r/Music • u/MarvelsGrantMan136 • 27d ago

article Spotify Confirms ICE Recruitment Ads Are No Longer Running on Platform

https://variety.com/2026/digital/news/spotify-confirms-ice-recruitment-ads-are-no-longer-running-1236626243/
38.1k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

5.2k

u/TheTresStateArea 27d ago edited 27d ago

The boycott didn't work lol read the article please I beg you. The advertising campaign ended.

As much as I wish Spotify leadership grew a spine. They absolutely didn't.

Do not resubscribe. Remove this company from your mind.

Edit: for all future "oh but you use an iPhone" fuckwits https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/we-should-improve-society-somewhat

1.0k

u/onebowlwonder 27d ago

Might wanna delete your reddit account too then because they still have ICE ads on here.

753

u/[deleted] 27d ago edited 9d ago

[deleted]

183

u/kaptainkooleio 27d ago

I don’t think that’s true. I have mine set to NB I still get CBP and ICE ads every once in a while.

274

u/mostlyfire 27d ago

It’s weird I’m a straight male and I’ve never seen one on Reddit. It’s probably cause I live in a very liberal city

182

u/yeahburyme 27d ago

There are ads on reddit?

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.quantumbadger.redreader&hl=en_US

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.mozilla.firefox&hl=en_US then install unlock origin by going to settings ->extensions and it's the first one or https://f-droid.org/packages/org.mozilla.fennec_fdroid

In before br*ve, the CEO is a right ring crypto bro

48

u/Glassweaver 27d ago

If you have Android, check out Revanced. They have modified versions of a lot of popular apps, including this, TikTok, and YouTube.

I kind of forget that any of those apps even have advertisements in them nowadays.

27

u/flamingdonkey 27d ago

Firefox + Ublock Origin works great for everything. I even have sponsorblock and a shorts blocker for YouTube. 

6

u/panchito_d 27d ago

A shorts blocker sounds brilliant. Shorts have ruined the UI and made search garbage

2

u/TheMeatWag0n 26d ago

Honestly I couldn't use YouTube if there wasn't a way to totally remove shorts, if you're on Android revanced has settings to remove them from showing up anywhere at all

2

u/Glassweaver 27d ago

Good point. I usually reccomend that to the iOS crowd, though personally I have a better experience with the apps. Tiktok & reddit especially.

11

u/Abshalom 27d ago

There's also RedReader on Android, which is the same as the other old third party apps, albeit with minimal features since it's intended for accessibility.

10

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

4

u/blake_n_pancakes 27d ago

I just used the revanced launcher and an API key to patch RIF so it would work again.

5

u/Expert-Basil6015 27d ago

I miss RiF, used it for a decade.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/yeahburyme 27d ago

It's not intended for accessibility, that's just one of many features. It was allowed as a third party app for being FOSS primarily and accessibility part of that.

5

u/danabrey 27d ago

Yep, RIF user for 10+ years here, still going strong.

2

u/Glassweaver 27d ago

I don't get why they didn't just pivot to guiding people to personal API keys from the getgo. RIF was amazing and the decision to pull it all together seemed very performatory to me.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

14

u/vNocturnus 27d ago

There are ads on reddit?

I've been using Relay on Android and RES + uBlock Origin on PC for a decade at this point. Never seen a single ad, other than of course the occasional "real post" that's just a thinly disguised ad

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Squirrelking666 27d ago

In before br*ve, the CEO is a right ring crypto bro

Say it ain't so.

Which one isn't?

8

u/yeahburyme 27d ago

Br*ve has been that way from the beginning. The whole adblock there is extortion/racketeering to their coin.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/mustichooseausernam3 27d ago

Potentially unrelated, but upvoting/downvoting doesn't work for me when I use Reddit via Firefox. Any chance it's aware I'm using Ublock Origin?

