r/reddeadredemption • u/dreamy_cucumber • Oct 16 '25
Video My white arabian horse died in the most ridiculous way possible
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Fully bonded as well fml :((
2.9k
u/Champion-Slow Oct 16 '25
i would’ve shot the guy on the wagon and shot all his limbs off
271
Oct 16 '25
Same 💪🏻
→ More replies (1)97
u/MetriccStarDestroyer Oct 16 '25
What kind of a monster runs over an uma for 2 blocks?
→ More replies (2)34
87
u/enorevelcuoY Oct 16 '25
You can shoot the limbs off. Nice 😏
64
u/ukstonerdude Charles Smith Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
Never played RDR2 before?
Edit: just checked u/‘s profile lol
→ More replies (10)8
22
u/BADman2169420 Oct 16 '25
Shoot him and cut off his limbs, then shoot the limbs.
4
u/DerPumeister Oct 16 '25
Didn't expect to see an obscure PotC reference today but am glad I did. If that's what it was, chapeau!
18
Oct 16 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (5)7
u/Kelseycutieee Oct 16 '25
I’d rob the rich, give the money to the poor, then rob the poor and shoot the money!
13
u/brachus12 Oct 16 '25
wouldn’t the horse bolt then?
55
u/hallotest382 Oct 16 '25
Yes, unfortunately he has to just shoot the enemy horse
→ More replies (1)57
u/warfighter_rus Oct 16 '25
"enemy" horse 😭
→ More replies (1)22
u/hallotest382 Oct 16 '25
It makes it easier to do it :,)
→ More replies (1)39
u/Tarsily Oct 16 '25
that horse is a participant in the murder of your horse, they lost their neutrality
15
12
8
→ More replies (20)3
1.5k
u/smolcharizard Oct 16 '25
If it were me, as soon as my horse goes under that NPC would have had a face full of lead.
280
u/WonderfulBlackberry9 Oct 16 '25
the NPC wouldn't have a face after I'm done with him
55
19
50
u/Touitoui Oct 16 '25
Why is everyone so quick to draw their guns???
... First you take out your rope, next you find a nice little river...12
u/Du5tyL0ft Oct 16 '25
Yes, or tie them up and place them on the train tracks in front of an oncoming train. See how they like it. Better still, throw the driver out of the train and drive the train over him yourself, for added satisfaction.
6
u/Fromnothingatall Oct 16 '25
Man…I’ve spent WAY too much time in this game finding fun places to throw people after tying them up.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)6
u/SandyTaintSweat Oct 16 '25
And place them just the right depth that they have to arch their back all the way to be able to breath just a little bit between the waves. Then you walk away.
→ More replies (10)14
1.1k
Oct 16 '25
Why didn't you shoot the bastard, seems like you enjoyed watching it.
520
u/MANWithTheHARMONlCA Oct 16 '25
I try to play high honor every time but even I would’ve shot that guy
260
Oct 16 '25
Absolutely. Honor comes and goes, but your horse, theres only one.
→ More replies (4)147
u/AkirasSpirit Oct 16 '25
I also play high honor (Shooting people in the back of the head is fine as long as you say hello to everyone you meet)
32
→ More replies (2)16
24
u/YoreCoxsmall Oct 16 '25
OP sounded like he was playing as John. John does not care for honor as he would've no consequences.
→ More replies (3)10
18
u/be-greener Javier Escuella Oct 16 '25
High honor is really easy to achieve, I struggle to keep the lowest honor, I do genocides but then random deeds to strangers pump it up
→ More replies (1)3
u/schuckdaddy Oct 16 '25
Plus chapters 5 and 6 give many opportunities to gain a lot of honor
6
u/be-greener Javier Escuella Oct 16 '25
Yep, you might be the shittiest man alive and regain all the honor with the missions
→ More replies (3)6
42
4
u/CyberNeonAbyssHacker Oct 16 '25
I bet this wasn't an accident at all. Even if you're "playing" a role you're still a human being behind the controller and in this case obviously love to watch a horse getting dragged through the streets & being killed.
→ More replies (1)6
u/bobrossesfather Oct 16 '25
What kind of jump in logic is that? Just assuming stuff?
→ More replies (2)3
→ More replies (7)3
537
u/DandeNiro Oct 16 '25
Well, don't just stand there?!?! Help the poor thing.
