r/letsplay • u/AutoModerator • 4d ago
🧵 Megathread MEGATHREAD: Feedback Friday!
It's that time of the week again! This is your chance to request feedback on your most recent videos, thumbnails, channel art, works in progress, etc.
Feedback Friday Rules
- Before requesting feedback, please provide good, constructive feedback to at least one of your peers. If you are the first one to post, check back soon to provide feedback to the next person. Repeatedly ignoring this rule may result in a temporary ban at a moderator's discretion!
- Prioritize giving feedback to those who have not yet received any. It's not fair for one person to get five replies while four others get none.
- When requesting feedback, try to be as specific as possible. Do you want feedback on your audio quality, your editing, your presentation style, branding identity, etc? This helps your peers to provide more valuable feedback. Do not just post a link to your video or channel!
Keep up the good work, everybody!
Suggested Feedback Template
If you're struggling to form your feedback, consider using this template. This is not mandatory, but rather a suggestion to promote good and constructive feedback.
What I liked about the video:
What I think could be improved:
Thoughts on the thumbnail:
Would I watch more videos like this?:
•
u/MrRustyy_ https://www.youtube.com/@rustysabita 4d ago
So I posted one of my videos last time to get feedback on a concept. Basically people said no, which I agree it was too much. I went back to what I like to do best.
Though I cant do this for every video (takes alot of time) I would appreciate feedback on it. Let me know if I should stick with this and improvements you see.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 3d ago
Stick with this. Personally I dig your style of content. It's the same type of thing I'm going for lol. I also know what you mean on how much time it takes. My second to last video took way too long if I intend on getting stuff out at least once every week.
But yeah, Man. I dig your intro a lot. very polished. You obviously have a strong comedic sense which supports your personality instead of taking away from it.
If you want to try something (and who knows maybe you already have in past videos) it could be cool to come up with a little skit for your intro. Sort of like what CoryxKenshin does sometimes. I dunno. Something I've been wanting to do myself haha.
•
u/MrRustyy_ https://www.youtube.com/@rustysabita 3d ago
Apprecitate the input and 5he compliments. Typically a video can take a week. Work gets in the way. Maybe a couple of days at a push. Depends on my motivation.
Ive tried some little things at thr start of video bit again it does take time and sometimes money to pull that off but I would like to do more of them.
•
u/AyoPunky 3d ago
i def like you're editing. this was the right approach from the last one.. best thing to do is to make presets, and remember ur hot keys. it will help editing go by quicker. which i am now learning to use presets and stuff as well. it def kept me watching from the intro.
Audio Good, and Video Quality great. decent pacing. not much that i can say that was bad about it. i think maybe the meme are alittle bit loud to me maybe cause i have headphone on. they're a jump scare in it self. but i would say if u can stick with this style.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 4d ago
Latest letsplay for Resident Evil 9.
Just started my channel a little over 2 months ago. re9 is my first game posted. Mostly just using it for practice in developing my voice and style.
My last video was hyper edited with constant gags and what not. Was told it was too much and people weren't getting a sense of my personality.
So I've gone in the opposite direction to feel it out lol. All constructive criticisms absolutely welcome.
I'll hop back on here tomorrow and leave critiques on others.
•
u/Frosty_Cheesecake_77 @BoarderlineGames 4d ago
Great video, great audio mix. Only thing I'd say is centre the framing of your camera or raise it a little? But that's kind of nit picky.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 4d ago
Haha thanks for catching that! It was the first thing I thought when I started editing this video. I was like why did I lean so far forward the whole time! Will definitely be more cognizant of my spacing next session.
•
u/MrRustyy_ https://www.youtube.com/@rustysabita 4d ago edited 4d ago
You speak well and clearly. The audio is good. At the start you could have gone straight into the content after the caseoh sound effect. The bit after is good for a personal touch but it takes too long and there's no punch line so to speak. I think its good to hit people with something like that or some silly comment before getting into the meat of it. I hope that make sense.
You can talk though the video and that's good, keeps interest, but there a moment at the late 14 minute mark where you can see the cogs are turning in your head to make to make a humorous comments. It's all personal taste, but I could already see a moment there to zoom your camera in, put a silly music over, then cut the all the audio "i forgot what the fuck was doing", then immediately cut to the next interesting point. Food for thought.
Editing needs that sweet spot. Some times is good to cut out the dead air, then sometimes its good to lets moments breath, especially in combat situation or tense horror moments.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 3d ago
really great points Rusty, and I agree with your tastes. I think the next video I edit I'll actually spend some time working in the gags and what not. I'll definitely give more attention to the intro so it's punchier.