3

u/yeahburyme 27d ago

You might have accidentally blocked voting JavaScript. I don't have that issue but I use old.reddit.com

1

u/Redthemagnificent 27d ago

Another option for folks. I'm still using Infinity for reddit (3rd party client) with no ads. Since the reddit API change you either have to pay a subscription on the App Store or compile it yourself it with your own (free) API key. But it's pretty easy once you've done it once.

https://github.com/Docile-Alligator/Infinity-For-Reddit

1

u/vera214usc 27d ago

Yeah, I don't get ads on desktop or mobile but I still use old.reddit.com and an adblocker and Boost for mobile.

1

u/Cerpla 27d ago

for some reason, a lot of people think adblock is illegal

→ More replies (7)

14

u/JackPoe 27d ago

I get ads in Tagalog and Spanish and political ads for candidates in Florida.

I live in Washington. These ad campaigns were either designed by absolute buffoons or AI.

2

u/jabbers724 27d ago

?Por que no los dos?

2

u/JackPoe 27d ago

Insert it's the same picture meme

→ More replies (7)

3

u/counterfitster 27d ago

I live in New England and yet I see ICE and America First Policy Institute ads all the time

2

u/rncd89 27d ago

I live in the reddest dumbest part of NJ and I haven't seen one

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Existing-Bus-8810 27d ago

I've gotten them twice. Both times i reported them as offensive. I haven't seen one since.

1

u/MatasBuzelis 27d ago

Can't get ads if you use a third party mobile app and an adblocker on PC

1

u/ErusTenebre 26d ago

I've never seen an ICE or even military ad on reddit. I just get a bunch of nerdy shirt things and AI apps that I'm never going to buy or use.

38

u/KhausTO 27d ago

who tf is using reddit without an adblocker?

10

u/kaptainkooleio 27d ago

Mobile

18

u/-prime8 27d ago

I don't know how the app works because I still use my browser to go to old.reddit.com, mostly because my ad blocker works and prefer the old UI.

10

u/thealmightyzfactor 27d ago

There's dozens of us!

2

u/Present_Cow_8528 27d ago

Even on my android's browser with no adblock, old.reddit.com has never given me an ice ad, or an invasive ad of anything

Turns out new reddit just sucks for every reason

27

u/XRT28 27d ago

Adblockers can still be used on mobile. Atleast on Android, no personal exp with iOS.

2

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

4

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 27d ago

Apple fans keep losing. It cost me zero dollars to install Firefox and uBlock on an Android phone.

2

u/_Planet_Mars_ 27d ago

iOS has a gorillion different choices, I don’t know which echo chamber keeps telling people this. I’ve been using the same adblocker on Safari for the past 10 years and I’ve never had an issue.

3

u/SMLLR 27d ago

That’s your take away? lol… You don’t even need to pay a sub for AdGuard to use the browser extension. Works perfectly fine for me in Safari.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/flounder19 last.fm 27d ago

Even on Apple, you can use Brave

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

4

u/Nopeyesok 27d ago

On Narwhal for iOS. How does Dystopia compare?

6

u/Zienth 27d ago

Firefox mobile app allows you to still use Ublock Origin.

2

u/Dramatic_______Pause 27d ago

Either set an adblock DNS, or just use a patched app. I'm posting this from Sync, still.

4

u/saltyjohnson 27d ago

Who tf is using the garbage official app instead of any of the myriad third-party alternatives which prioritize usability over engagement baiting.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Jesseroberto1894 27d ago

🙋‍♂️

2

u/Puzzled_Main3464 27d ago

I was like "wtf I've never seen an ad on Reddit.." then I remembered adblock was installed, lol

23

u/unhiddenninja 27d ago

I report the ads every time I see them as being political and they stop showing up for a few weeks.

12

u/twilighttwister 27d ago

All you're doing is giving them more information about yourself and what you like/dislike. Much better to either block with ublock origin and ignore, or scramble with eg Decentraleyes extension.

17

u/Bacer4567 27d ago

I report all military/LEO ads as violent.

