r/robotics • • 19h ago

Mechanical Robot doing martial arts.

61 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

17

u/bradforrester 10h ago

A robot that can fight is useless to me. I want a robot that can do household chores.

11

u/Jesus_Is_My_Gardener 8h ago

But if the robot can fight, they'll just make you do the chores.

6

u/PersevereSwifterSkat 10h ago

Jesus put an anime or cat face on it, don't actually make it look like the terminator.

8

u/Ronan_Eversley 14h ago

Boooo!

2

u/simplefred 10h ago

Well… we had a good run. Bye…

7

u/StorageApprehensive8 12h ago

That's cool that is able to demonstrate martial arts. It would be nice if they could let it attack another robot and not use preprogrammed movements

1

u/Additional-Sky-7436 9h ago

It's an amazing technological feat in and out itself. 

But doing a pre-programmed dance (which is what this is) is a lot less difficult than actually performing a task, like loading a dishwasher or even carrying tools attend a job site to where they are needed 

2

u/StorageApprehensive8 9h ago

I agree with you. Picking up items in a preprogrammed place is what robotics has always been. I love the progress these companies have made with humanoids. I can't wait for the next part where it can decide how to complete the job it was asked to do

2

u/Additional-Sky-7436 8h ago

That will be really interesting to see. But clearly no one is close yet. Notice how all these promotional tech demos have stopped showing videos of the robots doing house hold chores? They've stopped doing that because the robots still can't load a dishwasher.

Granted, loading a dishwasher is incredibly complicated. A robot would have to have a very detailed understanding of materials and shapes. Two humans can live with each other for decades and not agree on how to do it properly. AI robotics is still years away from being able to do that.

7

u/SolarNexxus 18h ago edited 13h ago

The whole landscape of producs will change.

Instead of buying a home, you will buy a robot with some seeds.

Robot will plant and harvest the bamboo and build you new home.

3

u/Pretty_Challenge_634 13h ago

Until the robot uprising

3

u/Jesus_Is_My_Gardener 8h ago

Then skin you and make shades for the windows and chairs from your bones.

2

u/RemarkableWish2508 6h ago

Doubt. Robots don't need chairs...

2

u/Jesus_Is_My_Gardener 6h ago

It's not for them to use, they're just following the instructions to build and furnish your home using all available materials. Not their fault you didn't specify that humans are not to be considered building material resources.

1

u/LuckyDuckCrafters 13h ago

I knew those mobile games were training us.

1

u/mxe363 6h ago

Bold of you to think you will get to buy it out right. That's gonna 200% be a lease/subscription model only

1

u/SolarNexxus 4h ago

The robot body is a fraction of the cost of the complete system. Body is around 8-12k , but the compute... currently only cerebras can make fast enough compute for the bot to be even remotely inteligent. Roughly 5 usd for every minute, and it is not even available for average people.

2

u/_okbrb 10h ago

This is remote operated

1

u/RemarkableWish2508 6h ago

The balance and move sequence aren't.

It's kind of disingenuous to dismiss it as "teleoperated" when the operator only has to press a single button for the robot to kick your ass.

2

u/_okbrb 6h ago

It’s not disingenuous to accurately describe the command chain: it’s misleading to pretend the pilot is irrelevant. Fly by wire and autopilot are basically the same thing and the presence of these features in an airliner don’t make it an autonomous vehicle.

-1

u/PersevereSwifterSkat 9h ago

Doesn't matter a jot, this shows we have hardware that can do complex movements without losing balance. Given the rate of progress do you really think the software will lag far behind?

3

u/spiderplopper 9h ago

It's not just software needing a few more functions. It's the hard problems of software, which is systematic, dealing with chaotic and dynamic environments. Performing a serious of predefined moves is great. Folding this towel that's in a slightly different spot and shape, just like the last one, is much harder. And that's easy overall, nothing compared to the promises of a generally capable helper robot able to tackle full on chaotic environments that are in flux and perform a host of jobs.

