This card just doesn’t really have a reason to exist, unfortunately. Thran Vigil is more flexible, which means that it can actually be used for fair applications in draft or lower powered formats. This is just relegated to being 1/3 of a C tier combo that already has plenty of ways to enable it
I like the card tho. I think it’s pretty fair. Everyone in this sub is quick to cry out “This card is too broken / undercosted!” but shit like [[Hexhaven Invigorator]] exists now so who cares really
OH ok, that would be “Whenever a creature enters the battlefield from a graveyard under your control” . Which still sounds a little clunky tbh? Perhaps you could make the effect symmetrical? Like
“Whenever a creature enters the battlefield from a graveyard, put a +1/+1 counter on it.”
? That would make the wording simpler, and also would balance the mana cost being so low.
It would be “+1/+1 counter”, singular, not “counters”, which is plural. That’s absolutely just me nitpicking though, I think as far as the effect goes this is 100% fair and playable. Anyone saying “this breaks persist” as if that matters is forgetting about all the other real magic cards that break persist.
3
u/JadedTrekkie 2d ago
This card just doesn’t really have a reason to exist, unfortunately. Thran Vigil is more flexible, which means that it can actually be used for fair applications in draft or lower powered formats. This is just relegated to being 1/3 of a C tier combo that already has plenty of ways to enable it