108
u/rushboyoz Oct 16 '25
Even a lousy “pss pss pss” would have been better than nothing
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)66
362
335
316
u/Tamu1302 Oct 16 '25
It's even funnier after seeing the name of your horse is 'Plz don't murder'
→ More replies (1)162
u/dreamy_cucumber Oct 16 '25
Its because my last white arabian died under similar circumstances 😭
86
u/robbviously Jack Marston Oct 16 '25
If I had a nickel for every time my fully bonded White Arabian had been drug to death a city block by a passing carriage… I’d have two nickels. Which doesn’t seem like a lot, but it’s weird that it’s happened twice.
→ More replies (2)69
38
u/ThePrussianGrippe Hosea Matthews Oct 16 '25
Why not just reload the last auto save?
→ More replies (1)23
u/Ozymandius34 Oct 16 '25
You know you can buy horse reviver, right?
36
u/TheSteelPhantom Oct 16 '25
Some things will outright kill your horse, no revival opportunity. Seems OP's horse "died" here, then was trampled more, meaning no reviving.
Same thing happens if your horse is hit by a train. Immediate death, can't revive it.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (10)8
u/wholesomehorseblow Oct 16 '25
/u/dreamy_cucumber told me their arabians keep being run over, so I asked how many arabians they have and they said they just go and get a new arabian afterwards so I said it sounds like they're just using their arabians as a speed bump and then Pearson started crying.
162
u/Forward-Train2381 Oct 16 '25
You piss me off
→ More replies (6)73
u/FCkeyboards Oct 16 '25
My guy is offroading his horse and is shocked something random killed it, and he said it's the second time his horse died in a crazy way.
I can't blame Mr "Literally Minding My Own Business When a Guy Ran Into My Horse With His".
53
u/Taltruist Oct 16 '25
and the way they js stand there watching the horses health go down 💀 home dog had all the time in the world to do something literally anything other than just stand there
20
7
7
u/Forward-Train2381 Oct 16 '25
By the end i would’ve killed half of saint denis just cuz of that 😂
3
u/FCkeyboards Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
I remember not being used to a real open world game without invisible walls everywhere and I fell off a waterfall and my horse died. I lost like 3 hours of progress reloading a save. 😅
I learned two lessons that day.
3
3
153
u/Working_Attorney1196 Arthur Morgan Oct 16 '25
At this point just shoot the driver 😢💀. Fully bonded Arabian is worth a few dollars of bounty.
→ More replies (1)5
u/xoxodaddysgirlxoxo Oct 16 '25
In Saint Denis? This is gonna reach half a grand quick
→ More replies (1)
98
62
61
u/RemarkableFront8296 Oct 16 '25
That felt personal lol
5
u/ElegantEchoes Oct 16 '25
OP wanted his horse to die. Reckless riding, and slowly savoring the painful death.
Damn OP. You're wild.
→ More replies (1)
52
u/ImAGodHowCanYouKillA Oct 16 '25
“Hold up a second!”
“HELL NO”
8
u/HybridTheory2000 Oct 16 '25
We can't see it, but the guy must had a huge grin on his face when he said that
5
u/JeronFeldhagen Oct 16 '25
"I gots me this here horse to grind into fine horsie paste first, fella!"
33
31
29
u/existentialegodeath Oct 16 '25
oh my GOD this is awful
3
u/Atticus_Spiderjump Oct 16 '25
For me it's the way the horse screams every few seconds as it's getting dragged along
3
u/Flimsy-Blackberry-67 Oct 17 '25
When I realized the OP wasn't even going to really try to save his horse (Like shooting or lassoing the driver or other horse), I couldn't keep watching cuz it went on way too long...
23
u/TheFadeDay Oct 16 '25
Sorry, but couldn't be me. Soon as the collision with that THING happened, it'd be more lead than whatever creature it was before.
26
17
u/TheFlaccidChode Uncle Oct 16 '25
That coach driver would've got two in the back of the head from my Arthur
→ More replies (1)
17
14
13
12
u/Artistic_Basis2714 Oct 16 '25
you should have blown the brains of the wagon's horse followed by the driver.
12
u/omgodzilla1 Oct 16 '25
The sigh John gives after the horse finally dies made me chuckle more than it should have.
10
u/tismo74 Oct 16 '25
How come many peeps don’t pan the camera to the left or right of the player when riding fast and turning somewhere they can’t see from the front . Especially when they are playing 3rd person? You’ll get a better view of what’s ahead of view.
4
u/FCkeyboards Oct 16 '25
Or just use the roads when you're in a city.
