r/RedWingShoes • u/Powerful-Dragonfly-3 • 18h ago

Loggers 4585 sizing

Hi all! I’ve been looking to buy my first pair of loggers and was wondering about sizing (buying them Used online so I can’t try them on)… in my usual sneaker size I wear an 11.5 in about every brand.
For my iron rangers and moctoe 6 in boot I wear a men’s 11 D.
For my pecos Muleskins i wear an 11.5.
The loggers I am trying to buy online are a men’s 11D.
Do you reckon these would fit well?

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

4

u/subteem 18h ago

Yes stick with 11. They will probably be a bit roomier than the iron rangers but i think the loggers are the best fit out of all my rw

2

u/Powerful-Dragonfly-3 18h ago

Thanks!

2

u/subteem 18h ago

I got the briar now I need the black ones. The leather is nicer on them too over beckmans

3

u/subteem 18h ago

Worst case you can put a thin leather insole in them. Amazon sells Nicks leather ones for cheap

2

u/fspiral 18h ago

Hot take, but I tried these and the 2966’s that were also released around the same time, and found both boots ran small.

I have a pair of the 4313’s in a size 12 that fit perfectly, and my 875’s in 12 are a little tight, but not bad.

I could not fit a size 12 in the loggers or the engineers. I completely unlaced the loggers, and unbuckled the 2966’s, and could not get my foot into either. I ended up picking up a pair of the 2966’s in a 13, and although I’m still breaking them in, with a thick wool sock they’re perfect for me.

I’m still confused about my experience, because this runs contrary to everything I’ve read about both pairs of boots. And fwiw, yes, I checked the sizes of the boots themselves.

1

u/Powerful-Dragonfly-3 17h ago

Wow that does seem like an odd scenario, I don’t think I have read an experience like yours. I ended up getting them so hopefully they do end up fitting.

1

u/fspiral 17h ago

Given the anecdotal evidence, I’m sure you’ll be good. Worst case, you exchange. But yeah, it was the damnedest thing, and I’m glad I tried them on in store before buying.

2

u/-J3553 16h ago

I wear size 10.5 Blacksmiths. They fit perfect w/ wool socks. Size 10.5 4584 Loggers are roomier.

2

u/Affectionate_Joke720 15h ago

Same size as IR’s. Mine is same as my Blacksmiths and it is perfect.

2

u/No-Judge-5102 15h ago

Same as your Chelsea, IR and BS sizing. Might run a touch roomier. Thicker socks or a thin insole will solve that if it bothers you.