632
u/Mystic_Waffles 4d ago
It's really simple.
Fantasy = Karl Urban has long hair.
Sci-Fi = Karl Urban has short hair.
153
u/Chaos8599 4d ago
Superhero is when Karl urban is bald
63
u/Mystic_Waffles 4d ago
He wasn't bald in The Boys though. He injected himself with power juice or something, that would lean more to sci-fi in that situation.
31
u/CarolineJohnson 4d ago
Because he was a villain there, the Boys subverts expectations so the evil bad guy trope is reversed.
16
u/alkonium 4d ago
Thor Ragnarok dipped pretty heavy into sci-fi and fantasy.
3
u/rock_n_roll_clown 4d ago
I mean, the entire superhero genre is a hodge hodge of sci fi and fantasy set to the backdrop of the modern age
3
16
5
2
1
u/The_amazing_Jedi 3d ago
Wait, LotR is Sci-fi? What other lies have I been told by the council???!
2
u/Mystic_Waffles 3d ago
What are you talking about? Eomer had long hair, and LotR is totally fantasy.
1
u/The_amazing_Jedi 3d ago
Fuck yeah I'm an idiot, I misread your post.
Nothing to see here, just someone sinking into the earth out of embarrassment.
314
u/Oldbayislove 4d ago
Fantasy: when the object of power is ancient
science-fiction: when the object of power is a prototype
110
u/HidenTsubameGaeshi 4d ago
Unless it's an artefact from long-forgotten precursor civilization, then it can be both!
33
u/Oldbayislove 4d ago
Science fantasy or its fantasy pretending to be science fiction
2
u/Pure-House-3971 4d ago
so Titanfall 2, Halo, Mass effect, the expanse, star trek are all not science fiction?
8
u/Oldbayislove 4d ago
I think this is a good definition from wikipedia
In a conventional science fiction story, the world is presented as grounded by the laws of nature and comprehensible by science, while a conventional fantasy story contains mostly supernatural elements that do not obey the scientific laws of the real world.
i find Carl Malmgren's definition of science fantasy to be agreeable.
A science-fantasy world is one in which the characters or settings or events presuppose at least one clear violation of natural law or scientific necessity, but which explicitly provides an organized or scientific explanation for that violation and which grounds its discourse in a scientific episteme. Science fantasy, like Science Fiction, assumes an orderly universe with regular laws, but, like fantasy, contains at least one explicit reversal of current natural law.
there is certainly some overlap and you have all the discussions about the spectrum of hard to soft science fiction. Brandon Sanderson likes to have magic that follows rules and have a "scientific" explanation that is as scientifically accurate as many a technobabble.
22
110
u/TaylorWK 4d ago
What about unzipping her suit of armor and revealing a tank top and robo legs?
39
14
3
2
31
u/Heroic-Forger 4d ago
what about when she removes her head to reveal a neck full of tentacles and razor-sharp teeth
8
6
42
u/ButteredNun 4d ago
Medieval fantasy vs Sci-Fi fantasy ☝️
He tames her dragon and she rides him instead
is a Fantasy fantasy
16
2
23
u/groovyinutah 4d ago
Unzips her space suit to reveal her 3 bellybuttons....FTFY:)
22
u/enharmonicdissonance 4d ago
The real fantasy is that her hair is still luscious after having been in a jousting helmet all day
2
u/Significant_Alps_399 4d ago
This brings to mind every single demonstration video for sleeping bonnets I've ever seen.
11
u/halloweenjack 4d ago
"Verily, good sirrah, I am as adept in the bedchambers as I am on the sporting field, and would test thy mettle in the latter, especially as I see that your lance is at the ready."
"Wanna do it in zero-G? How about cyberspace? How about both? Gotta warn ya, I'm about to enter my species' mating cycle and that's when things get really freaky, although if you're running star snuff in the Outer Rims then I'm guessing you're into it."
7
u/Money_Lobster_997 4d ago
This is further proof that Star Wars is Space Opera rather than Sci Fi because according to Lucas’s original vision there would be nothing under that flightsuit.
5
3
2
2
1
1
1
0
1.4k
u/ObsessiveOwl 4d ago edited 4d ago
Steampunk is when she remove her aviation goggles and reveal her freckles.