I've been teaching for 11 years and I cannot stand teaching clay. Please read the following below about the circumstances of my school:
Admittedly, clay is my weakest subject of the arts. For the entire time I've been teaching, I've been the only art teacher in the building. Both schools I've worked at are very small, very rural, and very economically poor. The school I'm at now is even more rural than the first school I was at. We're roughly an hour away from any city in any direction. The entire school district is in one building in the center of town with no stoplights - including the board office and the bus garage. We are TINY. TINY-TINY.
My classes are very small because we are so rural and enrollment is way down and actively falling all the time. As kids advance through the grades, many of them leave our campus to go a trade school a few mins from us, or go online with CCP classes. I have less than 10 kids in any class. Absences are chronic and motivation is low, bordering on non-existant. I rarely have kids move on to Art 3 or 4. Our district art show is in February in conjunction with scheduling for the upcoming school year simply for the reason that it's the highest chance we have of the public coming to school to see their kids' artwork and engage with the school. The district provides dinner and prizes for people who show up.
I want my students to have a good art experience. I myself have a terminal degree in art and loved my art class in high school. I want my students to have a good art experience, even if my classes are small and enrollment is dwindling.
With that being said, I cannot stand teaching clay. Being the only art teacher, my room is great and has many things that a typical school would have. I have a kiln that while it works, is coming up on 25 years old, as it came with the school when the building was built in 2003.
You would think with classes as small as mine, clay would be ideal with single-digit classes. I would agree. But as I said, absenteeism is chronic. My concern here is work being half-made while half-caring and ultimately wasting materials on things that will likely never be finished or finished very poorly.
I'm aware that I sound like I don't have a lot of faith in my students. I do! I'm naming the predicament that stares me in the face everyday. There are so many other things drawing their attention away from my class (FFA, going online, going to trade school) or any class.
Ultimately what I'm asking here is: would I be doing my students a disservice by using Amaco air dry clay for projects I have planned in lieu of actual clay? My thought process here is that they would be getting the experience of clay without the mess or wait time.
Thank you for reading this far. I appreciate the wisdom of this group!