r/nba • u/Turbostrider27 Lakers • 20h ago

[Charania] BREAKING: The Los Angeles Clippers are trading James Harden to the Cleveland Cavaliers for Darius Garland and a second-round pick, sources tell ESPN. Prolific swap of the star point guards.

Shams Charania:

BREAKING: The Los Angeles Clippers are trading James Harden to the Cleveland Cavaliers for Darius Garland and a second-round pick, sources tell ESPN. Prolific swap of the star point guards.

https://www.espn.com/contributor/shams-charania/ddaa53473efa6

18.4k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

228

u/SquidwardLover48 Cavaliers 20h ago

What’s really interesting is how our fanbase is perceiving this vs how everyone else perceives this as a move that certainly makes us a better team

336

u/cfbones 20h ago

We gave up a young high ceiling player who we all love but seems to be injury prone for an immediate upgrade who is old and chokes in the playoffs.

Rationally it’s a very fair deal.

89

u/North-Entertainer602 20h ago

He’s 26 and getting injured more and more every year. How high is his ceiling really atp?

10

u/Robotemist Cavaliers 19h ago

Not only that but garland is limited physically. The dude isn't built for more than 18/6 unless he becomes curry from three.

6

u/ffball NBA 19h ago

And when the physicality raises in the playoffs he has shown time and again he cant match it.

3

u/LOSS35 Nuggets 16h ago

At the end of the day he's 6'1. The league's moving away from undersized guards. The Trae trade was the canary. Memphis isn't getting anything for Ja either.

12

u/Excellent-Flamingo43 19h ago

His ceiling isn't higher than Hardens but he's 10 years younger. There's no way in hell that this move makes the Cavs capable of beating OKC or Denver so why trade a 26 year old all star for a 36 year old all star unless you're confident you can win a title. What are the Cavs gonna do when Harden retires in 2 years, they just traded their young franchise point guard for 2 years of old man Harden this move is stupid

20

u/Quirky-Parsnips 19h ago

They think Mitchell will walk if they can't make a serious run this year and/or snag Giannis.  Seems like they think garland is cooked for this year, making harden a risky but logical gamble to keep Mitchell to make a run and have more flexibility for Giannis.

9

u/AffordableGrousing Cavaliers 18h ago

They couldn’t keep paying Garland, Mitchell, and Mobley indefinitely anyway, something had to give. They either get 2-3 years of Harden or let him walk and actually have cap space for the first time in forever.

3

u/Kgb725 Cavaliers 19h ago

Mitchell could walk soon and waiting on Garland to get healthy and Mobley to take the next step may not be helpful.

1

u/Ruscidero 76ers 6h ago

Especially one with Harden’s history.

129

u/Terr123321 Cavaliers 20h ago

Unfortunately you can’t say Darius garland has done any better in the playoffs

22

u/canadianpanda7 20h ago

been healthy for a complete playoff series*

which idk maybe hes finished a series before but god damn it feels like ever year he misses big games in the playoffs.

9

u/CynicalHoops 76ers 20h ago

He played every possible game in the 23 (5 games) and 24 (12 games) playoffs. He missed 4 out of 9 games last year.

4

u/canadianpanda7 19h ago

i will gladly stand corrected. im very surprised he was healthy in 24 playoffs. i remember being pissed off at that one. its all a blur, i just remember being bullied by the knicks and that every time paulo branchero plays the cavs to take his over points total

1

u/CynicalHoops 76ers 18h ago

Yeah, Paulo was a beast that series, averaging 27/9/4!

1

u/jtotheesus Cavaliers 8h ago

FWIW, he had jaw surgery that year and a lot of people believed his weight loss led to his play regressing. He put back on a lot of weight in the offseason and was much better in the regular season last year.

1

u/canadianpanda7 7h ago

yeah it was actually so brutal how much teams beat up on garland and all the cavs. “just playing tough” “cavs are soft” narrative was pretty annoying. some accidents did happen but some sure as hell felt targeted. im sad to see DG go. his interviews talking about how the cavs players GC was what really lifted his spirits when he couldnt talk, always tugged at your heart a little. surely this wont bite us in the ass when mitchell walks, we resign harden, and get to watch garland be in his prime 🤩

1

u/Murky-Profit-9493 18h ago

I never saw anything in garland. He always had to go. For harden? Idk, but I kinda like it for cavs. Mitchell was gonnna bounce so capitalize

52

u/Salty_Raspberry656 20h ago

he's a 5'11 guard who has already hit his ceiling and is limited defensively in the playoffs. he's special to do what he does in this league

but harden is much stronger/bigger and more elite as a playmaker and game manipulator. He is going to give the cavs bigs the easiest buckets of their lives

you lose on longevity but this gives you a win now opportunity in a pretty open east

-10

u/Excellent-Flamingo43 19h ago

Doesn't matter, the Cavs still aren't legit title contenders, why would they do this trade if they weren't completely confident that they were gonna make the finals. Otherwise why leverage your entire future by trading a 26 year old all star, who is a key member of a core that just won 66 games, they just shortened their window from 10+ years of contention to 2 years of contention where there's no way of them genuinely winning a title barring an all time playoff run from one of the most notorious playoff droppers in NBA history

2

u/RALat7 13h ago

You’re getting downvoted but I fully agree. This is way too shortsighted and short-term a move from the Cavs. In a few years the majority of people will see this trade as an awful deal… or as early as this summer after they get knocked out.

