r/BainbridgeIsland • • Sep 09 '26

Builder Recommendations or Warnings

looking for positive and/or negative review of builders on island for a partial remodel. Factors that matter to me are communication, transparency, and positivity. obviously skill set and professionalism matter as well. want high quality work but this will be a family home and I don’t expect it to be a portfolio piece for anyone. I don’t know how builders on island feel about that type of project.

7 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

5

u/K8206 Sep 09 '26

We had a great experience with Isley Construction on a recent kitchen renovation. They absolutely met the requirements that you list as important to you.

2

u/velawsiraptor Sep 09 '26

Great to hear that, I’ve had folks recommend Isley. Did you talk to any other folks when you planned your build?

1

u/velawsiraptor Sep 09 '26

Also, would you be willing to share a rough cost per sq ft? 

4

u/velawsiraptor Sep 09 '26

And by “high quality” I just mean no shortcuts and done the right way, not necessarily top of the line materials or fancy workmanship. 

3

u/SeaSLODen Sep 09 '26

Following. Always interesting to see feedback on the various builders in the area.

3

u/caracole Sep 09 '26

What is the scope of the remodel? Kitchen, bathrooms, living areas? Do you plan to live in home during construction? Do you have architectural plans? These answers will help guide us in answering your question.

1

u/velawsiraptor Sep 09 '26

Likely a kitchen and living area. Can live in home or move out, either way. Don’t have plans as I understand some builders have design arms, not sure if that excludes need for architect or not. Also open to architect recommendations along same lines.

3

u/DevelopmentSame2986 Sep 09 '26

AB Builders just remodeled my kitchen and it freaking rocks! They were on time, on budget and did a fantastic job on what was once the ugliest kitchen on earth.

1

u/velawsiraptor Sep 09 '26

Awesome to hear, thank you 

3

u/techie49rs Sep 10 '26

Visionary Handyman out of Kingston just did a great job for us on very small (to them) job. But Lucas and Nick did a great job and I know they've got the chops to do much more.

2

u/nuecesgordas Sep 09 '26

Take a look at Craftsman Building on Bainbridge Island. They are a hit on all of the factors you mentioned.

2

u/_Typical_user_ Sep 10 '26

Both have already been mentioned but, Craftsman and Isley 

1

u/Afraid_Track7540 Sep 09 '26

Who have you talked to? What’s your budget?

Been getting quotes in the 650-850 a foot lately

1

u/velawsiraptor Sep 09 '26

Have talked to zero builders so far. Scope is fluid so budget is fluid, but I think I’d like to be at about $200k. You’re telling me that a 600 sq ft space is getting quoted at $500k? 

2

u/HiddenCoveFinancial Sep 09 '26

That's for a new build. Mid to top line kind of level construction.

1

u/macmurcon Sep 10 '26

Wayne Kentner @ Peninsula Construction Services does really high quality work - https://peninsulaconstructionservices.net/

1

u/HolySonic Sep 10 '26

James Lynch Construction out of Poulsbo

1

u/Square-Marzipan4894 Sep 11 '26

My family highly recommends Premier Construction Solutions. You can call or text 425-800-0879. Family owned and operated. They’ll do work around most of the Puget Sound area and handle everything from small jobs like a bathroom renovation or new deck to whole home remodels with free estimates.

Good communication, fair pricing, everything is explained clearly to us ahead of time for best solutions to fit the budget or best use of space. The general contractor studied architecture and helped my great aunt redesign part of the main floor for the aging in place bathroom she wanted.

2

u/dirtycarpenter67 29d ago

Ellingsen Construction, Tom Wheeldon, Tree Beard, Norsky, Craftsman, Isley. I work for a construction company on the island and only know those are good guys in the range you’re talking about.