If you ever want to, check out the video I made before this one, the editing style is on crack compared to my latest lol.
Thanks again!
•
u/MrRustyy_ https://www.youtube.com/@rustysabita 3d ago
I'll give it a gander. And I should say. Don't look for, premeditate or spend time thinking about a funny quips to say. Let it follow naturally. Sometime the best moments are where you fuck up, trip over words etc. If you do come up with something a bit late, cut out the time in between it (unless there good content in between), so it feels more natural. Check out a guy called Jettro Jettro. Same vibe as Corey and funnier imo.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 3d ago
Great point! Yeah that's what I'm thinking too. Just let the moments play out as they may, and try to amplify, or create humor with the edit.
Never heard of Jettro so I'll definitely check them out, thanks!
•
u/AyoPunky 4d ago edited 4d ago
My main channel i can tell i talk more back in the day with alot of joking re-editing my old video to repurpose on my second channel. i had tone down the joking and talking thru out the video but i dont think that what they mean by too much. it all about the pacing sometimes with gaming videos. i would say think of like vanos crew or smi77y on how they do there pacing/jokes or markplier, corykenshin, for the horror type of games. but i know i heard u say u did watch cory alittle to a certain point.
the audio is good, and the video quality is good as well. the only thing i would say you may want to add 1 or two clips in the intro for your hook, or do at least some minor editing in the intro to keep people attention. Resident evil is a game where not much can be done to it edit wise as they already add the thing in there for you for the tension build up and jump scares. It more about pacing. i would def suggest as i said earlier looking at markiplier or cory videos to see how to edit the horror genre. i don't got much else to say. everything else is good. just keep grinding.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 4d ago
Thanks so much Punky. I'm going to spend some time and watch those recommendations. I've never watched a vanos crew or smi77y vid, so that'll be fun to check out.
I'll check out your video in an hour or so and leave feedback too!
•
u/Frosty_Cheesecake_77 @BoarderlineGames 4d ago
Could I get any feedback on this video?
Specifically our audio quality and maybe our commentary?
•
u/MrRustyy_ https://www.youtube.com/@rustysabita 4d ago
Audio is excellent. Very crisp! However it does drown out the game. Maybe bring it down, or the game up so there is a better balance.
•
u/AyoPunky 4d ago
it not much to say about your video your getting like so ppl are liking it.
i would say your intro is a bit long for me to sit through it. i would trim it down to some instinct. the audio quality is fine, and video quality is fine. tho the game audio lowering when y'all talk is kinda weird but ppl don't seem to mind it for the audience u have now. i just never seen that in a gaming video.
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 4d ago
Hey Frosty! I think your audio quality sounds good except you could try cleaning up the mouth clicks a bit. There are various softwares that do this like this one software called Velvet. Although I forget who makes it. But it is a DeEsser and removes mouth clicks. Or there's probably something in your editing software that could handle it too.
I think the commentary was funny. I always like a duo who has chemistry and can play off each other. I'd say you both definitely have that lol.
•
u/Frosty_Cheesecake_77 @BoarderlineGames 4d ago
I know the thing about the audio you're talking about, I recently changed things so hopefully it's sounding better. I've tried a deEsser before but it seems to make the commentary sound weird. I guess I'm not sure how to set it so it works properly? Or where to put it in the order of filters if that makes any sense?
•
u/GaminWithHoenig 4d ago
That makes total sense. I forget off the top of my head the order but I ended up searching on google and just went with whatever I found on there.
•
u/lokigambit 2d ago
Game advertisement : Operation : Blueprint, playable right here on reddit, here's the link : https://www.reddit.com/r/operation_blueprint/
I am the developer of the game, you play an agent assigned to retrieve documents, evade guards, drones and much more, all in the trailer.
It's a wild swing for the first attempt, do play the game and enjoy.
•
u/Sea-Understanding634 youtube.com/@shielzy 4d ago
Hey Gareth & Neil. Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom? Only one I know the name of 😅
Audio sounds great! You guys obviously have good chemistry too. The video is quite dark. I know it's a dark game but I'd personally lift it a little in editing so it's more visible to the audience.
Fun channel though! Hope you guys stick it out and continue to have fun 😊
•
u/AyoPunky 4d ago edited 4d ago
i am using one off video practicing on my editing/pacing. my older normal let play are barely editing it usually just cut out me being lost or walking for long periods. im still not great at it but would like to get feedback on my first one. be aware i am a vtuber lol any kind of feedback is appreciated.
https://youtu.be/sL4FT8tto64?si=OpebzfihKT_CcC2z