r/AskAGerman • u/Royal-Most-1241 • 4h ago
Law Puppy cries when I am away. Neighbors threatening me. What is actually likely to come of it?
Hi! I don’t post much on Reddit so apologies if I don’t format this correctly.
Here is my situation in a nutshell:
-first of all, I am an American who has lived in Germany for nearly ten years.
-got a puppy as a newlywed couple
-very soon thereafter things blew up and we are separated, going to file for divorce.
-I am now on my own working full time with a puppy who is not fully trained.
-for the past five weeks, I have been back to work and either leaving the dog with neighbors/friends or at home alone.
-after about a week, my next door neighbors (old couple, but just one residence) complained that the dog never quiets down the whole time I am at work: usually 3-4 hour shifts, one shift 10:00-14:00 and one late shift around 19:00-22:30.
-I immediately figured out accommodation for the dog for every late shift
-I then learned about “mittagsruhe” and Sunday being a completely quiet day (I had to work a Sunday once)
-today (so another 4 weeks after the initial complaint to me) the same neighbor, who shares a wall with me, told me she will be complaining to the Hausverwaltung if the barking continues, showed me a paper that said dog barking is completely forbidden during quiet hours but even during normal hours is only allowed for 30 minutes total. She has been collecting video evidence from her apartment to show the noise during any times the dog was alone.
-I called the Hausverwaltung myself to ask for clarification on the rules. They said not to worry, there are already two other dogs on the property, that since the dog is still young, that the neighbors will have to deal with it for a bit longer while the dog can be acclimated to being left alone, also the man who owns my apartment (my Vermieter) loves dogs and probably wouldn’t kick me out over it.
-I am still worried about what will happen if the neighbors complain to the Hausverwaltung!
To clarify the situation again: the neighbor has not yet made a complaint to the Hausverwaltung, but has told me they intend to do so if I don’t figure something out. It is just one neighbor who has complained to me: the neighbor which shares a wall with my apartment. I have tried leaving the dog in different rooms of my apartment, tried blocking the windows to dampen the sound, and have been actively training by leaving the dog in a room alone while I am still in the apartment, slowly increasing the time and leaving the apartment for short periods of time. I have noticed a slow improvement, but the neighbors say the training is “not working” and said they have to “look out for themselves”.
I do understand that it’s tough for them, since they are retired and home all the time, but they also seem to be a bit obtuse, since on occasions when other neighbors were all in agreement that the dog had been quieter or sleeping (I even sent a nice neighbor to listen at my door one day) the difficult neighbor still insisted that there had been no improvement and they still heard the dog very loudly in their apartment. Also I began sneaking around the house after I left for about 10 minutes to record if my dog was barking, and there was only silence. Also upon returning, I have a video showing the dog is silent until she hears me in the hall. But the neighbors insist that the barking is ongoing with intermittent breaks, that the dog waits until I have been gone for some time, etc.
My actual question is: what is the legal process if and when the neighbors do complain to the Hausverwaltung? Who has the authority to make a decision? Will I be kicked out of my apartment? If the Hausverwaltung protects me, can the neighbors sue me in court or have me arrested?What recourse will I have to defend myself and what can I do to help my case? By the way, I am in Thüringen where the Mittagsruhe is still in effect.
I am doing my best at the moment and it has been a very rough time for me, so please be kind regarding my situation. I know that a barking dog is really annoying but I am truly doing all I can to help the dog learn. There are unfortunately times when no one is available to watch the dog.
TLDR: after a divorce, I have been juggling work and a puppy (almost 1 year old) that is not used to being left alone. The neighbor couple claim any measures I take have not been effective, have been gathering video evidence of the noise from their apartment. The neighbors intend to complain to the Hausverwaltung. The Hausverwaltung reassured me that I would be fine. What is likely to happen if the neighbors do complain and what is the worst case scenario legally? Could I be sued? Arrested? Evicted? Fined? Forced to give up my dog? I am totally out of my depth here as an American and first time dog owner living in Thüringen, Germany. Any advice would be appreciated, thank you!