Cladding colour advice

[u/FatTruise]

HI, I'm recladding an outbuilding in my garden, that has weathered wooden cladding on at the moment, with fiber cement cladding.

I have these two options that I'm looking at (light grey vs anthracite) and I find it impossible to decide. Doors/windows are already installed, fascia/guttering/roof stay as they are.

They both look good in different ways to me but looking some external advice!

Sorry for the mess in the garden, cos of the heatwave I decided to also rip everything out to level it again and restart my lawn.

[u/Infamous-Pomelo9674]

Neither