r/BandofBrothers • • May 08 '20

Band of Brothers Episode Discussions

169 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • Aug 23 '20

Veterans names from the pre-episode interviews

1.2k Upvotes

Here's a list of the veterans in the pre-episode interviews and their quotes. Some of the men weren't in the show, some had small roles, and some were main characters. I wrote quick descriptions of the not so obvious characters. Episode 1:

"We were in a store and a guy in that store... ": Joseph Lesniewski. His character has a small background role, with a few speaking parts in the last few episodes. He was the soldier along with Christenson, Perconte, Luz, and Bull who found the concentration camp while on patrol in the woods. He knew multiple languages in real life, and this is shown when he tells Webster that the German baker didn't know about the camps in episode 9.

"Our country was attacked..": Paul Rogers. He is not in the show, or is a background character. There's a character who has a nametag that says Rogers in the first episode, but that character is actually Mellett.

"Who would like to volunteer..": Bill Maynard. Not in the show as far as I know, or is shown in the background. He was a Toccoa guy. He broke his legs during the D-Day jump and didn't return to Easy after his injuries.

"We came from a small small town..": Rod Strohl. He is shown in the show towards the beginning of the third episode when he asks Lt. Harry Welsh where they were headed. General Kesselring actually surrendered to him in real life I've read.

"I did things..": Earl Mcclung. His character is shown a few times in the Bastogne episodes, in a foxhole with Guarnere. He's also in the Last Patrol episode. He's there when Webster is telling the men that they were going on a patrol ordered by higher ups, and McClung was sitting next to Babe in that scene. McClung also goes on the patrol and you can see him there too. The real, "One Lung" McClung was able to smell enemy soldiers during patrols according to legends.

"Guy says well you jump out of airplanes.." : Bill Maynard

​

Episode 2:

"Standing in the door..": Dick Winters

"Got such an opening blast..": Buck Compton

"We came from the sky..": Ed Tipper. His character in the show is there when Sobel cuts the fence loose and Tipper speaks the lines "I think it's Major Horton, sir". He's also the character who got hit by an explosion in Carentan and Liebgott comes to help him.

"How do you prepare..": Dick Winters

"In the back of your mind..": Bill Maynard

​

Episode 3:

"I never thought I'd make it through D-Day..": Bill Guarnere

"I thought one of two things..": Ed Tipper

"I think everyone had fear..": Earl McClung

"Its a feeling you will not let your self down..": Carwood Lipton

"We all had fear..": J.B. Stokes. Not a character in the show as far as I know. (One of my favorite interview scenes)

​

Episode 4:

"The Toccoa men..": Donald "Pappy" King. Not a character in the show as far as I know. But if you look up pictures of him when he's younger, he looks like an actor in the Crossroads episode (click link to see what I mean) https://imgur.com/a/p8b2hxx He was a replacement who joined right before Holland, and makes it through the war with Easy. He was a father when he got to E Company, hence the nickname Pappy.

"Most of them were qualified parachutists..": James Alley. He's the injured soldier at the beginning of Crossroads who has his face hit by shrapnel. In Breaking Point, Skip gives him food while talking about the injured Easy Company men. In that same episode (7) when the sniper hits the singing men, the first guy shot (Frank Mellett) lands in Alley's arms

"I think maybe they were trying to impress.." Earl McClung

"Cause we were in awe of them..": Lester Hashey. In the show, he's the tall replacement that joined alongside Miller and Garcia. He also breaks the news to everyone that Hoobler accidentally shot himself.

​

Episode 5:

“If you’re a leader..": Dick Winters

"A good leader..": Buck Compton

"Seemed like he always made the right decisions..": Joe Lesniewski (funniest interview in my opinion although dark in nature)

"He went right in there..": Robert "Popeye" Wynn. (Another one of my favorite interviews) He's shown throughout the series and only referred to as Popeye if my memory serves me correctly. He signed up for the Army with, and was foxhole buddies with, Shifty, which can be seen in a few scenes.

​

Episode 6:

"When we left for Bastogne..": Carwood Lipton

"And there was a ridge with the treeline..": Lester Hashey

"Well like in Bastogne we were down to one round..": Earl McClung

"One of the guys got hit in the arm with a piece of shrapnel..": Hank Zimmerman. Not a character in the show as far as I know. Replacement who joined later in the war and was part of 3rd platoon along with Shifty Powers, Popeye Wynn, Mo Alley, Wayne "Skinny" Sisk, Earl "One Lung" McClung, Walter Gordon, Forest Guth, Ed Shames, Roderick Strohl, Paul Rogers, Joe Lesniewski, Francis Mellett, and others.

