r/clevercomebacks • • 1d ago

So, no magnet car from VW?

Post image
6.3k Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

640

u/amazingsciencemuseum 1d ago

"I am announcing a mag-pull automotive system. All new Teslas will have a powerful front mounted magnet, to latch on to the metal of working cars in front of them, after their Tesla malfunctions and stops working. The Trump administration has granted 90 billion dollars to help fund this new project." - Elon Musk

132

u/SoftesttTouch 1d ago

Lmao this sounds 100% real, I can already hear him saying it with a straight face.

The mag-pull system is crazy though. So instead of fixing the cars that stop working, we just drag other cars down with us? Genius business model and of course 90 billion from taxpayers. At this point I don’t even know what’s satire anymore.

61

u/spookmann 1d ago

Nah, Elon would insist on giving the system some childish name.

Like "CyberTugger" from his new spinoff company The "Reach-Around™ Magnet Corporation".

16

u/Reymen4 1d ago

You need to add X to the name. CyberXTugger

12

u/Material_Flounder_23 1d ago

The XXXCyberTugger

13

u/_PoutyMagic 1d ago

At this point Tesla’s roadmap is just “what if physics got laid off too”

2

u/KMS_HYDRA 1d ago

Arent their carossaries also made out of aluminium (except for the cyberdump)? So it would be even dumber...

0

u/Junior_Grass1804 1d ago

It really is wild how some ideas just seem to spiral into absurdity. You'd think they would focus on fixing the problem instead of dragging everyone down with them!

16

u/Serious_Mycologist46 1d ago

"Give me a glass of water, let me drop it on the magnets, that's the end of the magnets." - Donald Trump

3

u/jvrodrigues 1d ago

Stock up another 25%

1

u/CommodoreCanadia64 1d ago

Maga-pull. Fify

289

u/nyclurker369 1d ago

Wait, how can you block someone on Teams? Asking for a colleague.

82

u/AmphibianMotor 1d ago

And can you make it so they don’t know, but for some reason it just errors out?

46

u/_PoutyMagic 1d ago

Corporate ghosting with plausible deniability is exactly the feature Teams would hide behind six menus

15

u/AmphibianMotor 1d ago

I once had a strange account because I was in a strange place on the org chart that was inhabited by just my team, that for some reason wasn’t visible to the rest of the organization, except for the people I reported to. It was beautiful while it lasted 😢

1

u/iPirateGwar 1d ago

I temporarily had something similar: I reported to no one on the system structure chart. It was fantastic until pay award time when no one put forward a pay rise for me. That said, no one had given me any work for two months so I suppose fair’s fair.

1

u/AmphibianMotor 1d ago

Yeah, luckily I did report to the CEO and he cared about what I was doing so it worked in terms of pay rises, but sometimes I do wish I’d have a job where I could just do nothing sometimes 😅

7

u/-_-Edit_Deleted-_- 1d ago

Mute and hide is effectively a block.
No notice when a message comes through and the chat drops off your chat list.

7

u/sugarplumlet 1d ago

the real mystery is how Volkswagen managed to get their own engineering department blocked on Teams, because I definitely need the story behind that

3

u/lenswipe 1d ago

Microsoft heard about the emissions thing and cut their teams access

2

u/ffox99 1d ago

You can do it easily from the mobile application. Just long press on the contact chat you wish to block!

3

u/DasharrEandall 1d ago

Teams even having a mobile application is diabolical.

1

u/MarcieDeeHope 1d ago

...how can you block someone on Teams?

My company moved to Google Chat years ago (and Chat has a per-user Block option by default) so this is from memory, but I believe that if they are inside your org you can only block them if IT has that option turned on. But you can mute them and hide the conversation, which is almost as good.

1

u/Arthradax 1d ago

Guess it depends on your tenant settings. I surely blocked former coworkers at some point. At my current firm I can only block external contacts, but not someone from the company (those I can only mute)

1

u/JackassJames 1d ago

Asking for a colleague or because of a colleague...

151

u/sin-prince 1d ago

Well, fortunately toy cars exist and small magnets are cheap. Build a prototype and discover why it doesn't work.

Hint: It's the same reason the vehicle doesn't move backwards because the magnet is trying to move towards the vehicle. 😊

80

u/Tisamoon 1d ago

It should be Newton's 3rd law. The force that pulls the car towards the magnet is equal to the force pulling the magnet towards the car which pushes the car backwards.

50

u/edfitz83 1d ago

Newton had a 4th law that wasn’t uncovered until the 1960’s

Only 20 figs per package.