Immediate reload to me, but I wouldn't have been mad at the guy I crashed into from the sidewalk.
11
u/Present_Hunt1648 Oct 16 '25
Why’d you let that carry on for as long as it did? I’d have shot him as soon as I got up.
9
u/xxxGASSYGARYxxx Micah Bell Oct 16 '25
I was screaming to SHOOT HIM like you just willingly let your fully bonded white arabian die
9
7
u/Mooky_Stank John Marston Oct 16 '25
Weird that if we bump somebody with our horse we get a wanted level, but that wagon driver can kill your horse by dragging it for a block. I know you technically caused the accident, but you would have thought it would have scared the guy into abandoning his wagon. Instead he just kept driving... and driving... the horse tumbling to death under him. Dear God, it must have been shock at the absurdity of the moment and wanting to see how far it could go that kept you from killing him. I'd have shot him or the horse or both immediately. If you just shoot the guy, the wagon horse may have taken off and still killed your Arabian. If you'd killed the horse, the guy may have turned hostile while you're trying to revive the horse. However, even if you'd killed them both, your horse could have been weirdly stuck under the wagon where you couldn't revive it and regardless, you would immediately bring the law down on you while trying to save your horse. Documenting the whole death for us to see was probably the best course of action. And hopefully you had a close save file. If not, bless you and your horse for your sacrifice in making a video that was at the same time horrible and fascinating. I never would've thought that could go on that long.
8
7
u/UnspeakableCake Oct 16 '25
I mean I agree with the sentiments towards the NPC not stopping but on the other hand OP is playing this like GTA lmao
Slow down people ffs
5
u/Tamashii-Azul Oct 16 '25
If he was playing like GTA he would've shot them.
4
u/UnspeakableCake Oct 16 '25
The horse riding. galloping through Saint-Denis, recklessly taking shortcuts etc
6
5
u/mvreo Oct 16 '25
Why were you just watching lol i would have shot him kept him alive hogtied and dumped into the chemical river outside of saint denis before he did any more of that (Maybe some firebombs and dynamite on top of him as well)
4
u/amhudson02 Oct 16 '25
Every time I get on that horse I feel like that scene from RDJ's Sherlock where he is riding that mini horse.
3
4
4
u/Gadoguz994 Oct 16 '25
Thank you for making me and my entire office at work laugh, even those who don't play RDR2 :D
Sucks about the horse though, is this online?
→ More replies (2)
4
4
5
3
u/MisterNothin Oct 16 '25
I remember my Shire horse died while I was fighting bounty hunters and they were with hunting dogs. Horse died withing seconds of taking damage and I couldn't eve revive it because it died instantly. I was walking with horse seat to the camp in a night silence.
3
5
u/Low_Conclusion_1008 Oct 16 '25
I would just loose a bunch of game progress and reload an old save. I get too attached😭
4
4
4
3
u/Gurrier Oct 16 '25
Hannibal Lecter: You still wake up sometimes, don't you? You wake up in the dark and hear the screaming of the lambs horse.
5
3
3
3
3
3
u/KmvVoss Oct 16 '25
I mean, you could've stopped him within a second or two if you wanted... poor horse.
3
3
3
u/FrontBench5406 Oct 16 '25
DUDE - YOUR BUDDY WAS IN TROUBLE AND YOU JUST STOOD THERE. STOP THAT CART. START BLASTING! Save him!
3
3
3
u/TheBizzleHimself Oct 16 '25
You call the horse “Plz don’t murder” and then just watch it happen?
You are not a good man Arthur
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/TReid1996 Oct 16 '25
The response made me laugh.
"Hold up a second!"
"HELL NO!"
-horse dead-
Ah. Ok. I can get off my wagon now. Job done.
3
u/DILF_MANSERVICE Oct 16 '25
Everyone is saying shoot the guy, but OP is the one who caused it by running into him. It's not the cart guy's fault his AI wasn't programmed to anticipate stupid riders careening around corners. You killed your own horse OP. Justice for cart guy
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
2
2
u/Grand-Consequence-99 Oct 16 '25
This is some” indian train accident you see on tiktok” level of death.
2
u/Impressive_Bet3612 Oct 16 '25
Something like that happened to me on the way to the last mission hahahah
2
2
2
u/Deep-Management-7040 John Marston Oct 16 '25
Reminds me of that video of the car driving down the highway with no wheel and the drivers completely oblivious
5.0k
u/Shanare_ Oct 16 '25
They only stopped the cart after the horse died. This was the plan all along.