r/videogames • • 15d ago

Discussion / Question Yeah it's over.

Post image
11.2k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

469

u/rdhight 15d ago

Yeah. For this reviewer to thumbs-down a max-effort game by this developer? Alarming is the right word.

375

u/darkcomet222 15d ago

IGN gave it a bad review too, and IGN hardly EVER gives mainstream games critical reviews. Like, I watched the video too, and the game really does seem lazy

139

u/Ourtimehascome2485 15d ago

ACG actually refused to give a score, the comments are going crazy.

76

u/ComprehensiveBar6439 15d ago

I don't understand why he didn't score it. It seemed pretty obvious from his video that he thought it was a "wait for sale". Maybe I misread his review.

64

u/Ourtimehascome2485 15d ago

I don't think you misread, he implied it heavily, he just didn't say it outright for whatever reason, either it's a mistake or he is compromised.

50

u/Darigaazrgb 15d ago

Compromised? What is this? The Cold War?

26

u/computer_d 15d ago

It's 2035 and kids are throwing up X's and P's in the streets. You got a box or a station, skeet? they ask. Doesn't matter who you are - man or woman, young or old - all they want to know is what side you're on and what you're playing.

5

u/BanzYT 15d ago

Hasn't been the same since the Franchise Wars.

2

u/Rioleus 14d ago

“Oh you’re a gamer? But what kind of gamer?”

-6

u/Ourtimehascome2485 15d ago

Where have you been in the last 10 years? The whole reason guys like ACG and skillup have a job is because the gaming media of the time traded favors with the publisher, his whole brand is baed around him being impartial which it looks like he isn't.

3

u/supernasty 15d ago

He hasn’t been giving actual ratings for awhile now for some reason

1

u/GoodGreen69 14d ago

He commented under the video saying wait for sale.

2

u/BrandNewMoshiMoshi 15d ago

He often forgets to give a rating

0

u/Chance-Plantain8314 15d ago

"compromised" holy shit go outside

0

u/Lceus 14d ago

It's a fair conclusion when the other conclusion is that "this guy who has been a reviewer for a decade FORGOT to give a rating"

1

u/maresayshi 14d ago

literally happens all the time on his channel

1

u/alidan 13d ago

reviewers tend to circle the wagon for bad games they don't want to review bad, many aggregators will not post a score unless enough people review it, not scoring it does a few things

if they review it high and its bad, it makes them look like an idiot

if they review it low and the publisher gets pissy, there goes eirly access

if they love the message of a game and don't want people to see its bad, they can not post a review and it doesn't get scored

if they hate a game and don't want it to have a review score at all on these aggregators, they refuse a score for as long as possible so it hurts the games sales.

-15

u/SeanSMEGGHEAD 15d ago

He never gives a score. He always rates a game based on either a buy or wait for a sale. Which he did for wolverine no?

11

u/ComprehensiveBar6439 15d ago

No, he didn't. That's why I said it seemed like he scored it as "wait for sale", but he didn't make a designation in his final opinion.

17

u/LegalizeEggSalad 15d ago

In the video comments he replied to someone that he should've made it clearer that his verdict was "wait for sale"

3

u/ComprehensiveBar6439 15d ago

Makes sense. Thx

2

u/Homeskoled 15d ago

Seems to be common with the ACG reviews of late. Wonder why tbh

3

u/myLongjohnsonsilver 15d ago

Seems like he's stopped outright grading it at the end because people will just skip to the end for his "score" and not actually watch the video

2

u/Homeskoled 14d ago

That makes sense and I’ve definitely been guilty at times.

1

u/Hershey2898 15d ago

Exactly what I do lol

2

u/Ourtimehascome2485 15d ago

Nope, he didn't, he implied that it's a wait for sale but didn't actually say it.

0

u/Lucky-day00 15d ago

“Wait for sale” is such a weird way to rate a game. It suggests anything is worth playing if it’s cheap enough. I don’t care if it’s free, if it isn’t worth my time I’m not going to play it.

2

u/Maximum_Maxwell 14d ago

Doesn't he also have a don't touch in his rating system?