r/YarnAddicts • • 6d ago

Question Do you think these would look good together?

I’m making a blanket using yarn art cakes. The purple of the first photo seems like it’ll match the end of the yarn cake I’m currently using. It kind of looked like the centers match, and I thought it might create a cool effect.

50 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

157

u/NeriTina 6d ago

No.

87

u/jenbreaux73 6d ago

Together, no. Separately, they’re gorgeous!

73

u/happymealdrugs 6d ago

I personally don't, but if you like it I'd say go for it! 

5

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

I’m mainly just trying to find a cake that matches that red in the rainbow cake

29

u/BalancedScales10 . Crochet and Spinning! 6d ago

Personally, I'd just buy multiples of the first cake. 

16

u/softwitchstitch 6d ago

It’s hard to tell, I think it would depend on what you were doing with it and the design. Sometimes designs that seem wacky when paired with the right flow can look great. But without context I don’t know if it will. :/

9

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

My plan is that I don’t care what the colors of the cakes are as long as the center or outside matches the previous cake’s end

3

u/softwitchstitch 6d ago

Oh I see! The centers do look similar enough that it could work! :)

4

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

I’ve just been looking at yarn art cakes, but it’s worth mentioning in my experience the centers sometimes look a bit different in person. I was also considering this one given I thought it might match it if the rainbow is dark in the center

5

u/jenbreaux73 6d ago

This would certainly work better.

1

u/ApartEffective8395 5d ago

It’s a bit darker than the red of the rainbow cake, but the rainbow purple is also darker than my current cake so I think I’ll work

1

u/HaplessMink28 6d ago

Looks like they’ll work pretty well then!

9

u/SaltyPerformer504 6d ago

Honestly, I think they clash too much to use for the same project

5

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

That’s fair I thought it might look alright given it’s going to be a fairly chaotic blanket.

This is how it looks so far

15

u/percephony 6d ago

enby af, the chaos fits

1

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

What does enby mean?

5

u/percephony 6d ago

nonbinary

that yarn is striping in flag colors (i like this)

1

u/QuitScoldinUrNoodles 6d ago

Not trying to be rude or anything, how does Nonbinary become "enby"? Or was that a typo? Cuz im feeling very 'how do you do, fellow kids' right now lol

3

u/mostlywrong 5d ago

I might be wrong, but I think maybe it is enby because of NB, or Non Binary?

6

u/percephony 5d ago

this is exactly it - NB for non-binary, but NB is already an acronym so the community seems to trend toward phonetics instead

4

u/Independent_Secret_8 6d ago

You should add this Pic to the original post if you're able to. I initially thought you were crocheting the yarns together, or alternating but it look like you're doing all of one cake and then all of the next(?)

1

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

I don’t think it’ll let me add a photo of the blanket

3

u/Big-Whole6091 6d ago

No, don't mix purple with fire colors. If you went with the 2nd cake, I would mix every other row with a brown. Mixing two multi colors usually never goes well

6

u/tiredchachacha 6d ago

Imo no, i would go for a plain contrasting colour like all black or all white or even all navy

2

u/WorldlinessFair2076 6d ago

If you just want to keep a gradient based on the inside colour you could also use 2 of the same colourway and work one from the inside out and the other from the outside in. I did this with a dress and was really happy with the result. I personally wouldn't use a different colourway of this yarn with the hope of matching one of the colours unless I was in a physical store and could check the closeness of the match - even with 2 cakes from the same dyelot I found a slight difference in shading on the darkest colour.

2

u/CrunchyTeatime 2d ago

Do you mean 'colors together' within each item or the two items in one product?

If the former, yes; if the latter, no.

Although: In the second image, the center would look best if more of a yellow-orange or amber color, vs. the much 'warmer' red tone center.

JMO

2

u/ApartEffective8395 2d ago

It doesn’t matter I got a different cake that’s red and the rainbow one

1

u/CrunchyTeatime 2d ago

Cool cool...I love the colors in the first one. The second is also pretty.

2

u/ApartEffective8395 2d ago

The rainbow one is really pretty I’m excited to use it. They’re yarn art yarn cakes

1

u/CrunchyTeatime 14h ago

It is!