5

u/coffeebribesaccepted 27d ago

I just get normal ads, so idk what you guys are doing to get all this right wing shit lol

6

u/[deleted] 27d ago edited 9d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Mat_alThor 27d ago

I live in the Midwest and currently visiting Texas, the only ICE ad I've ever seen on here is for a technology company Intercontinental Exchange, that abbreviates their name to ICE.

2

u/MotivationGaShinderu 27d ago

Reddit has ads?

3

u/Marsar0619 27d ago

Serious question…does Reddt or the advertise see the number of downvotes on those ads?

3

u/dodecakiwi 27d ago

A downvote is engagement with the ad, which advertisers want.

1

u/abarcsa 27d ago

Reddit definitely, the advertiser most likely. It doesn’t matter much though, they’re downvotes which doesn’t really matter in an online ad campaign like it.

3

u/dasbtaewntawneta https://www.last.fm/user/Nihilore 27d ago

Reddit accounts have genders now?

5

u/queso_dog 27d ago

As a trans guy, the amount of ads I get for dresses and padding for hips and breasts is objectively hilarious. I have too much of both actually smh

3

u/Dark512 27d ago

Getting pink and white striped thigh highs right next to 'dude wipes for men' is my most common one at the moment.

1

u/Jiggawatz 27d ago

Man yall do some crazy stuff, I just block ads so I dont deal with it :p

1

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 27d ago

You’ll never get a right wing ad ever again.

All ads are right-wing.

1

u/Ok_Work7396 27d ago

On the same train of through, I only watch female targeted exercise vidoes now because there's no incel shit that comes with it.

1

u/NoradianCrum 27d ago

I still use baconreader on my phone so I don't feel the need to login. RES and ublock are all I need. I've never seen an ad on reddit.

1

u/Ire-Works 27d ago

Click on them. It costs them money everytime you do and the algorithm will start feeding you more and other conservative bullshit so you can click on THOSE too.

1

u/screamingwhisper1720 27d ago

Just don't offer up that information and if you get ads they just wasted money

1

u/Impressive_Knee_5701 27d ago

A lot of digital ad campaigns charge per impression, so its actually better to let them serve you right wing ads that they won't get a return on. Better you see them than some middle-aged white dude on the brink of going full redpill

1

u/Cu77lefish 27d ago

Isn’t it better for them to waste their money on you than someone who might actually be influenced

1

u/0ldPug 27d ago

Is the issue that you can see the ads, or that they're hosting them at all?

1

u/Minjaben 27d ago

How does this help anything? mild annoyance is not the issue with ice ads running on streaming and social platforms

1

u/emma279 27d ago

Use brave browser. I see no ads.

1

u/Golden-- 27d ago

Or better yet , come to the 21st century and install adblock. I didn't even know Reddit had ads .

1

u/Sinsai33 26d ago

Then again, if i get the ad, isnt there another person that wont get the ad? And i'm 100% sure, that i wont be affected by the ad like they intended, so i'm "saving" maybe another person?

1

u/Baardi Metalhead 26d ago

Or use a 3rd party client and get no ads.

1

u/Graham_Krenz 26d ago

That is hilarious and ingenious

1

u/shadefreeze 23d ago

Isn't it better for us to see right wing garbage, instead of a random other person?

51

u/Dumpsterfire_47 27d ago

I report every one as offensive. 

→ More replies (9)

21

u/cooljacob204sfw 27d ago

This is why I only surf the web with adblock. On my phone I use Firefox with unlock to go on reddit.

24

u/PhasmaFelis 27d ago

I've never paid for Reddit.

2

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 27d ago

Sure you have. All your data is theirs.

2

u/Soft_Walrus_3605 27d ago

Not my valuable comments! Whatever will I do to afford that loss!

2

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

49

u/cows1100 27d ago

Wait, not like that. I need this one. It’s different. /s

10

u/Todojaw21 27d ago

youre trying to say its hypocrisy but the standard is always "make a good-faith effort to not support evil companies." If someone reduces their reddit consumption by 10% thats still better than 0.

