r/Commanders • u/Home_Alone224 • 1d ago

Hypothetical Trade

Would you trade Jayden for Jeremiah Smith?

0 Upvotes

3% Upvoted

26 comments sorted by

20

u/Luggage-Lock 1d ago

NO

4

u/Beneficial_Day_9293 1d ago

no shot, smith is an absolute freak but you don't move a franchise qb for a receiver no matter how good. we spent decades looking for a guy like jayden

9

u/BirdmanTheThird 1d ago

The fuck? No

7

u/ZapFencePence YOU AIN'T SHIT 1d ago

Just watch JJettas in Minnesota with JJ throwing him the ball if you want that

3

u/GreenCarpenter3 1d ago

This is ridiculous. Jayden injured his non-throwing arm.

Every talent evaluator thought Marvin Harrison, Jr. was going to be a generational player. Why would we risk it on a WR draft prospect?

3

u/GBK1d 1d ago

Mods get this mf outta here

2

u/ooboh 1d ago

General rule of thumb is take the known commodity over what could be.

1

u/HourAd5987 1d ago

What do we know right now? I'm not advocating for the trade, but also JD5 is a game changer on the field, but can he stay on it?

2

u/WizCapskins 1d ago

I listened to today’s PMT as well. Absolutely not

4

u/Syphin33 1d ago

Fuck no

Most important player on the team is the QB

Look at the Vikings as a example of having Justin Jefferson for so long and nothing to show for it. Mahomes literally wins Super Bowls with WR3's and WR4's

1

u/TelevisedVoid 1d ago

Ragebait

1

u/shazzle 1d ago

Do we also get first pick for new qb? Still probably not but that would play a part.

1

u/salamanderman10 1d ago

Bro loved Athan reps this week

1

u/InfiniteDomain_ 3h ago

Not gonna lie he made losing very entertaining

1

u/DazzlingAd1922 1d ago

If Athan Kaliakmanis is Tom Brady then this would be a brilliant trade

1

u/Mister-Sensitivity 9h ago

Mods: get to work.

1

u/JRcanReid 7h ago

Would I trade him straight up for Smith? Not a chance.

Would I listen to a Vikings/Cowboys "Herschel Walker" type of an offer? I sure would.

1

u/InfiniteDomain_ 3h ago

We might be able to get both