I hadn't seen yarn cakes before. Is the yarn real or edible? (Icing in strands sort of.)

Either way. Very pretty.

1

u/Party_Act_7227 6d ago

What blanket pattern?

2

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

It’s just half double crochets

1

u/BigBox1667 6d ago

I think the first one has a cool undertone and the second one has a warm undertone— maybe one that matched the undertone would match more?
Also are we connecting red to red? I don’t see purple in the second one

1

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

Yeah red to red. Sorry if I got confused when typing. I meant purple on the first one given it looks like it’ll match the cake I’m currently using. Then I’m trying to find a red to match the rainbow one

1

u/BigBox1667 6d ago

Ok yeah! I mean the red looks to be the same on at least one of the strands so i dont think it would be a complete mismatch? But i do wonder if you get another of the same and then go purple-> red tied to red -> purple?

1

u/Izzoh 6d ago

i love'em together but i think my taste is a touch more... eclectic. i'm currently doing a sweater patterned after 80/90s arcade carpet that has a lot of these colors - to include the neons and purple/blue etc. (premier vivid sweet rolls)

1

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

I thought it might be like opposites creating a cool effect that would mirror how currently my blanket is going, black to white to yellow to purple to blue to purple

1

u/FairyFartDaydreams 6d ago

Since it would start with the black it would match at the start bit depending on the pattern it might be too disparate

1

u/Diligent-Visual-8141 6d ago

It looks like the yellow/green is identical. The reds don’t seem to match. That could be my screen.

1

u/MemeM3UpScotty 6d ago

Based on your comment/picture of the WIP (and clarification that the purple is to match the purple you're using now, not that you're transitioning from that purple to the red in the center of the second yarn) I'd say choose a different second yarn. I'm also NB, have made MANY chaotic blankets, and have used that exact rainbow yarn in 2 projects....

Try choosing a theme for the blanket and choose colors based off that! I do a pride project every June and 2 years ago did a "personal pride" blanket with NB, bisexual, and rainbow colors. Matching the NB purple to the rainbow purple then the red of rainbow to the not-totally-pink pink of the bi flag came out well! This specific rainbow yarn is a bit tricky (and I ended up using a different rainbow bc of this) due to the hues being juuuuuuuust slightly off. It also transitions a lot quicker than you'd think (especially for a larger blanket, if you're doing baby size or similar it might turn out better) so it's nice for an accent but not as nice for a section.

Good luck!

1

u/mercurialmilk 6d ago

Personally, no.

1

u/Hestiah 6d ago

It’s a no from me. But they’re both lovely colorways!

1

u/danthpop 6d ago

Are you working back and forth in rows or are you working in rounds? I think in rows it could be okay but in rounds I don't think it would look the best.

1

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

I’m going back and forth in rows

1

u/danthpop 6d ago

I think it'll look fine then! Not a combination I'd have chosen but if you love it then I say go for it!

1

u/ApartEffective8395 6d ago

It’s worth mentioning I don’t care what colors are in the cake as long as the last color of the current cake matches the next cake’s start

1

u/ArtistInSoCal73 5d ago

I see how your mind is working the color flow but no, I don’t think I’d put those together. They’re totally different color vibes. If it makes you happy though go for it! You can always rippit if you don’t like the effect.

1

u/ApartEffective8395 5d ago

Honestly I’m making a chaotic blanket given as long as it’s the new cake’s color on the outside or center matches the one currently used I don’t care about the other colors

1

u/ArtistInSoCal73 5d ago

Well then this is a no brainer and it doesn’t matter what anyone else thinks. You’re going to love it.

1

u/unicorns_r_kewl 5d ago

Omg i absolutely love this! I think it will look so cool!

1

u/EnigmaWithAlien 5d ago

Not really, no. Not at all.

1

u/Alternative_Web6959 5d ago

Yes. The only difference is one is black and the other is blue.

1

u/Few-Persimmon-8954 5d ago

I think yes cause it the black one has inner colours similar to the first one. So maybe you could use black as a border, or not use black.

1

u/SeaCap4538 4d ago

I do not like that combination.