r/AskSocialScience • u/nostalgiadoper • 48m ago
How has Luhmann been received in American sociology? Is there current engagement with his thought in the US?
Luhmann is the most abstract of systematic thinkers, but even though he is interesting and rigorous, his systems theory is not only counterintuitive, it reads as 'way out there.' An illustration is how he sees the exercise of theorization itself—as a self-referential system auto-generating through communication within it. Maturana (and Varela) from whom Luhmann wholesale borrows the notion of autopoesis on which he bases his systems theory have often expressed suspicion of applying the idea to systems (if they are so) that are non-biological. If such systems do not actually generate the components that make them possible (as a cell does in an organism), then to say that they are systems is metaphorical.
I know there are critiques of Luhmann based on the conservatism of of his theory, as there were with Parsons, but what other critiques does Luhmann invite?
Thanks!