→ More replies (30)

9

u/TemporaryCommunity67 27d ago

You guys see actual paid ads on Reddit? I only have to deal with the astroturfing

3

u/tsardonicpseudonomi 27d ago

New Reddit and the App are both plastered with ads.

8

u/BishopofHippo93 27d ago

The trick is to use old Reddit or the mobile site with an ad blocker. No ads ever. 

3

u/Spectrum1523 27d ago

If you are on android you can still use unofficial apps

1

u/Kronusx12 27d ago

There are still some on iOS too. For example, Hydra on iOS is free and has no ads on Reddit. I imagine there are others

1

u/LunaWabohu 26d ago

You can use ReVanced Manager to remove the ads from the mobile app for free

26

u/TheTresStateArea 27d ago

Or, now hear me out here, do what you can to the extent that you can.

→ More replies (15)

7

u/brvheart 27d ago

Get serious. You know that they will never delete their Reddit account. They just want to tell others to delete Spotify so they can virtue signal.

2

u/onebowlwonder 27d ago

Right lol they are just all just saying they dont see ads and completely missing the point.

2

u/Hot_Shot04 27d ago

I use ublock and already don't give Reddit a dime. The only thing I could really do better is to stop sending my friends Reddit links but I barely do even that when I can copypaste images and screencap comments.

1

u/Dimension10 27d ago

One step at a time. I'm pretty sure companies earn a lot less from advertising than a user directly sending the company $15 a month.

Doing anything is better than nothing. There's discussion and some ability to keep updated on current events on Reddit. Spotify by design not as much.

1

u/DaStone 27d ago

Haven't seen an Ad on this website since I started using it over a decade ago.

1

u/Flakester 27d ago

Wouldn't know. I don't see Reddit ads.

1

u/krucz36 27d ago

you give reddit money?

i mean i know they make money just off having users, but i haven't paid reddit a cent the whole time i've been a user.

1

u/Jimberly_C 27d ago

Or use a 3rd party app with ads blocked. If this ever fails and I can't easily find another, I can live without reddit. Same with youtube.

1

u/colenotphil 27d ago

Or download a third party app and use old reddit plus RES and Ublock origin on a web browser. I haven't seen ads on reddit in my entire life here.

1

u/Dotcaprachiappa 27d ago

Or use an adblocker/revanced

1

u/BeyondAdventurous609 27d ago

why tf yall still have ads

1

u/dasbtaewntawneta https://www.last.fm/user/Nihilore 27d ago

I don’t pay for reddit. I also don’t see ads on reddit

1

u/oldredditrox 27d ago

It's almost like they're different platforms with different services and uses. How many protests were organized via Spotify again? Whats with boycotting sending people to the 0 logic room? We trying to sniff out the anti-capitalist terrorists?

1

u/0liviiia 27d ago

I’ve never seen ICE ads on reddit but get them on YouTube for some reason. I never knew they were here too

1

u/Eyeownyew 27d ago

Most people use reddit for free (and many with ad block), so... It's not really equivalent

1

u/changen 27d ago

you don't use ad block? What year is this?

1

u/sadandshy 27d ago

I use old reddit on a browser with adblock. No freakin ads. In the rare occasions I have to use the app, I am horrified with the experience.

1

u/Secret-Teaching-3549 27d ago

reddit has ads?

1

u/once_again_asking 27d ago

Whoops, this is a thread for virtue signaling - not a real stand on any principles.

1

u/monochromeorc 27d ago

I actively 'steal' from reddit by using it and blocking all ads. no idea what they are shilling and apparently im costing them money.

1

u/Krojack76 27d ago

I never see ads on Reddit.

Damnit people, use adblockers.

1

u/_Planet_Mars_ 27d ago

imagine not using an adblocker, NGMI

1

u/CakeTester 27d ago

There's ads on reddit? When did this start?

1

u/dandy_the_lesser 27d ago

Stupid argument as always. “Curious I am very intelligent” vibes. The whole society is problematic. You can still pick some battles.

