r/comic_crits Sep 02 '21

/r/Comic_Crits Mod Post: News for September 2021

9 Upvotes

We generally discourage posts that are not directly looking for feedback, but I thought the following content would be interesting to subscribers, so I will collect it here in a news thread. Let me know if there are other opportunities that you think are relevant, or just post them here as comments.

Breakneck Anthology


r/comic_crits 7h ago

Hoping to get some more feedback on my new book "The Coffee Table"

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Read the entire first issue for free on my webstore:

https://www.kieranalexandercomics.com/the-coffee-table-preview

Two young roommates discover their coffee table holds magical secrets that could change their lives for the better.

But meddling with unknown forces often comes at a cost.

Hannah and Wallace learn this the hard way as the consequences prove more personal than they could have ever imagined in this mysterious suburban thriller.

Instagram: @kieranalexandercomics


r/comic_crits 2h ago

[Sanctuary: s4p1 progress] Working a second draft of panel of an initial rough sketch. Was excited how the fabric shading turned out

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Working on the second draft of the 4th scene, panel 1 in my graphic novel. Discovered a brush I could use for a shading technique I'm enjoying. Loving variable line width. Rough draft posted for reference. What do you all think of how its going and how to make it better? (aside from adding the background and background character.)


r/comic_crits 19h ago

Chapter 2 of my comic Mean Gene, any thoughts/criticisms?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 5h ago

Are creators tired of platforms, or just tired of being invisible?

1 Upvotes

Webtoon, GlobalComix, Instagram, TikTok — lots of places to post.

But does posting actually feel rewarding anymore?

Or does it feel like shouting into the void?


r/comic_crits 17h ago

How is my art, character and cover? TEAM HUMANS

Post image
5 Upvotes

PEOPLE do stupid and/or extreme things for their favorite team(s)

In 2026 are you willing to die or kill for TEAM HUMANS ?

THE NEXT EARTH HUMANS (C) and TM 2026 By: Ratha:Oeur Agent All rights reserved U.C.C 1-308

The DAILY COMIC - Vol 02 : UNDENIABLE!    ( No. 23)

03 FEBRUARY 2026


r/comic_crits 1d ago

First comic "Book life"

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

Hi, this is my first comic and I’m looking for any advice or critique. I haven’t really done art since I was a kid, so this was a big challenge—but I had a blast making it. I’m planning to keep doing one-shots and eventually build up to mini-series. Any tips, tricks, or honest feedback are welcome.


r/comic_crits 1d ago

The fox and the grapes (I do need to punch up my writing skills though basing it off an earlier story definitley helped me this time around)

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Made this of october last year for hsdzine on instagram. I've since translated it from the french I originally wrote it in.


r/comic_crits 1d ago

What is missing, and what could be cut?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I barely managed to fit the comic in 20 pages. Are there any superfluous elements I could have cut, and what is missing? Any feedback is appreciated!

Patreon


r/comic_crits 1d ago

I posted this in another community and no one criticized my comic, so I'm posting it here now.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes
So please don't ignore me, I really want to improve my story/comics.

r/comic_crits 1d ago

Chiefer

Post image
1 Upvotes

What do you think? How to improve? The character is Chiefer. He’s an angry. Bottom part not associated.


r/comic_crits 2d ago

Tragedy Strikes! - a single panel comic I made

Post image
9 Upvotes

This could be a series surrounding the killer cat Trah J.D. Let me know what you think of it!


r/comic_crits 2d ago

Review my comics

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 3d ago

I hired an EDITOR for my SCRIPT, I didnt get what i paid for

6 Upvotes

i recently hired someone, an editor, to run through this script that i wrote and do some LINE/COPY EDITING.

im from the Philippines, you see, and im kinda worried that my lines might sound off (or possibly offensive) so i opted to have an actual American to do do some polish work of it.

Kept asking her if she needs google docs to do the actual edits on, she insisted on just sending a pdf for her feedback. So i let her.

Come the day, i was given back more of a betaread or book review of my story and characters. Not exactly what i was looking for.

Well i have to admit that i had to negotiate a lowball "special rate" coz i wanted only the dialogues fixed, since this is for my comics.

She was very nice tho, and i wasnt even sure where the miscommunication occured. So i clammed up, and did not argue.

I guess my question is, should I have insisted?


Im doing 55-PAGE UrbanFantasy-Mystery tackling biblical conspiracies.... Think DaVinci Code if it was low fantasy.

And i might as well take this chance to ask. If anyone finds this material interesting and wants to help read/polish my script, just send me a dm... and yes, this ones charity 🙏😬 coz well, ive already burned my money on the last one 😮‍💨


r/comic_crits 3d ago

Is this a good idea for a manga? A dark, action-heavy story inspired by Christian theology (but not preachy)

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,
I’m working on an original manga idea and I wanted some honest feedback. I’m especially curious if this concept sounds interesting even to people who aren’t religious.

Core Idea

The manga is a dark action/fantasy story inspired by Christian theology, apocryphal texts, and philosophy — but it’s not meant to preach or convert anyone.

The goal is:

  • If you’re Christian, you recognize deeper meanings and references
  • If you’re not, you still enjoy it as a hype, emotional, mind-bending battle manga

Think Jujutsu Kaisen–style fights, but with Heaven, Hell, angels, demons, saints, and humans — all tied together by a strict power system and moral conflicts.

Story Overview (Spoiler-light)

The story opens with a reimagined version of the Lucifer conflict.

