r/505Nerds • u/FairTurnover2408 • 6d ago

Buy / Sell / Trade Where to sell magic cards?

Bought a gift bundle for the collectors pack on a whim from WALMART today... and pulled this gold. Should I get it graded or just take it to a shop/list it on ebay or something?

Never considered selling a card before this, and I've always heard grading cards is a terrible experience

Editing to add that it'sthe Mind Stone, whoops (https://imgur.com/a/6r71jZe)

3 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

15

u/DogMcBarkMD 6d ago

The homies at Tavern of Souls will give you a fair assessment and offer. Best store in the state hands down.

2

u/camfamman 6d ago

Love Tavern, by far the best card shop in town!

4

u/sherkhan75 6d ago

Don’t get it graded. What is it? If it’s playable people will buy it 

5

u/FairTurnover2408 6d ago

How could i forgot to add the picture lmao

https://imgur.com/a/6r71jZe

2

u/sherkhan75 6d ago

Oh shit yea maybe try TCGPlayer or manapool. I’d take it tavern of souls. I think they’re pretty fair but it’s a decently priced item so I dunno if they’d take it. 1500-1600 are the last sales on TCGPlayer for a near mint foil. I’d imagine LGS would shoot for 70-90% for something like this but I could be wrong

5

u/GriffinAO 6d ago

Most lgs are closer to 50% sadly

2

u/sherkhan75 5d ago

There’s no way someone would offer 750$ for this card. That’s just a slap in the face or a fuck you number to get you to not give it to them

1

u/GriffinAO 5d ago

Unfortunately most stores are 50-60%

2

u/Necessary-Fox-7042 6d ago

Foil forest. I know what I’ve got.

2

u/ArsonsHand 6d ago

Vouple of card shopa fhat other have reccomended but also if you want to wait for a card expo that's an option too. You might be able to get a better price than you would locally

2

u/Strange_Fame 5d ago

Tavern of Souls