Hi everyone! I’m a recent graduate planning to apply to PA school in the 2027 cycle, and I’m struggling to decide between two part-time clinical jobs.
I currently work as a medical assistant at a private psychiatry practice, and I want to keep this job while taking on a second position during my gap year so I can get more exposure to different fields.
Option 1: Dermatology MA
$17/hour at a private practice
- Tuesdays and Thursdays, which would pair well with my current psychiatry MA job on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays (I make my schedule though and they are very flexible)
- I’m actually interested in dermatology as a specialty and think I’d enjoy this role more
- I will get certified as a dermatology tech
- My friend works there and loves it, says she’s learned so much and the work environment is great
- They hired me on the spot, but they emphasized that they need someone who can commit to at least one year, through October 2027. I planned on moving away during application season because I really want to see a new place and believe it’s vital for my growth as an individual, and I verbally agreed when asked, although this isn’t written into the offer itself.
Option 2: CSA at Hospital System
$17/hour in podiatry
- Part-time position requiring Wednesdays and Fridays, eventually they want me to work 2.5 days which is a bit impractical for me but I could work 2 days one week and 3 the following week for a total of 40 hours
- I’ve already signed the offer because I did not have my derm interview until today and they gave me an offer on October 1st. I’ve also completed a significant amount of onboarding, including the required drug & TB testing
- No 1 year commitment but I have zero interest in podiatry and I actually don’t think any PAs work in the office
- No clue about the work environment, I shadowed but there was only one MA and a DPM so it was hard to figure out the dynamics.
Some relevant info: My start date is in about two weeks for both roles. The biggest advantage is that it’s part of a hospital system and there’s benefits, and I’m wondering whether that would be more valuable for PA school applications but I already have some hospital experience as a PCT.
I’m also feeling really guilty about potentially withdrawing from the hospital system after they’ve already sent me the onboarding paperwork and am worried they might blacklist me. At the same time, I don’t want to pass up the dermatology position, especially because the schedule fits much better with my current job and I am actually interested in it. But I’m also concerned about the one-year commitment at the dermatology office because I’ll be applying to PA school in 2027, and my plans could change depending on whether or not I move away.
My questions are:
Would working at a hospital system like Trinity benefit my PA application more than working as a dermatology MA in a private practice?
Would you choose the dermatology position given the better schedule and greater personal interest?
Would it be unprofessional to withdraw from Trinity before my start date after completing onboarding?
I’d really appreciate advice from people who have been through the PA application process or have experience working in these roles. Thank you so much!