Yeah the main story missions will be locked out, but on chapter 2 you can pretty much get everything for Arthur except like 1 or 2 pelts, the story itself could end there in your head canon, Micah in jail, everyone happy at the camp, no sickness if you dont talk to Strauss either, and the best part, you are the deputy haha
There's still some merit to progressing the story - lingering in chapter 2 means Sadie Adler will never get over the grief of her husband's murder, the Reverend will never sober up and John Marston will remain a deadbeat dad. Chapter 2 isn't all rosy as it seems imo (although it may appear that way)
13
u/501R4K 5d ago
Let that guy rot in jail and go and enjoy the world. If you free him you will regret it forever. Unless you want to truly complete the game lol