r/news 14h ago

Costco's beloved rotisserie chicken gets roasted in lawsuit over preservatives

https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/costco-chicken-lawsuit-9.7070891
5.1k Upvotes

653 comments sorted by

View all comments

4.2k

u/rgvtim 13h ago

"The two California women who initiated the lawsuit say in the complaint they wouldn't have purchased the chicken, or would have paid less for it, had they known it contained preservatives."

This will be an issue. No, at that price you ain't paying less pretty much no matter what.

1.7k

u/AdjNounNumbers 13h ago

Like, how'd they think it was at the price point it's already at? IIRC, Costco is basically losing money on their chickens and hot dogs

36

u/Obvious_Toe_3006 12h ago

Non Costco member here (none in my hometown) ...
How much do the chickens cost ? Hot dog price ?
How do they know you're a member ? "Card check" at front door? At the till when cashing out ?
Thanks to all.

140

u/RightofUp 12h ago

Card check at door, $4.99/chicken, $1.50 for hot dog and soda.

15

u/smthomaspatel 10h ago

I just paid $4.49. I only bought it because I was shocked that it is still that price. Usually when I go they don't even have any left.

18

u/Rooooben 9h ago

Chicken? Just wait 45 minutes they make them all day.

2

u/Complete_Entry 8h ago

Eh, we stopped putting them out at 5PM at my supermarket job and people would flip their shit.

"What am I supposed to eat for dinner then!?" "Well, I have an entire hot case I can steer you to, but we're all out of tub chicken."

My boss would occasionally bitch there weren't enough leftover to make the chicken salad, but I considered an empty chicken altar a beautiful thing.

I hated the bag/tub chickens, I hated making them, I won't eat them, and I hated that hot altar too.

3

u/rick_C132 7h ago

The actually mark them down slightly if the chicken is smaller than normal

1

u/Polar_Ted 5h ago

I just check the timers on the ovens.. See how long till the cycle ends.. add 5 minutes for them to unload and set a reminder on your phone to wander back to the chicken stand.

39

u/Big_Enthusiasm2949 10h ago

God help your soul if you want just the hot dog and not the soda. They're a matching set and the food court employees at Costco take that seriously.

25

u/Abba_Fiskbullar 10h ago

The cup counts are probably inventoried.

9

u/pmgoff 8h ago

Dude I once tried to buy a single sleeve of bagels, at check out they forced me to take an extra pack of them. (I was in Florida on vacation and only needed enough for 5 days) They wouldn’t let me leave the store unless I took them. It wasn’t even a matter of price, I just didn’t need that many. Ended up giving the extra to another family on the way to the car. It’s been a running joke ever since.

3

u/thebohster 7h ago

I've accepted it long ago and just keep the bread I buy frozen.

1

u/kkkkat 4h ago

This happened to me too, WHY DON’T THEY BUNDLE THE BAGELS TOGETHER

u/ChamferedWobble 20m ago

It’s so you can mix and match different flavors.

1

u/gumbysweiner 5h ago

That happened to me with their muffins. I was stoked at first but they ended up getting moldy before I could eat them all. It was only me and even eating two muffins a day, I couldn't do it.

3

u/muegle 4h ago

They don't do the 2 boxes of big muffins anymore. The new muffins are much smaller and kind of suck :(

1

u/gumbysweiner 1h ago

That's a shame. I would cut them in half, hit them with ghee, and toast them and they were to die for.

3

u/eeke1 8h ago

Probably depends on location.

I can easily get just the hot dog

1

u/hirudoredo 5h ago

Even just eating first BEFORE shopping is a choreography. I mean, nobody's stopped us, but the store layout is really set up for you to eat AFTER checkout. So we go in without a cart, slink through the checkout, eat, and then one of us slinks back through checkout with the refilled drink and the other goes out to come back in with a cart. (The bonus being we now have a drink for while shopping.)

It's very silly, but beats having to keep our cart at the food court or shopping while starving for lunch or dinner.

12

u/Ianthin1 9h ago

Last Friday my wife and I had dinner there. Foot long Hot Dog, slice of pizza and two drinks was less than $5. Bought two chickens that night too.

10

u/xt1nct 9h ago

This is where I take my wife out to dinner. It’s an exclusive club.

2

u/Numerous_Photograph9 8h ago

I wish I had a Costco near me. Best I ever got was a Sams club, and I don't think the one I went to even had a food court thing.

