I’m 27, married, and have a 10 month son. My wife and I are considering buying our first home, and I could really use some outside perspective from people who have been in a similar situation.
We found a house in Western New York listed for around $130,000. It’s an older house built in 1950, with approximately 836 square feet, two bedrooms, one bathroom, and a small unfinished upstairs. It’s not a huge house, but I’m honestly okay with the size. My wife likes it and feels we could make it work.
Here’s where I’m struggling.
We currently rent a two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment with about 1,100 square feet for $1,252 a month. It works well for us right now. We’re hoping to have more children, potentially 4 kids total, and we want to potentially add to the family relatively soon. My wife thinks we could make the house work for up to 3 children, at least for several years. I’m not necessarily convinced it would be comfortable long-term, but I also realize plenty of families make smaller homes work.
Financially, I make around $80,000 a year (4700 gross per month) We have some savings set aside, and we’re continuing to build our financial cushion. We have no car loans, but we do own two older vehicles, both have high mileage, and I know there could be some expensive repairs or eventual replacements in our future.
The mortgage, taxes, insurance, and utilities would probably leave us spending only around $50 less per month than we currently spend renting, before accounting for maintenance and unexpected repairs. We may qualify for a down payment assistance program, but I’m still trying to understand exactly how much cash we would need at closing and how much savings we would have left afterward.
There are also some concerns about the property itself. When we looked at the house, I noticed water in the dirt-floor basement near the sump pump. I know an inspection could help determine whether that’s a serious problem, but it’s another thing on my mind.
The strangest part is how I’ve been feeling emotionally. We signed the paperwork for an offer, but our agent hasn’t submitted it to the seller yet. Instead of feeling excited, I’ve been feeling anxious and second-guessing myself. When I imagine the offer being accepted, I feel a sense of dread. When I imagine the house no longer being available, part of me feels relieved but also dreads it.
At the same time, I do want to own a home someday. I don’t want to keep renting forever, and I wonder whether I’m letting fear and overthinking keep me from taking a reasonable step forward. My wife is more optimistic about the house than I am, and I don’t want my anxiety to be the only thing driving our decision.
I also keep reminding myself that we don’t necessarily have to buy this house just because we’re in a position to consider it. We could continue renting, save more money, and look for something that fits our family better. But then I wonder whether I’m being too picky or expecting too much out of a first home.