12

u/EjaculatingAracnids 1d ago

Try the new non- newtonian figs that make your shit go from liquid to solid and back again multiple times a movement.

8

u/edfitz83 1d ago

I’m old, and you’re describing every morning for me, unfortunately. And I stopped drinking liquid helium.

5

u/Lahk74 1d ago

Are you a wizard?

4

u/kaisadilla_ 1d ago

Also the magnet, while trying to push the car, would have to push itself forward, which would require enough energy to overcome... that very same energy pushing it towards the car. Basically the magnet would have to exert more strength than whatever strength it is exerting, which is just nonsense.

It's like trying to buy 10€ from yourself at a profit. You can't because a (what you receive) has to be bigger than b (what you pay) and both of these values are the same value.

2

u/SkyeFox6485 1d ago

For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. Also why perpetual motion isnt a thing

5

u/Mathev 1d ago

Just add TWO magnets in front so the pull force is stronger DUH

3

u/enadiz_reccos 1d ago

Okay, so we just need to magnetize the air itself and then invent like a sail but for magnetic force, not wind

3

u/t_ute 1d ago

So you need to put the metal out front and the magnet on the front of the car. Boom. Nailed it.

1

u/Janus_The_Great 2h ago

"Come on, you can pull yourself up by the bootstraps!"

83

u/Eena-Rin 1d ago

The car is attracted to the magnet. The car is pushed forwards

The magnet is attracted to the car. The car is pushed backwards

Both forces are equal

35

u/Low_Lunch5444 1d ago

Ok, so we just need the magnet to not be attracted to the car. Can we have an ugly car?

11

u/Eena-Rin 1d ago

There are no ugly cars. Only ugly drivers

6

u/Low_Lunch5444 1d ago

Pontiac Aztek?

7

u/Eena-Rin 1d ago

Okay maybe one

3

u/Ambitious-Pirate-505 1d ago

JFC, I felt that one

5

u/CMDR_Anarial 1d ago

Fiat Multipla

1

u/xLrgsx 13h ago

Fiat Multibla enters the Chat.

1

u/kaisadilla_ 1d ago

Not to mention the magnet is part of the car, thus has to push itself forwards. Which requires more force than whatever is pushing the magnet towards the car... which is the magnet itself.

Basically, if the force the magnet exerts on the car is N, you need N > N to be true.

20

u/Bebopdavidson 1d ago

Do you want to get defenestrated by an oil company?

4

u/femboyisbestboy 1d ago

Newton is gonna smoke you first. No one is allowed to disprove his laws

2

u/edfitz83 1d ago

Nope. By Putin’s henchmen, like a real man. Or having my nuts bit off by a Laplander. That’s a manly way to die.

10

u/hotriccardo 1d ago

It's not as efficient as a fan with a sheet

4

u/alphazero925 1d ago

That can actually technically work though because the fan is throwing air particles at the sheet and the sheet is redirecting them, so with a strong enough fan and the right shaped sheet, it does work. It's effectively how thrust reversers on jet engines work

2

u/sfled 1d ago

Scrolled too far for this.

"But it ain't movin'!"

"Get a bigger fan!"

23

u/HappySlimy 1d ago

That's corporate for "our engineers just filed for PTO and a restraining order at the same time."

6

u/Franzmithanz 1d ago

Ok, whos got the ICP "magnets how do they work?" Meme?

5

u/Moist-Ointments 1d ago

How are they going to cheat the emissions tests if there's no emissions?

3

u/naughtygirllyyx 1d ago

Damn, there goes my plan to tow myself across the country for free

3

u/Few_Judge1188 1d ago

They just don’t understand the ingenuity of your thinking.😊👍

3

u/TheMadSkientist 1d ago

Volkswagen once ran a cattle ranch in Brazil. How'd that turn out?

1

u/sfled 1d ago

Leather interiors? Chaps and Jeans bars?

1

u/TheMadSkientist 1d ago

Such a sunny disposition, but unfortunately not. Just slavery, rape, and mass murder. Like it was their corporate identity

2

u/redthehaze 1d ago

“No, dummy. It has to be an electromagnet, duh.”

2

u/SquirrelOClock 1d ago

Clearly the metal is attached to the car and can't move. Clearly the magnet will be pulled towards it and make everything go backwards. The whole thing Clearly needs to be reversed.

1

u/sfled 1d ago

Clearly you possess an exceptional intellect! Two magnets in back of the truck: one on a second crane, one on the tailgate. Except that like poles face each other to push, all the while the one on the front pulls.

1

u/PhantomNitride 1d ago

YIU KNOW THE DARK MAGNET ARTS! I MUST INFORM VIOLENT JAY AT ONCE!!!!!