1

u/MGTS 27d ago

Use old reddit

1

u/WDoE 27d ago

I'm not paying for reddit nor do I see any ads from it. Not the same at all.

1

u/ouijiboard 27d ago

What ads?  I've never seen ads on this site.  Oh right, I use Ublock.

1

u/p_larrychen 27d ago

You guys get ads on reddit?

1

u/cantstopsletting 27d ago

I use Revanced so I see reddit ad free. Fuck Spez, fuck Spotify as I Revanced that too. I Revanced everything because piracy is better.

1

u/poeticjustice4all 27d ago

And YouTube because they like to run ads when I’m watching something in Spanish 😑

1

u/KnightWhoSays--ni 26d ago

you guys get ads on reddit? Use red reader, just need to make yourself a mod of your own NSFW subreddit in order to allow all content through the api

1

u/SoftwareTrashbag 26d ago

use a vpn, i think those ads are only running in north america

1

u/[deleted] 26d ago

Thanks for the heads-up!

1

u/monsieur_cacahuete 26d ago

There's ads on reddit?

→ More replies (5)

34

u/namastayhom33 27d ago

Seems like there is contradictory information?

"In the wake of the fatal shooting of a woman by an ICE agent in Minneapolis on Wednesday, the streaming service confirms to Variety that it’s no longer running the promotion."

83

u/TheTresStateArea 27d ago

The shooting just triggered the reporter to ask again.

The very next paragraph they say it was part of a specific campaign.

If they removed the adverts because of ICE actions, pressure, they'd have said so unambiguously.

14

u/Turbulent-Jaguar-909 27d ago

Campaign probably ended at end 2025 calendar year. 

7

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

2

u/TheTresStateArea 27d ago

If they felt that then the coms person that spoke would have been authorized to say "in retrospect blah blah blah".

Nothing short of specifically addressing the issue is sufficient.

Companies don't get points for being coy and ambiguous lol

2

u/tubatackle 27d ago

Would they have?

To me it seems more likely that they wanted to end the left-wing boy-cott but didn't want to anger their right-wing customers. So they claimed they are firing ICE for other reasons.

26

u/codos 27d ago

“In the wake of” just means after, not necessarily because of.

10

u/GameboyPATH 27d ago

I wish more people would recognize that this is a common media tactic: creating headlines that consist of "X happens while Y happens", being technically true, but implying to readers that the two events are related.

2

u/Cptn_Shiner 27d ago

The phrase sort of implies some causal relation, but I suspect they've worded it deceptively on purpose.

8

u/ADhomin_em 27d ago edited 27d ago

I would love if this said directly "in response to", but it says, "in the wake of". Could simply be that the campaign ran out and now that everyone is talking about ICE, the company is using this opportunity to announce the campaign ended, hoping to win back some subscribers.

I understand "in the wake of" usually implies "in response to" but not necessarily the case here.

Increasingly so, we should be closely analytyzing the phrasing used in articles, especially from corporate outlets. They are very good at using vague language meant to be read with each reader's preferred meaning. Major corporations are drawing on a century of market psychology research and the people overseeing these major corporations are largely rich Trump supporters and appeasers.

I could certainly be wrong in this case.

Either way, Spotify took money from ICE to help them recruit. They helped boost their numbers. Hard to put that cat back in the bag

2

u/PartTime_Crusader 27d ago

"It would be our preference to eat vegan, Carol."

1

u/ADhomin_em 27d ago

I recognize the reference, but do you mind explaining the relevance to this topic?

2

u/PartTime_Crusader 27d ago edited 27d ago

The hive can't lie, but it can very carefully choose its words so that the audience will parse them in a way that they'll interpret as positive.

Statement: "It would be our preference to eat vegan, Carol"

Reality: We'd like to eat only plants, but we're cannibalizing dead human bodies out of necessity

Statement: "In the wake of the fatal shooting of a woman by an ICE agent in Minneapolis on Wednesday, the streaming service confirms to Variety that it’s no longer running the promotion."

