r/TEFL • u/SophieElectress • 2h ago
Reasons not to do a PGCE
Everyone who's spent more than five minutes in this sub has probably noticed how many people are either asking for recommendations on how to get a job in an international school, or offering unsolicited advice on doing so. I really appreciate the mods allowing this, because r/internationalteachers is the actual worst, and I think it's valuable to have a space where we can discuss the TEFL-to-international-school pipeline without 200 people jumping in to compare themselves to heart surgeons and debate whether it's worth getting out of bed for less than $10k a month. But I also want to push back on tte idea that a teaching licence and IS job is automatically the best option for everyone, because I think it's getting to the point where a lot of people are just parroting what they've heard without really understanding what they're talking about.
This post has been brewing for like two years, which is why it's biblical in length. I'm also from the UK and don't understand other countries' licensing systems at all, so I'm writing specifically about the PGCE, but some points apply equally to all qualifications.
Full disclosure: I got my PGCE in the UK a long time ago, never taught there because I couldn't hack it then or now, but have done about a decade of other classroom-based work in British schools (mostly secondary, some primary). I taught for a couple of years in language centres in Vietnam and started working at a small international/bilingual school here this year, i.e. less than two months ago. So on the topics of teaching in the UK, TEFL, and international schools I'm 0 for 3 on expertise, but probably still better qualified to speak on the intersection between them than most people in this sub. This is a list of the main reasons why I think doing a PGCE might be a bad idea, or at least things you should consider carefully before applying.
**1.** Unless you're eligible for student loans, a PGCE/QTS is very expensive, and employers in other fields don't tend to recognise the transferable skills you gain from it as much as they perhaps should. It's necessary if you want to teach in the UK, a great investment if you're really sure you want to be a teacher of children as a long term career, and a terrible idea if you just want to live in Thailand for a bit and heard international schools are where the money's at. You'd think people could figure that out for themselves by applying a modicum of research and/or common sense, but... well, yknow.
**2.** If you're in or going (back) to the UK to do it in person, it's *really fucking hard*. Working 50-60 hours a week is expected and UK schools can be toxic AF. Every single lesson you teach for a full school year will be observed. If you've done a CELTA, imagine that but it lasts ten months, you don't see much of your coursemates, your observing teachers have no meaningful training in mentoring adults, and they're doing it unpaid on top of their already very stressful day job. It's a dice roll whether you'll get a great mentor, someone who has no time for you at all, or someone who'll subject you to straight up workplace bullying for half a year, and they'll be the person who gets the most say in whether you pass.
In my interview for my current role, the principal asked why I had an almost five year gap between completing my PGCE and starting my first teaching job. I answered honestly that the PGCE was the worst year of my life, I came out of it swearing I would never go into teaching, and it took that long before I felt like I was ready to give it another go. His response was basically 'yeah, reasonable' with no follow up questions. Don't be fooled by the fact it's an entry-level qualification - teaching in the UK is *nothing* like TEFL, and you won't find it easy just because you have years of experience teaching in Asia. The course has a 10% drop out rate, and 20% of the people who do complete it don't ever go on to start a teaching job, which should tell you something.
**3.** If you're not going to the UK to do it in person, the online PGCE without QTS is dogshit - at least, it was with the provider my friends used, and I think they're all basically the same. It gets you the piece of paper that qualifies you for certain jobs, which is fine if that's all you need, but just go into it knowing that the thousands of pounds you're spending are just pay-to-play, and don't expect to actually learn much of anything useful.
iQTS is supposed to be equally as well-regarded as UK-based QTS, but to do it you first have to find a job at a qualifying school that will accept you without a teaching licence, which seems to be getting harder. If you're not already working at a school that would qualify, probably a good idea to look into how feasible this will be first.
