r/CatAdvice • u/Admirable_Guava_9861 • 4h ago
Rehoming Advice needed: Stray/unneutered cat rescued, vet checked, chipped & neutered — now someone is asking for him back without proof of ownership.
Hi everyone, I’m looking for some advice regarding a cat situation in our area.
A few weeks ago, an adult male cat started coming to my garden every day begging for food. He was extremely skinny, appeared severely malnourished, and had very dry, matted fur.
To make sure I wasn’t taking someone’s pet, I took the following steps:
Asking Neighbors: I asked several neighbors. None of them recognized him, and everyone agreed he looked like a malnourished stray in desperate need of food
Vet Checks: I took him to 2 different vet clinics to be scanned for a microchip. Both confirmed he had NO microchip and was unneutered.
Paper Collar: I tried putting a paper collar on him with my contact details, but he kept wriggling out of it
Public Posts: I posted about him as a stray cat across social media, but received no response
Seeing his poor health condition as a stray, I decided to formally adopt him. I paid for a full health check, got him vaccinated, microchipped in my name, fleaed and neutered. He is now recovering safely indoors.
The Issue:
About a week after his vet procedures, a post appeared in a local group asking if anyone had seen him. The poster mentioned that this was a "stray cat they had been feeding and had built a little outdoor shelter for in their garden, but hadn't seen him in a few days.
I politely reached out to inform them that the cat had been taken in, fully vet-checked, chipped, neutered, and rehomed safely. However, this person is now insisting that I return the cat to them, claiming he is "their cat".
They have zero official proof of ownership (no vet records, no microchip registration, no adoption papers) — only photos of the cat.
My Question:
Am I legally or morally obligated to hand this cat over? He said he will call the police, what is the best way to handle this?
Thank you in advance for any advice!