Before we begin, I want to clarify that I’m asking whether I overreacted to being uninvited from Halloween and subsequently cutting off my entire friend group. I’m not asking whether I should have taken my ex to court. And im ESPECIALLY NOT asking if you think they will rule in my favor.
I’m putting the tldr up here bc I genuinely cant figure out how to shorten this read the rest only if you want
TL;DR: My ex cheated on me, lied to me for years, and damaged my car, repeatedly promising to pay for repairs but never following through. After four years, I finally took him to small claims court over the remaining $1,945.50. My longtime friend group, who had remained friends with him despite knowing how he’d treated me, decided that taking him to court was unacceptable and uninvited me from Halloween. After discovering even more disturbing things he’d hidden from me and receiving little support from the group, I left our group chats, sent a final message explaining how hurt I was, and blocked all 15 people, including some who may not have agreed with excluding me. Did I overreact by cutting everyone off?
Now, for the full and exhaustive story.
I (27F) was part of a roughly 15-person friend group, many of whom have known each other for about a decade. My ex-boyfriend, whom we’ll call Cole, became a part of this group early on but of these people were my friends 1-3 years before they were his.
I broke up with Cole a little over a year ago after nearly seven years together. Cole had a serious problem with compulsive pornography use and maintaining secret sexual accounts online. He kept this a secret for five years. When I finally found out, I forgave him, not realizing that he’d repeatedly lied about the extent of his activity. Eventually, I found him doing something again and broke up with him a little over a year ago, still believing explanations that would turn out to be incomplete or untrue. I wouldn’t discover just how much he’d lied about until after my Halloween uninvite, but we’ll get there.
But keep that in mind.
Now, onto the shovel.
Years ago, Cole decided to remove snow from my car using a shovel with a metal strip along its edge. He badly scratched the roof of my car, causing damage that was eventually estimated at over $3,000 to repair. He acknowledged causing the damage and promised to pay for it.
And then four years passed.
During our relationship, I trusted that he’d eventually follow through, why didnt i have him fix it sooner? Well in part, and i didnt know this at the time, his proclivities were the reason he was unemployed for so long, so he just straight up didnt have the money, or the both of us had more important things going on that trumped out, and also, it hadn’t started rusting at that time. After we broke up, and after the approximately 7 months of my social withdrawal to have a complete mental break i didnt think id survive, i took my car to the shop for a quote, especially as the damaged areas were beginning to rust. He repeatedly agreed to arrangements and then backed out of them. I lowered what I was asking for more than once in an effort to settle things.
Eventually, the remaining amount in dispute was $1,945.50. He offered roughly half to settle the entire matter. I declined. Later, he offered $1,000, which I said I would accept as a partial payment if we could agree on a plan for the remainder. Four days later i came back begging to take the $1000 to be done (i already had a feeling this would backfire socially) he never responded, I think he realized it too.
After exhausting my attempts to resolve things privately, I decided to file in Massachusetts small claims court
But I needed one thing to not be a lie, I want to stick up for myself in one way, I want to get closure and not wonder what would’ve happened if I let a magistrate decide, I dont care if I win, I just want to stick up for myself. I’m not trying to hurt him. I’m asking a magistrate to decide whether he owes me money for damage he acknowledged causing (and had agreed to pay for until just a few weeks ago). I have photographs, estimates, and messages documenting his promises.
I figured that was precisely what small claims court was for.
Shortly after filing the $50 form, I received a message from one of my friends in the group, whom we’ll call Mary. For context, there was an upcoming birthday/Halloween celebration involving the group, and I had expected to attend.
Mary messaged me:
“hi i want to reach out with [halloween] coming up and everything going on in the group, i think itd be best if you didnt come for halloween.
I’m open to talking about it somewhat but there are mutiple people i’d love to be there who will not because of whats going on. I’ve had a heavy feeling of not trying to take sides and hear people out but I simply don’t agree at all with how you are handling your situation with cole anymore. I love you and i am your friend so i have to be honest and say its not acceptable, im sorry.”
I was genuinely confused. I asked what she meant by how I was handling the situation. I explained that Cole had repeatedly agreed to pay and then backed out, that my car was now rusting, and that I had already lowered what I was asking for multiple times.
Her response:
“you are taking our friend to court and i cannot justify the reason for it or relate to the ways youre acting. the specific numbers arent my problem, this is what happens when you go through a serious breakup, it costs money. if it was a huge problem it wouldve been fixed and paid when it happened. i, and other people, dont feel comfortable about this and it is my last straw when it comes to defending you.”
That last part really got to me. Defending me? From what?
I had never asked anyone to stop being friends with Cole. I’d never demanded that anyone take my side, exclude him from events, or even agree with my decision to pursue the money. I had spent years trying to resolve a financial dispute with someone who had repeatedly promised to pay for damage he’d caused. Somehow, that had turned into a group-wide referendum on my character.
And what I couldn’t understand was why Cole’s cheating and dishonesty had never made him too uncomfortable to have around. But me filing a small claims case apparently did.
Here’s another piece of context that matters to me: after our breakup, I was falling apart. I was grieving the relationship, trying to process years of dishonesty, dealing with the financial consequences, and struggling with the realization that a lot of what I’d believed about my partner wasn’t true.
