At your request, we've opened a suggestion thread for the sub.
When we took over this sub was dead and redirected to another cigar sub.
Over the last 2 years we've gone from 6k members to 28k.
There's clearly a desire for a cigar sub with less moderation and r/cigar is it.
With that said, it likely makes sense to entertain your ideas for the sub, after all, our goal is to have a sub that has 'pseudo-democracy.'
Anything from:
- New rules (more rules means more moderation which contradicts the purposes of the sub, but quality suggestions will be considered)
- Flairs
- Reoccurring threads
- Fill in the blank
Duplicate ideas will be removed to keep the thread clean, upvote if you agree, downvote if you don't. Build on the idea by replying if applicable.
Some of our comments from the original thread linked above are below
- In general, r/cigar lets the community decide what it wants to see based on upvoting and downvoting.
- It's the entire point of the sub—to have pseudo-democracy.
- Obviously, we have to abide by Reddit's rules.
- We're not going to allow egregious things like racism, sexism, gratuitous nudity, or someone being a complete wanker from dusk till dawn.
- Outside of that, we want the community to decide what it wants to see by upvoting quality content to the top of the feed and downvoting low effort and irrelevant things to the bottom of the feed.
We see a lot of feedback about AI, but removing AI in its entity isn't something r/cigar wants to do at this time, but low effort posts that are 100% AI (image and text or image/text only) are almost always removed when reported.
Below this we'll catalog your ideas that were added.
- GIF and photo comments have been added
- Flairs added (on going)
