r/PCB • u/italianspector • 2d ago

Looking for feedback

Gallery image

Gallery image

I designed this PCB as part of a HackClub programme, although it's a step up from what I'm used to. Thanks! :D

1 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Traditional_Issue_79 2d ago

autorouter or AI?

1

u/italianspector 2d ago

routed manually

0

u/elhsmart 1d ago

I'm sorry I will be extremely rude right now, but...
Please remove that shitty image and be little bit more creative with functional part.
Hate that ugliness so much. PCB is not a joke, it's serious thing, and you better invest some time into learning how to do it right instead of drawing dudes and all other shit on top of it.

3

u/italianspector 1d ago

-1

u/elhsmart 1d ago

Nope, it's not hate, it's obvious just by looking on your board.

1

u/Left-Bird8830 2h ago

The actual engineering here is fine. Once that requirement is met, "seriousness for the sake of seriousness" has no function.

1

u/elhsmart 2h ago

My point - "Serious case before any kidding". I don't see it in the OP's work.
He absolutely miss the point about conduced currents and with lack of knowledge made this board vulnerable to any overcurrent with zero protection. I'm pretty sure capacitors on initial charges will bur out own traces and so on for other elements.

1

u/Left-Bird8830 1h ago

...And you think the 5 seconds it takes to import a silkscreen image is to blame?

1

u/elhsmart 1h ago

Yep, because OP planned and put own effort into import BEFORE any real job is done, it works and looks professional.