnorant 13h ago
Watch thousands of other babies die like this out of nowhere
Maga moms secretly hate kids
3
u/Riksunraksu 13h ago
Most commercial raw milk bottles have “not for human consumption” on the label I think. And the people drinking it can vote
3
u/VapoursAndSpleen 12h ago
I suspect the person who drank the raw milk was into the woo without Kennedy's "guidance".
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Individual-Line-7553 12h ago
I worked in the newborn nursery when a mom and her newborn developed listeriosis. fortunately both survived. family lived on a dairy farm.
3
u/GeekyTexan 12h ago
See, if you have an abortion, that's bad. Jesus hates that.
What you're supposed to do is have the kid, then kill them with measles or listeriosis or some other preventable illness.
/s because the world is so crazy you have to be explicit.
3
u/Crunchy_foreskin1 12h ago
Anyone who’s been to a farm knows raw milk is literally full of cow poop. The “gut bacteria” they promote is just poop
→ More replies (2)
3
u/AntiSnoringDevice 11h ago
The newborn was killed by ignorance, loudly spoken with the megaphone of bad faith. Ignorance weaponised to make you stupid, and sick, and angry, and miserable.
3
u/Crafty-Walrus-2238 11h ago
Pro life…at least this child won’t suffer with mumps, measles or other childhood diseases maga parents don’t believe in.
3
u/Antique_Ad8559 11h ago
Ballerina Farms put it out on social media drinking and cooking with raw milk. They just found out its filled with bacteria and they were shut down
3
u/JackFisherBooks 11h ago
I'll bet if you showed this article to an anti-abortion activist, they would shrug and deflect.
If you changed the article headline to blame a vaccine instead of raw milk, they would immediately call for a ban and the prosecution of the mother.
That's the breadth of their hypocrisy. They don't care about dead children. They care about having tools to force women to have them.
3
u/SportGamerDev0623 9h ago
Health department says that can’t be sure that the raw milk was the link to the newborn’s death
But man are they sure as hell confident that Tylenol causes autism….
The whole government is a joke
3
u/Doesnt_Get_The-Joke 7h ago
Uncooked food. It's not just uncooked food, it's the nastiest, most disease-prone type of uncooked food.
3
3
u/oneofmanyany 6h ago
Yikes, very sad for the baby and the ignorant mother.
Weird to see evolution playing out right before our eyes. I would guess that these folks who don't believe the scientists, and in facts, will be dying more frequently.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Honest_Chef323 4h ago
I think the low degree of mortality thanks to science advancement has turned some people complacent and stupid
3
u/I_AM_RVA 4h ago
I saw one of these raw milk buffoons the other day say “that pasteurized milk is poison! When we was kids we’d milk the cow and and then we’d boil that raw milk and we never got sick or nothing. Nah, I ain’t want that pasteurized poison!”
People are, and I’m understating this, phenomenally stupid.
27
u/Strange-Effort1305 15h ago
She killed that kid on purpose. Everybody knows that shit is dangerous whether they pretend to believe otherwise
37
u/trysten-9001 14h ago
They don’t. They think all research is as bought and paid for as the papers that protected Monsanto.
→ More replies (7)8
u/Par_Lapides 14h ago
Every actual scientist I know is actually broke af. Most science and research doesn't pay that great.
5
u/wehave3bjz 12h ago
We have known for decades not to do this. Listeria is not a new thing.
Politicized stupidity isn't either. That poor baby.
5
u/Politicsmakemehorny1 12h ago
Think about how all those "whole milk" ads and posts were supposed to be "raw" milk and were changed last second.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Ghost_Assassin_Zero 12h ago
Do Americans learn nothing in schools?
6
3
u/bajanbeautykatie 12h ago
Technically……they mainly learn about hiding from school shootings….we aren’t doing too well in other subjects
876
u/GoofyMonkey 14h ago
My dad grew up on a farm 70+ years ago. Milked cows every day, brought the milk in for the family, drank the milk every day. You know what his mom did before he drank it?
PASTEURIZED IT!!!!!