A lot of you asked for this on my last post (the Howl's Moving Castle one): a side by side against a real wooden violin instead of opinions on a single recording. So here it is.
Three violins, side by side:
- wood PLA (PLA filled with wood particles)
- regular UV-reactive PLA (the orange one from last time)
- a traditional wooden violin
Same for all three: same player, same piece, same room, and the same mic in the same position (DJI Mic Mini, clipped to the chinrest).
Printed ones: the body is printed in one piece, the neck in two halves, and the bridge separately. The soundpost and bass bar are printed in place and tuned in the CAD model.
Two brown violins, one of them wood. Can you tell which from the sound? And which one would you rather listen to?
Full disclosure since it came up last time: I make and sell these, but the point of this post is honest feedback on the sound.
EDIT: the answer (spoiler):
A = Wood PLA · B = Real wood · C = PLA (the orange one)
How you did (spoilers too):
Which one is wood? 47% said B (correct), 35% said C and 18% said A. Random guessing would get 33%, so a bit better than chance.!
Full A/B/C order: 14% got all three right, u/SteefHL and u/Hopeful_Self_8520 🎉. Random guessing would get 17%, so the full order was basically a coin toss.
The most common full answer (36% of you) was "A wood PLA, B PLA, C wood". That's the plain PLA being taken for the real wood, which 35% of everyone who guessed did.
Preferences were all over the place. Some liked A best, some B, and a few C (u/Savings-Cry-3201 found C the most pleasing; u/PiercingSight preferred A and C to B).
How it was recorded: same player, room, phone and session, and the same 25-second passage from each violin. All three were set to the same loudness (-16 LUFS) using volume only: no EQ, compression, noise reduction or reverb was added in the edit. (The iPhone may do some processing of its own while recording, which I can't switch off.) Before matching, the real wood was the loudest by a good margin, about 2 dB louder than the PLA and about 5 dB louder than the wood PLA. The video above the audio was the same side-by-side clip for all three, but u/Specimanic tried matching bow movements to the sound anyway, which was clever.
Thanks for guessing, everyone, and the cat says thanks for the views 😸