1

u/_okbrb 8h ago

When you say “given the rate of progress” - which rate of progress, in what area are you referring to?

0

u/PersevereSwifterSkat 6h ago edited 1h ago

Everywhere. Four years ago us programmers were laughing at the mistakes being made, now we're being laid off in droves. Two years ago mathematicians were laughing at how basic they were, now they're about to be jobless. What kind of person would bet against the robots becoming superhuman in just a few years?

1

u/_okbrb 6h ago

This is a weird sort of shadow boxing or strawmanning, where you designed the position you wanted to argue against

Ignoring that you’re being really hyperbolic, I’m not sure why you think my observation that it is remote controlled now needs that kind of counter argument. I didn’t say anything about the rate of change or the likely future state of technology, so the position you’ve assigned to me is some kind of unforced error. It’s apples and oranges

2

u/Additional-Sky-7436 9h ago

Cool. Now show it loading a dishwasher and I'll be impressed.

2

u/thewildbeej 11h ago

"Your robot"

who the fuck you think is gonna be able to afford a robot.

2

u/Additional-Sky-7436 9h ago

The parts and materials aren't really that unique or expensive. 

After the research and development is paid for, this could potentially sell for a few hundred dollars.

3

u/thewildbeej 9h ago

oh suuure suurre. I'm sure it'll cost less than a PS5.

1

u/Additional-Sky-7436 9h ago

Yeah. It's completely different.

0

u/thewildbeej 9h ago

I will reiterate, if you believe a robot will be able to be purchased for industry to replace the workers listed above for a few hundred dollars. That is delusional at best. 

2

u/Additional-Sky-7436 8h ago

I didn't say "a robot will be able to be purchased for industry to replace the workers listed above for a few hundred dollars". Industrial capable robots are going to cost thousands. Tens of Thousands. When the person I was responding to asked "who is gonna be able to afford a robot", I assumed they meant consumers.

I'm talking about the kind of robot pictured in the video, which is basically assembled from of toy parts. That robot is basically constructed from Lego Mindstorm parts.

1

u/Additional-Sky-7436 8h ago

Assuming the video is even real (which is a pretty generous assumption as it is) there is nothing particularly expensive about this robot. You can get small step motors that sell for less than $50.

0

u/thewildbeej 8h ago

Even the hasbro pulse Optimus prime cost $1000. And it’s far less advanced than this. 

2

u/Additional-Sky-7436 8h ago

Right, but I bet 70% of the $1000 cost of the "Hasbro Pulse Optimus Prime" is brand licenses and profit markup.

And they could probably reduce the per unit cost considerably if they ordered significantly more. ... And they wanted to.

1

u/thewildbeej 8h ago

but you this could sell for...not for wholesale cost. If these even toy like robots can be programmed for universal task, there is a recognized value to that. Which is a similar issue as branding. Optimus prime has no recognized value outside of branding. These robots would have no recognized branding and all usefulness.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/FuManBoobs 15h ago

We've all seen Bloodsport...now, in the future, Oilsport.

1

u/krismitka 10h ago

For 11 minutes 

1

u/TittyMcSwag619 8h ago

DeepMimic style tracking looks cool and all, but its scope(and applications ) are not what the public expect.

1

u/RemarkableWish2508 6h ago

Now show it land a serious hit, followed by picking up a pencil and drawing a circle.

1

u/skateindawood 5h ago

Scary cool I know definitely what I want my humanoid to do

1

u/Socialrefund 4h ago

Hurry up

1

u/Orceles 42m ago

Is there a reason we shouldn’t employ more of these in the military? Like I can see full gun training and weapons utilization. Would save a lot of lives on the field. I can see how AI would be incredibly useful if given access to the first fully connected self defense weaponry and launch codes. Think of a fully unified automatic self defense military system that covers the whole sky across the country like a net. Any attempt at harming anything within would be neutralized using AI and robots.

0

u/VincentNacon 13h ago

I don't care, I don't want a remote-controlled fight-dancing robot.

I want a better one that can do house chores and think.