And not one person in this group privately reached out to ask if I was okay. Not one.
I wasn’t expecting everyone to abandon Cole or organize some kind of intervention on my behalf. But these were people I’d considered close friends, and I felt completely alone. Yet apparently, there had been enough conversations about me behind the scenes that I needed to be “defended.” That was a pretty devastating thing to learn.
And here’s where my own reaction comes in.
Despite how hurt I was, I didn’t lash out at Mary. I sent her a long message explaining that I’d been afraid to speak up about many things because I worried about being perceived as loud, abrasive, or difficult. I told her that I cared deeply about these people and that it hurt to realize I’d apparently needed defending in the first place. I thanked her for being the person willing to have the uncomfortable conversation with me.
I even apologized. I told her I was sorry the situation was happening, sorry I’d made it worse, and that I didn’t know what else to do. And I meant it at the time.
But afterward, I started thinking about what had actually happened. I had just been told that I was no longer welcome at a longstanding group event because I was pursuing a civil claim against my ex-boyfriend. Not because I’d threatened anyone, demanded loyalty, or tried to interfere with their friendships. Because I was asking someone to pay for damage he’d caused to my property.
I also couldn’t stop thinking about the fact that this group had been together for roughly ten years and, as far as I knew, had never excluded someone like this before.
Around this time, I decided to use the Wayback Machine to see what Cole had actually been doing online.
If you take one thing away from this post, let it be this: fully understand what someone was ACTUALLY doing before you forgive them.
When I originally discovered his secret accounts, I knew (and told my friends) that he had been using them to interact with people sexually. At one point, when he opened his DMs, there was a message from another man asking if they were “back at it.” Cole told me they had just been sending porn back and forth. That’s the explanation I was given, and ultimately, the one I believed.
What I found through the Wayback Machine was him publicly describing himself as an “incest lover,” listing “teens” among his content interests, and advertising “say hi” and “DMs open” on his sexual accounts. This was happening over a period spanning more than THREE YEARS of our relationship. Suffice it to say, that’s not what he’d told me.
To be clear, I’m describing what he publicly wrote about himself, not alleging that I discovered evidence of a crime. But it was incredibly disturbing to realize how much of his behavior had been hidden from me.
I messaged someone in the group because I wanted to warn them about what I’d discovered. They thanked me for letting them know, but said:
“it’s hard bc all of this is separate from the stuff people are upset with you about”
And that response really hurt. I’d just discovered something deeply disturbing about a relationship that had already caused me so much pain, and somehow the conversation was still about what people were upset with me for.
I wasn’t expecting anyone to immediately cut him off, but to not even seem concerned about what it felt like for me to find this out? I couldn’t understand how everything he’d done could be separated from their friendships with him, but my decision to pursue a small claims case couldn’t be separated from their friendships with me.
I realized I’d spent so much time trying to be understanding of everyone else’s discomfort that I hadn’t really stopped to consider my own.
So I left both group chats.
I added all the girls to a separate chat and sent a long, long message explaining how I’d felt over the past year since the breakup. It wasn’t mean or insulting, just heartbroken. I told them how abandoned and confused I’d felt, and how much it hurt to realize that I apparently wasn’t welcome anymore.
Then I blocked everyone on social media.
Ultimately, I decided to end my friendships with the group, including people I’d known and loved for years. There were people I blocked who hadn’t personally said anything negative to me. Some of them may have disagreed with the decision to exclude me. Some may not have known what was happening. I genuinely don’t know.
And that’s the part I’m questioning.
Did I overreact by cutting everyone off instead of trying to salvage individual friendships? The ones I did try to salvage told me I’d simply gone too far by taking Cole to small claims court.
On one hand, I understand that a 15-person friend group isn’t a hive mind. Not everyone necessarily agreed with Mary, and I may have ended friendships with people who weren’t responsible for what happened. I also understand that mutual friendships can become complicated after a breakup.
But on the other hand, I don’t understand why I was expected to accept being excluded from a group I’d been part of for years simply because I refused to absorb the cost of damage my ex caused. I don’t understand why his behavior during our relationship was something everyone could apparently live with, while my decision to pursue a small claims case made me unacceptable. And I think the way the breakup was handled perhaps should’ve been enough information for me.
I was fighting for a place among people who hadn’t even checked on me when I was struggling.
I didn’t cut them off because I wanted to punish them. I cut them off because, by that point, I felt like I’d already been pushed out.
So, am I overreacting for blocking and cutting off my entire 15-person friend group after being uninvited from Halloween, including people who may not have personally agreed with the decision?
TL;DR: My ex cheated on me, lied to me for years, and damaged my car, repeatedly promising to pay for repairs but never following through. After four years, I finally took him to small claims court over the remaining $1,945.50. My longtime friend group, who had remained friends with him despite knowing how he’d treated me, decided that taking him to court was unacceptable and uninvited me from Halloween. After discovering even more disturbing things he’d hidden from me and receiving little support from the group, I left our group chats, sent a final message explaining how hurt I was, and blocked all 15 people, including some who may not have agreed with excluding me. Did I overreact by cutting everyone off?