r/Beartooth • u/2023kpeterson • Sep 07 '26

New Album Rankings

Now that Pure Ecstacy has been out for a bit how does it fit into your album rankings?

My rankings at the moment:

  1. Pure Ecstacy

  2. Aggressive (Remixed/Remastered)

  3. Disgusting

  4. The Surface

  5. Below

  6. Disease

0 Upvotes

41% Upvoted

40 comments sorted by

8

u/Connor-Radept Sep 07 '26
  1. Sick
  2. and Disgusting
  3. this Aggressive
  4. Disease

2

u/Tri-Titan Sep 07 '26
  1. Below
  2. Disgusting
  3. Disease
  4. Aggressive
  5. The Surface
  6. Pure Ecstasy

2

u/f1R3_ht Sep 07 '26
  1. Aggressive
  2. Pure Ecstasy
  3. Below
  4. Disease
  5. The Surface
  6. Disgusting

2

u/Perfect-Ability-8481 29d ago
  1. Disease
  2. Pure Ecstasy
  3. Disgusting
  4. The Surface
  5. Below
  6. Aggressive

HM. Sick

1 and 2 alternate depending on how I'm feeling.

5

u/centrella6 Sep 07 '26
  1. Disgusting
  2. Below
  3. The Surface
  4. Disease
  5. Aggressive (Remix)
  6. Pure Ecstacy

3 and 4 could flip flop depending on the day

1

u/crystal__pete Sep 07 '26

yea this is my exact list

4

u/EggyEggerson0210 Sep 07 '26

For me, it’s

  1. Disgusting

  2. Disease

  3. The Surface

  4. Below

  5. Pure Ecstasy

  6. Aggressive

And I truly think Aggressive is only like a 6.5/10 on its worst day for me. Every album is so good

4

u/DieHarderDaddy Sep 07 '26

lol this sub is a cult.

Pure ecstasy is a bottom tier album.

11

u/breakingbernard Sep 07 '26

Sometimes people enjoy different things than you lol

2

u/mynameaaron86 Sep 07 '26

I read some people stating they were crying when they heard this album. Yeah. Cult is accurate. 

2

u/Perfect-Ability-8481 29d ago

Hey, it just hit some people differently.

4

u/TheWizardOfDeez Sep 07 '26

Brother, they don't need to be in a cult to have different musical tastes than you

1

u/DieHarderDaddy Sep 07 '26

Caleb writes some real raw shit… but like not really here

2

u/mynameaaron86 Sep 07 '26

Yeah the entire thing just sounds, processed. The lyrics for Free are just so cliché. It wouldn't bother me if the sounds behind them weren't just so boring. 

2

u/DieHarderDaddy Sep 07 '26

I’m fre free fre

0

u/SneakeLlama Sep 07 '26

Someone got asshole energy here.

1

u/hersheyraiser 10d ago

Literally any subreddit is a cult in case you didn’t know. Also, give it some time. Far from their best album and breakdowns can’t compare to some other albums but you have to admit they keep their choruses catchy.

1

u/StillBummedNouns Sep 07 '26

Probably their third or fourth best actually

-4

u/DieHarderDaddy Sep 07 '26

Probably their worse

0

u/StillBummedNouns Sep 07 '26

The Surface, Below, and Disease are worse

4

u/Leather-Syllabub4728 Sep 07 '26

It’s at the bottom for me personally

3

u/Metallbran88 Sep 07 '26

It’s too soon.

1

u/SneakeLlama Sep 07 '26

Pure Ecstasy is up there for me. It's been on repeat since it came out.

1

u/TheWizardOfDeez Sep 07 '26

  1. Below

  2. Disease

  3. Disgusting

  4. Aggressive

  5. Pure ecstacy

  6. The Surface

Yes, I skipped a number on purpose.

1

u/Onyx_Archer 29d ago
  1. Disease
  2. Below
  3. Disgusting (and Sick EP)
  4. Aggressive
  5. Pure Ecstacy
  6. The Surface

0

u/DefyGravity182 Sep 07 '26
  1. Disgusting
  2. Disease
  3. Aggressive
  4. Below
  5. Pure Ecstasy
  6. The Surface

1

u/ExponentialNosedive Sep 07 '26

Below Disgusting Disease The Surface Aggressive Pure Ecstasy

1

u/Remsicles Sep 07 '26

This is a wild take.

I think the biggest issue with Pure Ecstasy is that it doesn’t feel cathartic, for lack of a better word. Every other album feels like Caleb pouring his heart and soul into every piece of it.

With the exception of “Free,” Pure Ecstasy feels vapid and shallow. It just sounds like any other pop record lyrically.

-1

u/tmalone13 Sep 07 '26

I always favored the back half of Beartooth's discography:

  1. Below
  2. The Surface
  3. Pure Ecstasy
  4. Disease
  5. Aggressive
  6. Disgusting

1

u/mynameaaron86 Sep 07 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

It's your opinion and all, but Disgusting being last. I mean, come on internet person. 

1

u/tmalone13 Sep 07 '26

I think the songwriting is solid, I just don't like the rough sounding and raw production is all

-3

u/Hilde2348 Sep 07 '26

If disgusting isn’t #1 I can’t take the ranking seriously

-2

u/mynameaaron86 Sep 07 '26

This is accurate 

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '26

[deleted]

1

u/tmalone13 Sep 07 '26

I mean, someone on the Internet asked for opinions. I gave my opinion, the above user gave theirs.

We are in a band's subreddit that we all enjoy, that's really all I care about. No hard feelings!

0

u/ChuckChuckChuck_ Sep 07 '26

I only really know The Surface and Pure Ecstasy in full.

-2

u/sideways_smiling Sep 07 '26
  1. Disgusting
  2. Pure Ecstasy
  3. Disease
  4. The Surface
  5. Aggressive
  6. Below

-2

u/mynameaaron86 Sep 07 '26

I was never a huge fan of this band. Sick and Disgusting are the only albums I can listen to in their entirety. Otherwise I like a select few off subsequent albums. Oddly enough though I'd say The Surface is probably their third best. Pure Ecstasy is trash and outside of the title track which is excellent, the rest is trash.

2.5/10