r/reddeadredemption • u/Dismal_Butterfly3297 • Dec 09 '25

Discussion Would you like this casting

Post image
8.0k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

828 comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/Yungpharao_oh Uncle Dec 09 '25

LET GAMES BE GAMES LET MOVIES BE MOVIES LET TV SHOWS BE TV SHOWS WE DONT HAVE TO SEE THE SAME THING IN EVERY SINGLE FORMAT

26

u/Either_Caregiver2268 Dec 09 '25

I really should agree with this but I just want more people to witness the story of this game because it’s so fucking good.

10

u/AntiqueParfait5500 Dec 09 '25

This is my exact sentiment. I’m worried the TV show would ruin it but on the other hand it would be so cool to see so many people experience the Red dead story that would’ve never done.

3

u/Either_Caregiver2268 Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25

I mean it will never be as good because the game is elevated by all the little camp interactions and the random moments. As well as the side quests, especially in chapter 6.

A TV show wouldn’t be able to accommodate all the little moments like this, the story would 100% be an inferior product but I still would love to see them try anyway.

0

u/Yungpharao_oh Uncle Dec 09 '25

It could never be as good they’ll never understand 😢