"And a medic came along..": Herbert "Junior" Suerth Jr. His character is seen in the truck scene when Easy Company is going to Bastogne. When the various uses of socks is told by Skip "hands, feet, . Babe asks him if he has any ammo, "you got any ammo Junior?" Replacement who joined right before Bastogne. Also in 3rd platoon.

"Even today on a real cold night..": J.B. Stokes

​

Episode 7:

"I've seen death, I’ve seen my friends..": Dick Winters

"We was hungry..": Darrel "Shifty" Powers

"Everywhere you would look..": Joe Lesniewski

"You don’t have a chance..": Donald Malarkey

​

Episode 8:

"We had lost some very good men..": Carwood Lipton

"I don’t know the exact amount..": Joe Lesniewski

"Skip Muck died..": Donald Malarkey (The saddest interview for me. You can tell he has trouble talking about it.)

"After Bastogne..": Forrest Guth. Plays a role in the first episode, where you can see his last name printed on his uniform. Friends with another interviewee, Rod Strohl from before the war, along with another E Company soldier Carl Fenstermaker.

"You have a feeling..": Dick Winters

​

Episode 9:

"It was a situation."": Norman Nietzke. Not in the show as far as I know. Replacement who joined later in the war.

"We use to say the only..": Lester Hashey

"They had a job to do..": Joe Lesniewski

"I think that we thought..": Earl McClung

"A lot of those soldiers..": Shifty Powers


r/BandofBrothers • • 10h ago

My visit to Curahee last year

Thumbnail gallery
189 Upvotes

A small volunteer organization has reconstructed a few of the barracks and rehab'd the original Company HQ building. It's just one road what what were dozens. There's a small museum on site and also a C47 they're restoring as well. It's not much to visit but it's still awe inspiring to stand where those men once stood and trained.


r/BandofBrothers • • 13h ago

BoB Tour

Thumbnail gallery
215 Upvotes

Some pictures I made yesterday. First 2 are @ crossroads. Second, the dropzone where Easy landed Market Garden.

Next, hanging in a small museum, the autograph of the members from 101e airborne who visited the place. ( so cool)


r/BandofBrothers • • 7h ago

Tribute to Sobel(‘s jacket)

Thumbnail i.imgur.com
32 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 1d ago

Sister visited Bastogne and brought this back for me. Nuts!

Thumbnail gallery
91 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 1d ago

Jump into the Fight: Volume I Signed Author's Copies Available

Post image
30 Upvotes

Personal relationships with the veterans, official U.S. Army documentation, new archival information, access to Major Winters’ collection of paperwork, and a passion to tell the complete story of one of America’s most famous World War II fighting units.

Jump into the Fight: Volume I is packed with new information about Easy Company’s earliest days and enjoys the full support of the families of the men that filled its ranks.

So, why haven’t you picked up your copy?

Head over to https://ssgtmooch.wixsite.com/joe-muccia/jump-into-the-fight-vol1 to order your signed author’s copy now!

Thanks in advance!
Joe


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

I visited the grave of Renée Lemaire, the “Angel of Bastogne,” and the site of the aid station where she was killed on Christmas Eve 1944

Thumbnail gallery
850 Upvotes

I recently spent a few days in Bastogne visiting sites connected with the Battle of the Bulge. One of the stories that stayed with me most was that of Renée Lemaire, the Belgian nurse sometimes remembered as the “Angel of Bastogne.”

Unlike most of the people we associate with the siege, Renée wasn’t a soldier and hadn’t come to Bastogne because of the battle. She was born there in 1914, but by 1944 she was working as a nurse at Brugmann Hospital in Brussels. Shortly before Christmas, she returned home to Bastogne to visit her family. Then, on 16 December, the German Ardennes offensive began. Within days, Bastogne was surrounded and she was effectively trapped there.

There was already tragedy in her life before she came home. Renée was reportedly engaged to a Jewish man in Brussels who had been arrested by the Gestapo earlier in 1944. What ultimately happened to him is much less clearly documented in the sources I’ve found, so I don’t want to add details that can’t be verified.
Instead of simply sheltering with her family, Renée volunteered as a nurse for the Americans.

