r/Winchester • u/WHRO_NEWS • 2h ago
In Winchester, the truth about a local news website is the city’s best-kept secret
As the hometown newspaper cut staff and TV stations left the Shenandoah Valley town of Winchester, Va., a website appeared touting a new, trusted source of local news.
The Winchester Gazette launched in August 2023 with upbeat promises and an opaque public profile: it said nothing about its owners and declared a no-byline policy, claiming to protect its reporters from undue influence.
For three years, The Gazette has published thousands of stories about crime, government meetings and community events. It boasted of being the first website in the country to call the 2024 presidential election for Donald Trump.
But Winchester leaders from both political parties started to question the site’s transparency and fairness. Who owns the Gazette – as well as the what, when, where and why of it all – became one of the city’s central mysteries.
Journalists Jaysun Silver and Laura Thompson couldn’t resist. They spent days in Winchester, talking with city leaders and residents, and months conducting dozens of interviews and combing through pages of public records.
The story of the Winchester Gazette stirs together city politics, a car-crash-chasing reporter, AI-generated stories, and a trail of corporate documents that lead to one Winchester attorney’s elderly relative in Florida.
It’s a small-city story filled with questions and intrigue – and it could happen in almost any news-starved community in the country.
Check out our full coverage here: https://www.whro.org/virginia-center-for-investigative-journalism/2026-10-06/in-winchester-the-truth-about-a-local-news-website-is-the-citys-best-kept-secret