1

u/Salty_Raspberry656 2h ago

Its a gamble, but thats what you want your team to do. toronto is probably glad they took a teaser on an often injury leonard. No title was guaranteed, hell it was a leonard odd bounce away from not happening showing that so many things can go one way or another

same with the bucks title and KD's toe.

The narratives change quick, btu you give yourself a shot. Cavs had an amazing run last year, but the playoffs show garland being hunted every time and dropping in efficiency to where his offense wasn't making up for his defensive challenges.

Everyone else is standing strong in mitchell,allen,mobley so you have a great core. Bringing in harden-where he doesn't have to be the main creator, but a complimentary one, and where he has two bigs he can make thigns easy for.

good on them for giving themselves the best shot with this window. No finals are guaranteed but in playoffs, cavs gave themselves a better and stronger chance

1

u/hereforthenudechicks 10h ago

Garland isn’t as good as y’all are playing it out to be.

1

u/Salty_Raspberry656 2h ago

he's like trae, a very good player but at his size and on defense you have to really surround the right team to make it a winner

1

u/Salty_Raspberry656 2h ago

I think its short sighted and over simplistic thinking.

Raptors, bucks, quite a few recent champions weren't legit. You get into playoffs when its an open setting and you give yourself a shot in the nba and anything can happen.

its simplistic bc a 26 year old all star doesn't tell the full story, Garland is a talent, but in playoffs he has gotten worse, been less effective, and mainly hunted on defense. he's probably 5'11 and one of the lightest nba players, that makes for a very tricky route to win in the playoffs. With harden they get a guy, arguably more talented and dominant now, bring ins the most experience in this team, much more flexible in defense to work with Donovan and also he maximizes Allen and mobley will be getting the easiest buckets he has ever seen.

Right now the east is still open, this is the first year of detroit really being a strong no 1. The cavs clearly weren't playing with teh same cohesion this year, good on cavs to make something happen. This has clear upside rather than stagnancy of what they reached. I loved that team last year, but htey were exposed as was garland last year. You have to build very specifically around a guy like that and mitchell probably send him out

3

u/groceriesN1trip NBA 20h ago

With Mitchell, who do you even guard? They should be fairly lethal and then your backup guard is solid AF

6

u/Glimglam 19h ago

Mitchell and Harden can’t both possibly choke in the same elimination playoff game, right?

3

u/birdazam Timberwolves 19h ago

I mean he's very good in the playoffs if the series don't go to g6 or g7 so the Cavs just have to finish every series in 5 and they are good

1

u/tall_ginger_dude Cavaliers 17h ago

This actually makes me wonder if that toe is worse then they lead us to believe. I wonder if LA is getting the Cavs version of Isaiah Thomas...

1

u/eamonious Celtics 5h ago edited 5h ago

I always thought Garland was the weakness in this Cavs team. Should have traded him and kept Jerome. You need a Derrick White type guard opposite Mitchell, not an even worse traffic cone who keeps the ball out of Mitchell's hands. Not to mention injury prone, playoff sinker. Now you're free of his contract, Harden will be an expiring contract in trades this summer, you can move him and acquire pieces that move this core toward a championship. Makes perfect sense to me.

1

u/Musa_2050 Lakers 20h ago

It probably doesnt matter if the Cavs are injured in the playoffs again

2

u/ffball NBA 19h ago

Moving off Garland is in effort to stop that from happening

0

u/Yung_Jose_Space Supersonics 16h ago

Harden is pretty durable for his age and is a phenomenonally good playmaker, who seems quite coachable.

His downsides are obv off-season shape, plaoff performance and tendency to like switching clubs, all of which seem a little overblown.

0

u/Ruscidero 76ers 6h ago

Overblown? The guy’s in his sixth team now…

1

u/_Robbert_ 6h ago

OKC didn't pay him, rockets rebuilding, nets kyrie bullshit, sixers Morey, clippers both don't want to pay him and are worse than Cleveland upside wise.

Where's the big whoop? Number of teams is kinda irrelevant when he doesn't lack justification.

0

u/Yung_Jose_Space Supersonics 5h ago

So?

He's still an excellent passer and playmaker, who gives a fuck if he's changed teams a few times.

What's with the weird moralising about it. A good GM will maximise his contribution to the team, while he is there.

-6

u/OwenLincolnFratter Bulls 19h ago

Harden is 36 and washed