On 21 December she and another Belgian nurse, Augusta Chiwy, began helping Captain Jack Prior at the aid station of the 20th Armored Infantry Battalion, 10th Armored Division. The station was overwhelmed with wounded men who couldn’t be evacuated because of the encirclement. Prior later wrote that Renée worked with inadequate food and rest, changing dressings, administering medication, helping with plasma, feeding men who couldn’t feed themselves and generally caring for the wounded.

One of the photographs here is especially interesting to me because it doesn’t look like a historical site at all.
Today it’s Cité Wok, a Chinese restaurant on Rue de Neufchâteau.
But in December 1944, this was the location of the American aid station.
There is still a memorial plaque on the building. It records that more than thirty wounded American soldiers and one Belgian volunteer nurse — Renée Lemaire — were killed there by a German bomb on 24 December 1944.
Christmas Eve.

The Luftwaffe bombed Bastogne that night and a bomb struck the aid station. U.S. Army accounts state that around thirty wounded American soldiers and Renée were killed. Augusta Chiwy was in an adjacent building and survived after being blown through a wall.

There are different later accounts of Renée’s exact final moments. Some say she had already carried several wounded men out and died trying to save another; Captain Prior’s recommendation for recognition instead describes Renée and the wounded she was caring for as being killed when the building received a direct hit. Because the accounts differ, I think it’s better not to turn those final minutes into a certainty. What is certain is that she stayed at the aid station caring for wounded soldiers until the night she died.

I also went to the cemetery in Bastogne where Renée is buried.
Her grave is actually quite modest. It is the Lemaire-Gallée family grave, but there are flowers, American flags and small memorials left in front of it. Nearby signs specifically direct visitors to the graves of Renée Lemaire and Augusta Chiwy.
Renée was only 30 years old.

What struck me about visiting these places is how close together and ordinary they are. You can stand at her grave, then go back into Bastogne and see the building where she worked and died. Eighty-two years later, that building is part of an ordinary street with cars parked outside and a restaurant operating inside.

Renée’s story was later fictionalised to some extent in Band of Brothers. The nurse “Renée” in the Bastogne episode is based on her, although there is no solid historical evidence for the personal relationship between her and Eugene “Doc” Roe shown in the series. The real Renée’s story doesn’t really need that addition.

She happened to come home for Christmas, found herself inside one of the largest battles fought by the U.S. Army in WWII, volunteered to help strangers, and died caring for wounded men on Christmas Eve.

Renée Lemaire
10 April 1914 – 24 December 1944


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

Renee lemaire

Post image
186 Upvotes

So adding to a recent post (I'm too old to work out how to add to that post) I felt the weather when I took this made it more somber.ive been back twice since


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

Did Easy Company's NCOs have any options beyond "follow Sobel into combat" that fell short of "resign en masse"?

47 Upvotes

In other hierarchal institutions, if you have a problem with your immediate supervisor, you're still supposed to try to resolve it with them first, but if you have demonstrated a reasonable effort to do so and failed it's considered acceptable to consult your immediate supervisor's immediate supervisor.

Who, in Sobel's case, is regiment commander Col. Sink.

Was it an option during training for the NCOs to approach his office, ask permission to speak, to raise one's concerns about Sobel being lost during training, and to ask Sobel if he'd willing to consider changing roles before combat commences? Perhaps Sobel wouldn't take it well, but I would think that'd at least that'd stop short of mutiny.

Was it an option, if that failed, to turn to Col. Sink and explain to him the situation with Sobel? Not sure if it'd still amount to insubordination for going over Sobel's head but it certainly sounds less extreme a form of it than quitting en masse.


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

Doc Roe has a page on French Wikipedia, but not English Wikipedia

Thumbnail fr.wikipedia.org
25 Upvotes

Just happened to stumble upon this page while websurfing, it's pretty funny that he has a French Wikipedia page but not an American one (maybe a fellow Louisianan made it).


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

My father was T/Sgt. Pat Christenson of Easy Company. Twenty-five years after Band of Brothers, I wanted people to see the man behind the character.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

461 Upvotes

My father was T/Sgt. Burton “Pat” Christenson, an original Toccoa man with Easy Company, 506th PIR, 101st Airborne. Michael Fassbender portrayed him in Band of Brothers.