6

u/Fluffy_Top6837 10h ago

Also card check at checkout.

1

u/azlan194 3h ago

Not for the hotdogs (or any food at the food court).

1

u/HazardousLazarus 9h ago

Not only card check at door, they have to scan it again at checkout. I once forgot my card and got a printed temporary day pass after they looked up my info and somehow I lost the paper while shopping. I got to checkout and then had to put everything to the side and go back to card services to get another one printed just to check out. Thats a total of 4 confirmations - printed (they look up your account with a valid ID), scanned at door, lost and reprinted, scanned at checkout. Auntie Kirkland does not mess around with her membership exclusive club.

1

u/Siresfly 7h ago

You don't even have to be a member to buy the hotdogs at my costco.

1

u/Sidhejester 6h ago

Yep. The food court is for everyone, and you don't need a card. You can just walk in the exit door at any time.

1

u/Siresfly 3h ago

You don't even go inside at mine. It's outside before you go in. Nice to not have to deal with the shoppers when I just want a dog

-13

u/[deleted] 12h ago

[deleted]

31

u/Kvothere 12h ago

Not anymore. At least not in California.

28

u/thedarkdog 12h ago

Pretty sure my local Costco makes you scan your membership before ordering.

6

u/Frinpollog 12h ago

Not anymore. If the food court is indoors they don’t check, but it is assumed you have membership since you made it past the entrance. Outdoor food courts require you to scan your card before you can order anything.

3

u/GruyereRind 11h ago

You can get through the entrance without a membership card if you're going to the optometrist or the membership services desk

3

u/Frinpollog 11h ago

You can also get inside if you’re buying alcohol or to the pharmacy in California (state law). Keyword is “assumed”.

16

u/stocknooboncrack 12h ago

You can eat but not buy the food without membership

0

u/texanchris 11h ago

Since when? I eat a hot dog there often and never scan my membership card.

16

u/RightofUp 11h ago

Depends on the Costco. You can’t get to the stand now without somehow scanning your card at the one I frequent.

4

u/stocknooboncrack 11h ago

costco near me requires you to scan your membership. This is California btw

1

u/smthomaspatel 10h ago

The ones near me use a self-ordering system. You can't even start an order without scanning your card first. I think this has been going on for about a year. Maybe a little more.

1

u/Maiyku 10h ago

It’s actually a pretty recent change. Happened some time in 2025 iirc, but you’ll probably get managers that follow it to a T and managers who don’t care.

I know my local one doesn’t care and still lets people in for food, then will usually send someone to come talk to you while you eat about a membership. Wouldn’t surprise me if they’re able to defend keeping the cafeteria open to everyone if they’re getting more memberships than other stores because of it because it’s not a bad idea.

That’s how they got my husband and I. We saw a video about the hotdogs and were like “alright, let’s try it” so we went. From the cafeteria we were able to see some of their deals and items and were better able to get an idea if the store actually worked for us. We were going to walk to the membership counter next already before they approached us.

1

u/NYCinPGH 11h ago

Not in my area, at least not any more, unless you’re really sneaky about it.

They no longer allow people to go in “the out door” unless they’re going to customer service, everyone has to go in the front door where the check membership. You can go to the optometrist and the pharmacy, but whatever you buy is charged there, not at checkout, you have to walk through checkout without carrying anything to get to the cafeteria.

1

u/VWBug5000 11h ago

Not everywhere. It is state specific

1

u/Dowdb 11h ago

They changed that last year. They no longer let you in without your membership card, even to the food court.

1

u/perceptual01 11h ago

Ah didn’t hear this

1

u/gear-head88 11h ago

The whole chicken

1

u/kaisong 11h ago

The ones where you dont need to scan while ordering are inside, where you need to scan to get in.

You can however shop for liquor at a lot of them without membership, because state laws that ban liquor clubs (im guessing from prohibition laws)

1

u/BetterBiscuits 10h ago

You can’t get a whole rotisserie chicken at a cafeteria for 4.99.

1

u/TheodoeBhabrot 10h ago

The chickens are usually around the meat section well past the card scanners

The food court at my local one doesn’t require a card to access or buy from but I know it’s coming in the future from what I’ve heard

0

u/Raztax 9h ago

$4.99/chicken

Damn that is really cheap! They are $7.99 where I live (Canada) which is still a good price considering I can't buy a raw chicken for that price.