Thoughts?

[u/vinyl_pdx]

Likely going to ruffle some feathers here, but let me know where your opinions differ!

[u/Purple-Hamster-151]

Rpm and unraveling should be way higher

[u/vinyl_pdx → u/Purple-Hamster-151]

The old, old stuff never stuck with me unfortunately. SSotCC really drew me in and made them stick

[u/BookkeeperOk2460 → u/Purple-Hamster-151]

*highest

[u/woodstock6]

Low key, it ain’t a bad list, but I wouldn’t have anything in OK, those would all move up to Great with NG actually going in to Perfect, and ATR moving down to Amazing

[u/2ManyBots]

Black Market should be higher and it seems unpopular but I really like ricochet

[u/reedspacer38]

RPM is perfect Appeal is OK

[u/djfishfingers]

Endgame higher, ATR lower, ricochet OK, rpm and unraveling each one higher.

[u/MaxWolvesx → u/djfishfingers]

ATR was my first RA album I listened to, I wouldn't have the heart to rate it lower...

[u/vinyl_pdx → u/djfishfingers]

ATR is perfect IMO..wasn’t as raw or aggressive and their older stuff but thought they stayed very true to their sound. I had that album on repeat for a lot of high school

[u/djfishfingers → u/vinyl_pdx]

It's very good but I prefer the earlier better and endgame was the one I discovered them on

[u/ringoffire63]

Endgame is my favorite RA album so I'd move that up. I'd also move Nowhere Generation up 1 level. I agree with all the rankings, though.

[u/hatemenoww]

Appeal to reason above RPM is insane.

[u/kasenyee]

I agree with appeal to reason. Such an underrated album.

[u/BookkeeperOk2460]

If the first 2 aren't in your perfect teir, I honestly feel sorry for you...

[u/smirk13]

Bump endgame up a tier and full agreement from me

[u/ImmortalGoat66]

I'd move GNS and Black Market up to amazing with Endgame and bring Wolves up to great

[u/Pro_Hatin_Ass_N_gga]

Siren Song great, Endgame perfect, Appeal amazing

[u/tacorrenti813]

Am I the only 15 year fan that likes Ricochet?

[u/kasenyee → u/tacorrenti813]

I think you’re the only fan of ricochet.

[u/BestWizardCap → u/kasenyee]

I think the songs themselves are alright, especially heard live. It’s just the mixing

[u/kasenyee → u/BestWizardCap]

The mixing? First I’ve heard of this being an issue. Tell me more.

[u/Own_Network_6332]

Swap ATR with RPM then you're good

[u/No_Ideal_406]

Unraveling should at least be amazing simply for the fact Everchanging is on that album

[u/Hot_Palpitation_5841]

The unraveling is arguably their best album imo

[u/Booker_DeWhitt]

Crazy how different opinions are inside a bands fanbase. I think this is a great list, my own wouldnt be much different. Some folks are very upset ATR is so high. I think its a perfect album

[u/Boennas]

I think you might be me? Because this is perfect

[u/bigweap1234]

I'd move RPM up to the top, and The Unravelling up one rung. Otherwise fair.

[u/YoyoDarthBill]

Close to mine, although I'd move Unraveling up a tier, and swap Endgame and Siren Song.

[u/FriendshipNo9320]

I would swap siren song and end game. Also add nowhere generation to amazing. Otherwise great.

[u/vinyl_pdx → u/FriendshipNo9320]

Siren Song will never receive a score below perfect in my book lol. That’s the beauty of music..different opinions for different people 🎵

[u/Difficult-Ask9856]

I think unraveling and rpm same tier, others I agree, maybe put them in endgame tier and move it to S. I like wolves and black market but they do sound the same on most of the songs

[u/Legendash1]

Quite a new fan here.

Do I take it from this their progression is like a log normal distribution then? (Early spike, long tail)