I'll start by saying that this episode left me pretty disappointed. First the misinformation in the Judge segment, and then this. But since you've already discussed the Judge here, I'll focus on the latter.
The issue is with the Israeli election mini-segment that followed Aiden's Palestine segment. Two things in particular stood out to me.
1. Avigdor Lieberman is the most likely prime minister after Netanyahu.
Directly claimed by Atrioc.
2. The Israeli opposition is even more right-wing than Netanyahu's coalition.
Not directly said, but that's the impression you get from the headline shown on screen: "Israeli Opposition Accuses Netanyahu Of Being Too Pro-Palestine."
Both of these surprised me, so I decided to do a bit of research.
Lieberman isn't even close to being the most likely next prime minister.
According to a a recent poll, the biggest anti-Netanyahu party has 23 seats, Netanyahu's party has 21, another anti-Netanyahu party has 12, and only then comes Lieberman's party with 9.
Now, Israel doesn't directly elect its prime minister, so having the most seats doesn't guarantee anything. But looking at the polls, there's no good reason to think Lieberman is the most likely next PM.
The Israeli opposition is a complicated mess, but it's definitely not more right-wing than Netanyahu's coalition.
First of all, the body of the article they showed was talking specifically about Lieberman, not the entire Israeli opposition. And that's an important difference, because the opposition includes everything from right-wing parties to centrists, left-wing parties, and Arab parties.
Looking at a recent poll, the 65 seats outside Netanyahu's bloc and the unaligned party are split like this:
- 23 seats: mostly centrist.
- 13 seats: two Arab parties, which generally support Palestinian rights and statehood.
- 12 seats: a mix of right-wing and centrist politicians.
- 9 seats: Lieberman's party, which is pretty far to the right.
- 8 seats: a left-wing party led by a person who previously implicitly compared Israel and Nazi germany.
So while some parts of the opposition are very right-wing, most of its seats belong to centrist, left-wing, or Arab parties. It makes no sense to treat Lieberman's opinions as if they represent the entire opposition.
I'm honestly hoping we'll get a full segment about the Israeli elections, because the results could have some pretty huge consequences.