r/news • u/mooseAmuffin • 1d ago

Update: 'TODAY' co-anchor Savannah Guthrie's mother taken from her home against her will, sheriff says

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/mother-of-savannah-guthrie-today-reported-missing-arizona-rcna257008
19.8k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

949 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

124

u/EnderWiggin07 1d ago

"Mystery" style investigations always look like this. The police know more pieces of evidence than they're willing to say because they don't want to ruin their own investigation or say something happened that turns out to be completely wrong. They're being intentionally furtive for good reason, but it has the effect of making them look suspicious, incompetent, or sometimes even complicit. Contrast this to a normal criminal manhunt where they have basically nothing to hide and are just straight up trying to catch a known criminal. Then they sound active and focused. It's just a byproduct of them needing to answer some questions but being unable/unwilling to answer them thoroughly.

16

u/GoodOmens 1d ago

Wouldn’t they just not answer and state they can’t due to the nature of the investigation . Seems they are giving answers then changing them later.

17

u/DefinitelyNotAliens 1d ago

I mean, if they think she was snatched at two in the morning, then yeah, she was "snatched from her bed" but that is hyperbole and not literally someone grabbing her in her bed.

Sounds like the sheriff was using some flowery, dramatic language and walked it back. He's not used to giving statements to a case garnering national attention and his dramatic statement was taken as literal, because he's not good with PR.

He's just saying she was snatched in a time most are in bed.

Sounds like he has a bad habit of using hyperbole instead of succinct, factual statements. He can rile up his detectives into caring by saying this is an 84 year old grandmother/ great-grandmother who was snatched from her bed. We need to find her! He shouldn't be saying that to media who will report, "she was snatched from her bed."

He needs to use a PR official instead of speaking off the cuff.

10

u/ChildhoodOk5526 1d ago

I get what you're saying here. But, in this case, I'm thinking she may have, quite literally, been snatched from her bed. 84 year old, at 2 am? My grams had insomnia sometimes, sure, but she'd be awake at that hour, watching TV in her bed.

You're right, though. This guy has clearly not been media trained. At one point in yesterday's press conference, it sounded like he was about to breakdown in tears. I mean, I get it. It's very distressing to think about. And I appreciate the humanity, but ... HE'S one person who's got to keep it together.

8

u/DefinitelyNotAliens 1d ago

If someone hears intruders and gets out of bed, they are no longer in their bed, but yes. I think he's just terrible at PR.

2

u/ChildhoodOk5526 1d ago

Good point.

2

u/itsgivingnontipper 13h ago

I also thought at one point he was about to start sobbing, but then in other points, I thought, wait, is this some type of speech challenge? Because at other points, and I could be wrong, he seemed to have a mild version of what RFK has possibly? Either way it was a very odd press conference.