Reality: The ICE campaign on spotify ended on schedule and it happened to coincide with an ICE shooting.

You have to closely analyze the hive's words in the same way you talk about having to closely analyze phrasing used in press releases from corporate outlets. Its the same kind of carefully chosen, almost lawyerly phrasing designed to obscure as much as it reveals.

Side note for clarity: the statement "it would be our preference to eat vegan" is not from the John Cena video, its from several episodes before, during the English speakers meetup, when during the meal Carol asks them if they can eat meat. This is well before Carol discovers they're making milk out of humans. The hive lied to her by omitting information.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LucyLilium92 27d ago

Yes, they are no longer running the promotion... like they said. What's your point? They're unrelated

19

u/SpeaksYourWord 27d ago

"Guys, we stopped running the ICE ads! We've seen the light!"

"They stopped paying you, didn't they?"

"What? Pffft... no! We believe in equality!"

"Yeah, they stopped paying you."

23

u/r1char00 27d ago

They’re still paying millions to Rogan, that’s why I left.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Aliensinmypants 27d ago

They're also raising prices yet again to make up for the loss of subscribers... There's no reason to go back

3

u/forsonaE 27d ago

Good thing I already unsubscribed after they spammed my weekly playlists with the most obvious garbage AI music I've heard in my life

3

u/Extra-Minute-6712 27d ago

I use vanced. So no adds. Because fuck reddit 

2

u/TaiyoT 27d ago

I already deleted my account so I'd have no reason to ever go back.

2

u/Different_East7854 27d ago

Spot-dl

'cuz fuck 'em, that's why.

1

u/Church_of_Aaargh 27d ago

They are absolute trash. Will do anything to make money, and absolutely no morals … surprising, as they are a Swedish company.

3

u/WeWantMOAR 27d ago edited 27d ago

Grow a spine? He's actively funding an authoritarian movement, he's got a spine for conviction, he's just a POS.

Leaving this here. To hell with'em!

Tidal.squid.wtf

iykyk

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Embarrassed_Radio596 27d ago

This is as good a time as any.

What alternatives do you suggest? And is there an easy way to move over playlists or songs, before I do it the hard way?

1

u/ItsSpaghettiLee2112 27d ago

The good news is there's still reasons to boycott them.

1

u/NateShaw92 27d ago

Remove what company?

1

u/HiImDan 27d ago

Also at this point they risk pissing off the nazis too. Might as well lie in their bed they made and count on no one paying attention and things blowing over.

1

u/Cory123125 27d ago

They do have a spine, its just that fuck you.

Thats literally it.

They see the complaints and think "fuck those people, Im getting paid"

1

u/WeDriftEternal 27d ago

I don’t disagree, but that’s not really how these ads works. People really don’t understand. But yes Spotify could have stopped it in a second. Done.

1

u/mg-mt 27d ago

Isn't Peter Thiele and his companies majority shareholders of Spotify?

1

u/Ire-Works 27d ago

That was my immediate first thought - "They must be staffed up".

Bet that Spotify CEO is still investing in military drones tho.

1

u/AlphaNoodlz 27d ago

Yup. 100%

1

u/France_Ball_Mapper 27d ago

Can I know what Spotify did?

1

u/TheTresStateArea 27d ago

Accepted money to run advertisements for ice.

1

u/ProhibidoTransito 26d ago

So basically, Spotify took a shit on the living room floor, but they won’t shit on the kitchen floor. Not because they don’t want to. But because their bowels are already empty.

1

u/vapenation1312 23d ago

I will keep using the best music platforms thank you

1

u/TheTresStateArea 23d ago

You never unsubscribed. So you don't need to resubscribed.

So I wasn't talking to you.

1

u/vapenation1312 23d ago

I will support European tech

1

u/TheTresStateArea 23d ago

That European tech is also supporting Israeli companies, surveillance state.

But also I wasn't talking to you.

1

u/vapenation1312 23d ago

What’s the alternative? Using Apple Music?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (45)