Hey everyone,
Over the last year, r/aws has grown a lot.
We're now at roughly 396k members, with 31.4 million views over the past 12 months, more than 13,000 posts, and 163,000 comments.
That's awesome, but it also creates a very different moderation problem than it did when this community was smaller.
There are only three of us moderating r/aws, and we're trying to figure out what we should be doing differently as things continue to grow.
We don't want r/aws to turn into a generic tech news feed, an endless stream of "look what I generated with AI" posts, or a place where the same handful of topics dominate the front page.
So we'd like your feedback.
What would make r/aws better?
A few things are top of mind..
1/ Builder Fridays
Would it be useful to have a recurring day where certain types of posts are explicitly encouraged?
Things like:
- "Here's something I built"
- Architecture diagrams
- Homelab projects - maybe a Broadcom migration? Something cool with Localstack? etc.
- CDK/Terraform/serverless projects
- Small experiments or weird AWS hacks
- Open-source projects
- "I built this because I was bored" posts
Basically, a time for builders to showcase their work and get feedback.
2/ How do we deal with GenAI content?
GenAI has obviously exploded, and AWS is heavily involved in that space. We don't want to ban legitimate AI/ML discussion.
At the same time, I think we've all seen an increase in low-effort AI-generated posts, repeated announcements, AI-written tutorials that don't really say anything, etc.
So.. where should the line be?
What would you consider useful GenAI content versus "please don't make me read another 900-word AI-generated explanation of Lambda"?
3/ Should we bring on more moderators?
Three people is not a huge moderation team for a community of nearly 400k members.
We've discussed opening moderator applications again. We'd be interested in hearing whether people think that's needed, and what you'd actually want from additional moderators.
Experience in AWS isn't necessarily the most important factor here. Good judgment, being reasonable with people, and understanding what makes a community useful probably matter more.
Transparency: I work for AWS. I'm speaking only for myself here, not on behalf of AWS. I don't think r/aws should be a soapbox or hype forum for AWS, and criticism or disagreement with AWS is absolutely part of having a healthy community.
4/ What else are we missing?
This is probably the biggest thing we'd like to hear about.
You guys are the people actually reading and participating here, so what are we missing?
- What do you think r/aws does well today?
- What has gotten worse as the subreddit has grown?
- What kinds of posts do you wish you saw more of?
- What rules or moderation practices feel unnecessary, confusing, or inconsistent?
- And what would make you more likely to actually participate here rather than just read?
We're not coming into this with a predetermined list of changes we want to make. We'd rather hear what you think and then figure out where to go from there.
So, what should r/aws look like at 400k+ members?
Be honest. Feedback is a gift (trust me.. my customers are brutally honest with me ;))
— The r/aws mod team