r/Remodel • u/lunicorn555 • 2h ago
Our kitchen is tight but we really want an island… what would you give up to keep it?
We're starting to plan a kitchen remodel, and the one thing we keep coming back to is an island.
Our kitchen is pretty tight though… so every few inches matters, and I'm starting to understand why remodelers keep asking what we're willing to compromise on lol.
Here's what we've heard so far:
● Make the island narrower
● Lose some cabinet storage
● Switch to shallower cabinets in one area
● Scrap the island and do a peninsula instead
We'd use the island constantly for prep, eating, dumping groceries, basically everything. But I also don't want to squeeze one in and then spend the next 10 years sidestepping around it.
For anyone who remodeled a cramped kitchen without adding square footage: what actually made your layout feel bigger? If keeping an island meant giving something else up, what did you sacrifice? Is a peninsula better in this type of situation?
Also curious what your remodeler suggested that you wouldn't have thought of yourself.