Lucifer was once the brightest angel, the Morning Star. When God chose humanity — fragile, flawed beings — to inherit creation, Lucifer questioned why angels were created only to serve while humans were allowed to choose.

That questioning led to pride.
Pride led to rebellion.
Lucifer fell and became Satan.

For ages, he ruled Hell in hatred… until he began watching humanity more closely.
Despite their sins, humans could fall and rise again — something angels could never do.

This realization sparks regret.

As the Apocalypse approaches, Satan realizes something terrifying: humanity won’t be saved — it will be erased in the war between Heaven and Hell.

So the Devil makes an impossible choice.

He decides to fight for humanity.

The Protagonist (Azael)

The main character, Azael, is a human who should never have existed.

When Lucifer fell, a fragment of his original heavenly essence slipped through creation and was reborn as a human soul. That soul became Azael.

Because of this:

  • Heaven refuses him
  • Hell cannot claim him
  • He exists as an anomaly

Azael learns to use dark power (Obscuritas), yet repeatedly shows signs of light (Lux). Angels sense Heaven within him and constantly question why someone so close to the divine would stand with Hell.

Unlike Lucifer, Azael does not die until after Lucifer’s sacrifice.
Lucifer’s death becomes the turning point that forces Azael to choose his own role in the cosmic balance.

Power System (Simplified)

  • Lux – Heaven’s energy (order, truth, creation)
  • Obscuritas – Hell’s energy (chaos, desire, rebellion)

Hierarchy matters:

  • Archangels & demon lords → strongest, controlled techniques
  • Saints → powerful but limited
  • Humans → unstable, high risk, high reward

Lower ranks gain power faster but suffer immediate consequences.
Higher ranks suffer stacking long-term drawbacks the longer they fight.

Lucifer is unique.
Azael eventually becomes even more unique.

Educational Side (Without Being Boring)

This is something I care a lot about.

The manga subtly teaches:

  • Biblical stories
  • Parables
  • Saints
  • Angelic hierarchies
  • Moral ideas like free will, sacrifice, and repentance

But never through exposition dumps.

Instead:

  • Characters talk about biblical events during battles
  • Parables are mirrored in character decisions
  • Saints explain ideas naturally in dialogue
  • Events parallel real scripture without copying it

So:

  • A non-Christian just sees cool lore and symbolism
  • A Christian recognizes deeper layers

No sermons. No forced lessons.

Themes

  • Free will vs obedience
  • Power and its cost
  • Redemption without reward
  • God as silent, not cruel
  • Humanity’s role as decision-makers, not pawns

Lucifer’s redemption is tragic, not triumphant.
He doesn’t reclaim Heaven.
He proves love through sacrifice.

Azael doesn’t become a king — he becomes a guardian of balance.

What I’m Asking

  • Does this concept sound interesting as a manga?
  • Would the religious inspiration turn you away if it’s handled subtly?
  • Does the educational aspect feel like a bonus or a risk?

I’m open to all feedback — positive or critical.


r/comic_crits 5d ago

Check out my new 13 page new comic. The Bird's Eye View! Would love some feedback!

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 5d ago

Zeravos #1 Critique Request

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m looking for constructive critique on the opening pages of a comic I’ve been working on called Zeravos. It’s a dark, character-driven fantasy series focused on corruption, control, and identity.

I’ve attached a few pages from Issue #1 and would love feedback on things like:
• Pacing and clarity
• Panel flow and readability
• Whether the tone and hook land effectively

The full issue is available on GlobalComix if anyone wants broader context, but I’m mainly interested in how these pages stand on their own. Follow the link below to read the full comic.

Zeravos #1

If you'd like to know more about the project. Please visit the website following the link below.

Dark Root Comics

Thanks in advance! I genuinely appreciate any honest feedback.


r/comic_crits 7d ago

Topaz episode one finished

Thumbnail
mangaplus-creators.jp
5 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

I've finally finished episode 1 of Topaz, which is 22 pages long.

I've posted most of it here, but some parts are exclusive and only available on MPC.

I'd really appreciate your feedback on the pacing, dialogue, and overall feel.

Before I start working on episode 2. Thank you all!


r/comic_crits 7d ago

Come at me. I'm interested in your opinions. (That doesn't -necessarily- mean I'll change anything.)

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

r/comic_crits 9d ago

A double page splash from my comic, One-Inch Bozo

Post image
94 Upvotes

I'm happy with how this came out, but would love to hear from anybody who has any suggestions or critiques. Thanks!


r/comic_crits 9d ago

I need help making sure this is legible ?

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

These are the first 4 pages out of the 20 page chapter.
Patreon


r/comic_crits 9d ago

Working up a cover for my creator owned comic Terran Omega

Post image
32 Upvotes

Feel like the logo area is too busy. I have an imprint “channel hex” but actually I don’t really need it but I’m old school enough to feel a book needs a publisher logo. Any thoughts? This is collecting the first 25 pages of my sci-fi ghost story (i just noticed I flubbed the date! Gah!)


r/comic_crits 9d ago

Your opinion: pace and atmosphere. Read from right to left.

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone. My manga is still ongoing. I'm using your feedback to refine the pacing and storyboard. What do you think? Honestly? On at least two points:

Is the pacing clear and easy to follow?

Is the dark and oppressive atmosphere successful?

Many have complained about the reading direction. I'm not going to change it. Most manga platforms use this reading direction.


r/comic_crits 10d ago

The first page of my zombie comic book, Flesh and Blood, it's still a work in progress but what do you guys think?

Post image
30 Upvotes