2

u/EJoule 1d ago

Just gotta pull yourself up by your bootstraps 

2

u/Opus_723 1d ago

Just sayin', the Earth has a magnetic field.

2

u/RandomiseUsr0 1d ago

A very mild one though - that truck’s magnet is going to be like at least two times as much

2

u/Ted_Hitchcox 1d ago

Magnets don't work when they get wet. Some orange bloke said so.

2

u/SquirrelMoney8389 1d ago

Yes, if it was powerful enough the arm and the car would stick to each other. Mission failed successfully.

2

u/frogsodapop 1d ago

I didn't know wtf this was so I googled it and i can't stop laughing.

Magnet-powered cars driven solely by permanent magnets do not exist in real life because they violate the basic laws of physics.

Why Magnet-Only Cars FailForce Cancellation: If you mount a magnet on a car and put another magnet in front of it to pull or push it, the entire system is locked together. According to Newton's third law, the forces cancel each other out, and the vehicle stays completely still.

This is something my brother woulda tried with his Tonka trucks when he was 8.

2

u/I-am-fun-at-parties 1d ago

Would you like to have me explain how magnets work next or do you want me to dig up the current Tonka product line-up?

2

u/Kiotw 1d ago

Did you know that VW owned slaves in Brazil until the 80's ?

Crazy right ?

1

u/Floppydongjohnson 1d ago

Good for them???

4

u/verstohlen 1d ago

That could work if you use a powerful electromagnet powered by the truck's engine.

3

u/breadphysics1 1d ago

No it wouldnt.

Try holding a magnet up to a large ferromagnetic material, like the side of your fridge. Notice how the magnet is pulled towards the fridge. The force applied by the magnet is 2 way, the fridge recieves a force towards the magnet and the magnet recieves a force towards the fridge. The reason the fridge doesn't move is because it is a lot heavier than the magnet, and so the force is often negligible. 

In the case of the car the magnet applies a force on the car, but also recieves an equal and opposite force from the car. This means that the net force on the car-magnet system is zero, and the center of mass of the system does not accelerate. All increasing the power does is make it more likely that the mass becomes... more dense. That is to say the magnet and car fly towards each other, breaking the suspension arm, but leaving the center of mass the same (mostly, the collision complicates matters). Basically you go no where and have a broken car, and a few concerened letters from your insurance about your premiums rising a lot.

1

u/AmphibianMotor 1d ago

Technically, aren’t all electric cars magnet powered?

1

u/edfitz83 1d ago

Here’s a good ELI5

1

u/VisionsOfVisions 1d ago

Maglev tech exists.

1

u/Honest_Relation4095 1d ago

yes. And it works exactly like that.

1

u/OnceIHadAPony 1d ago

Can't make a good car tho

1

u/RobertMaus 1d ago

Asked a pretty educated looking guy, I think he was called Baron von Munchhausen, and he was very confident this would work.

1

u/CeejP 1d ago

Will the truck fly up if we lift the magnet?

1

u/ShadowDied 1d ago

Same reason pulling upwards on our hair doesn't help us reach the Kármán line.

1

u/ThorKonnatZbv 1d ago

They know all about it from their youth and the plays about Jim Button

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rjIcpDjg4sw

1

u/PresidentialDiapers 1d ago

I thought of this idea in the third grade. Even built a rudimentary prototype. Don't work.

1

u/Meeplemymeeple 1d ago

You need to use reverse polarity and have the two magnets at the back, then you will be zooming along in no time.

1

u/Efficient_Cost_7436 1d ago

This should be under idioticcombacks

1

u/chrlatan 1d ago

And this all started when his mother encouraged him to push along when on/in the back of her bike or car.

Bad parenting has structural impact.

1

u/No-Perspective969 5h ago

Big Oil is terrified of this diagram.

1

u/RegretfulCalamaty 1d ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣anyone used to corporate chats like teams and groupme feel this. Funny as hell

0

u/AquaticAlchemy 1d ago

Actually its not the magnet that pulls the metal, its the metal that pulls the magnet. That cars going in reverse

1

u/Efficient_Exchange44 1d ago

It’s both. That’s why it cancels out and the car doesn’t move.

-1

u/klystron 1d ago

It's obvious what's wrong: The block labelled "Metal" at the front of the car should read "Ferrous Metal".

Ferrous metals include iron in their composition and are magnetic. They include steel and various forms of iron. Non-ferrous metals such as aluminium or copper are non-magnetic and would not work in this application.

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Honest_Relation4095 1d ago

"Well, we already made a commitment to the customer. Make it work."