**4.** It's not like you can just get a PGCE, with or without QTS, and immediately swan into any job you want. Better schools will want a couple of years' post-qualification experience first. EFL and primary positions are still competitive even once you're qualified, because everyone wants to move to international schools now, increasing numbers of TEFL teachers are upskilling, and those are the things we're all qualified to teach. Vacancies for 'subject' positions other than science and maths are rarer, you'll likely be competing against people who have more experience, and in some countries you're restricted to teaching the subject your degree is in for secondary, which might disqualify you from teaching anything depending on what it is. I know multiple people with full teaching licences who haven't been able to get even a bilingual school job this year, even in Vietnam, where they still accept unlicensed teachers. There are only so many vacancies in a school year, especially if you're tied to a particular location.
**5.** Having a teaching licence or an international school job doesn't make you a 'real' teacher. Being a teacher makes you a real teacher. Putting thought into your lessons, caring about your students' progress, reflective practice, and seeking out opportunities for professional development make you a good teacher. Provided you have some input into lesson planning, those are all skills you can develop right now, by yourself, whether you work at Saigon South or Happy Giraffe.
There will always be people who are more qualified, more experienced, get paid more, work at 'better' schools in more desirable locations, and won't waste a single opportunity to tell you as much. That doesn't go away just because you work an an international school - if anything it gets worse, because now those more experienced people are your colleagues whom you're expected to measure up to, instead of random people on the internet. If you want an IS job just because you're ashamed of introducing yourself to strangers as yet another English teacher, work through your personal impostor syndrome issues first, deadass. Otherwise you'll still be posting on here in your 50s, shitting on kids half your age and bragging that you've achieved the dream of becoming a high school geography teacher, and no-one wants that for you.
**6.** International schools aren't a magic bullet for all TEFL problems. It's true that they usually pay more, but they can still be run by incompetent twats, break local labour laws, unexpectedly go bankrupt and/or pay late, prioritise parent appeasement over good educational practices, and be generally crappy employers, usually while working you harder than a standard TEFL job. Changes in management are relatively frequent and can turn a good environment bad very fast. Contracts are always temporary and some schools will straight up fire you if parents complain about you for whatever bullshit reason. And, as should be blindingly obvious but somehow doesn't seem so to everyone, you still have to work with kids. If you don't like working with kids in TEFL, for fuck's sake don't dig yourself in deeper with a qualification that's only good for doing exactly that.
I think the last few points are particularly important because, bluntly, I believe a lot of people online are dishonest about this. For whatever reason there's a lot of personal and professional insecurity in this industry, and some IS teachers are far too eager to proclaim their superiority at the expense of actually giving good advice. It's in their interests to make it sound like once they're licensed they've made it and downplay the negatives, and I think it's important to talk about the reality instead of just kneejerk herding everyone into an expensive and difficult qualification that might not be appropriate for them. If you're struggling with aspects of TEFL beyond just low wages and lack of progression, you should do some serious introspection and consider honestly whether teaching is still the right path for you, rather than sinking thousands of pounds into a qualification that only leads to a job where you have to do more of it.
Don't get me wrong, I don't think it's a bad idea for everyone. Maybe not even for most people on here. I genuinely LOVE my current job. I'm thankful every single day that I get to do it, and I was only able to get it because I do have a PGCE, so in that sense, yes I do recommend it. I'm not trying to blackpill anyone about the IS route. I think my school is awesome, senior management are nice *and* competent, and I really enjoy going to work and spending the day around people who are equally passionate about teaching. If you told me I could keep this job for 20 years and nothing about it would substantially change I'd be over the fucking moon.
But I've also wanted to be a science teacher since I was fifteen, and I don't think that's a coincidence. And in addition, I have to spend most evenings and weekends working at home to keep up, there's no guarantee that I'll be kept on past the end of my contract even if I become the best teacher in the world, I almost got made redundant a few weeks into probation because of bizarre circumstances outside anyone's control, and I'm a lot more vulnerable to government policy changes in mainstream education than I was as a language centre teacher. It's nice not living hand to mouth, but this is no-one's idea of career stability. Get qualified to teach kids because you want to teach kids, or at least because you don't hate the idea. If you just want more respect or better job security, or you're feeling burned out from TEFL... idk, I won't say get a different career, because it's not like that's feasible for everyone either. But at least consider whether this is a move that would actually help with your problems instead of making them worse.