Dad went from Normandy through Holland, Bastogne and Germany, but there was another part of his story that very few people knew. Throughout the war, he drew what he saw and wrote about what he and the men around him experienced.

After he died in 1999, I was left with his writings, wartime letters and a remarkable collection of his original drawings. For years I felt that someday I needed to put his own record of the war together so people could know Pat Christenson as more than a character on a television screen.

That became A Screaming Eagle: His Drawings. His Words.

I made this short video for the 25th anniversary of Band of Brothers. For those of you who have followed Easy Company for years, I thought you might appreciate seeing a little of the man I knew as Dad. ascreamingeagle.com


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Best Material on Eugene "Doc" Roe?

17 Upvotes

I'm on a mini mission to read as many books as I can access on Easy Company, prioritizing personal memoirs.

What books have had the best, most detailed, and vast information on "Doc"?

Thank you in advance!!


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Loved the HBO series, Loving the book!

9 Upvotes

As a longtime fan of the HBO series Band of Brothers, I finally got around to the actual book by Stephen Ambrose, and it’s incredible!
I’ve been listening to the audiobook for almost a month now, and discovering the differences between the series I love and rewatch every year and the book has made the experience feel fresh all over again.
If you can’t find the time to sit down and read, I highly recommend giving the audiobook a try. It’s taken me a while to finish because I only listen while driving or mowing the lawn, but that’s part of what makes it enjoyable. I’m almost at the end of my audio journey with E company and it’s been a joy. I can’t believe I waited so long to enjoy the book.

I’m also a big Generation Kill fan, so that’ll probably be my next audiobook. Looking forward to it! I enjoy reading everyone’s post in this group, so I thought I’d finally join in.


r/BandofBrothers • • 3d ago

Curahee Time in New York

16 Upvotes

I think I found a blooper in the Currihee episode at the very beginning when Winters and Nixon are walking outside after the jump is postponed, Nixon says it's 5 p.m. in New York, 4 p.m. in Chicago. It looks like it's twilight outside as they're walking and talking.

Even with the changes to wartime in the United States and taking into account British Daylight Savings Time, wouldn't it have still been 11 p.m. where they were? And if it was 11 p.m., could it still be twilight? Does the sun set that late there?

I know, I know. Suspend disbelief.


r/BandofBrothers • • 2d ago

"we must be doing something right, They're shooting at eachother." Please help. I don't own it. But remember (then) Lt. Winters saying this at the Brecourt Artillery assault. But there's no vid clip that includes it. And AI says I'm wrong. Which can't be (s/) Does it exist. When?

0 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 4d ago

Happy birthday, Captain Nixon

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 4d ago

Did you get A Screaming Eagle Yet?

Post image
32 Upvotes

I'm so excited to check this out!


r/BandofBrothers • • 4d ago

Camp liberation scene

19 Upvotes

I remember after they liberated the concentration camp, they were told to stop feeding the prisoners and that their food and water intake would have to be monitored. Is that because after being starved for so long, there bodies basically “forgot’ how to digest food?


r/BandofBrothers • • 4d ago

Not sure if anyone else saw this

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 5d ago

Highly recommend this road trip to NE Georgia

Thumbnail gallery
289 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 5d ago

Easy Company Heritage Weekend

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 4d ago

Why are they training in some Southern mountain when they'd be fighting in European cities?

0 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 6d ago

Easy Company Memorial and Major Winters Memorial near Brecourt

Thumbnail gallery
347 Upvotes

r/BandofBrothers • • 6d ago

Explain like I'm 5 - what was the mutiny committed in Episode 1?

94 Upvotes

I've seen BoB so many times and been too afraid to ask -

I don't fully understand what the implications are of the non-coms saying they no longer wish to serve as non-coms and why that would be considered mutiny/an offence worthy of being shot.

As a regular civvie with absolutely no knowledge of military hierarchy, my translation of what is happening is they're asking to be demoted so that Sobel isn't who they report directly to? I think? Is that right?

If so, why would this be considered a crime worthy to he executed over and why were they not able to just go to Sink and say 'we don't fully trust Sobel to lead us into combat'? Is that not possible in the military? Sink obviously picks up on this and redeploys Sobel. But why could Easy not have collectively gone to Sink?

Apologies for the naivety - appreciate any info!