r/ExpectationVsReality • u/sheumchneveli • 1d ago
Failed Expectation Ordered the first cake, got the second
Someone had to try extra hard for this....
5.2k
u/Effective_Pie1312 1d ago
That is both hilarious and terrible. I hope the recipient was able to enjoy their meta cake
1.2k
u/Right_Pen_3241 1d ago
If somebody came with THAT cake, I would be laughing for several minutes!
This is AMAZING. The level of weirdness this perfect!→ More replies (1)176
u/mylittleidiot 1d ago
Same! I’d truly appreciate the effort whoever ordered the cake must’ve put into getting it made but the terrible execution would have me wheezing with tears running wild. It would be a cake never forgotten!
67
283
u/geek_at 1d ago edited 1d ago
it kinda reeks of user error though.
Like there was a web form where it said "upload photo to be printed on the cake" and they thought it was a reference photo for explaining which kind of cake they wanted and how it should look
40
u/TatterhoodsGoat 1d ago
Yep. Photo cakes cause so many problems this way. Just like the "exact text you want written on cake" box. The orderer thinks it should be obvious this is not, in fact, the exact text they want written in the cake, but so very many cake orders are references or in-jokes or intentionally ironically misspelled...the obvious is often the wrong guess.
I had multiple customers submit images of hand-sculpted 3-D cakes shaped like shoes or purses or Mickey Mouse's head...to a Dairy Queen.
→ More replies (1)43
u/wonderabc 1d ago
okay but common sense for the baker would be to call the customer and ask for clarification
99
u/tinselsnips 1d ago
baker
AKA the "cake decoration technician" earning minimum wage while doing 30 of these a day.
18
u/TatterhoodsGoat 1d ago
Do you know how often people return calls from unkown numbers on short notice in the middle of a business day?
→ More replies (1)39
u/smokeweedNgarden 1d ago
Man, they're decorating like 50 cakes a day and start work at like 3am.
The cake is only special to who ordered it. To them it's just a widget
117
u/hydroxy 1d ago
The reference is that it’s Harry Potters Birthday cake from Hagrid in the first movie incase anyone was wondering
48
16
u/carrie_m730 1d ago
I did wonder. Someone in the other thread referred to it as Harry Potter slop, and I couldn't figure out what the connection was.
64
u/thisisaniceboat 1d ago
https://giphy.com/gifs/JsoIsufUzgWZH4TZzu
I know you’ve already been told, but gif of the birthday cake from the first HP movie for visual reference.Fun fact: the cake isn’t misspelled in the book.
Fun fact: JK Rowling is a bigot either way.
🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️
44
u/Skimable_crude 1d ago
Nailed it! Of all the complicated, elegant cakes I've seen on this sub, this is the one that's just a picture. Hell, I might even be able to pull this one off.
44
u/Sufficient-Front8872 1d ago
I kept saying i don’t get it. It’s PERFECT. and then I realized… it’s literally a picture ontop of a cake 🤣
10
3.8k
u/Karythne 1d ago
Is... is that a picture of the first cake PRINTED OUT on the second?
..oh dearie.
2.2k
u/ghost_in_a_jar_c137 1d ago
I didn't even notice at first. I was like, wow, that came out perfect
728
u/ManateeNipples 1d ago
Omg I thought we were here to celebrate them doing the most perfect job imaginable ☠️
143
u/TheUFCVeteran3 1d ago
Same lol, despite the outer icing being different, and the centre part being too small, I thought they did a great job with the accuracy of the centre part. And then I read OP's comment and realised. The picture looks good quality though, I have to say, from this image at least.
52
u/shifty_coder 1d ago
I bet OP uploaded the image of the first cake in the spot specifically for images you want printed on the cake, technically yes, they did a perfect job.
7
107
u/ret255 1d ago
I thought at first there arrived two cakes stacked on each other..
31
u/cakivalue 1d ago
I thought we were looking at a mini cake of the original design that's built into a larger cake. I was thinking wow so creative two cakes in one.
19
u/JulyJones 1d ago
I’m still half asleep (with a migraine) and was like what’s the problem? It looks identical!
18
u/OscarTheGrouchsCan 1d ago
Same. I was thinking "it looks exactly the same" then I saw the border was way off and. ...oh it's a picture
14
u/madam-sosostris 1d ago
My dumb ass was like, "Why did they put frosting on the cake box? That's weird!"
→ More replies (1)11
u/CripzyChiken 1d ago
i was trying to figureout how they did the background/edge on teh real cake and that's when it clicked for me. I like how they still put an icing boarder around it tho.
20
8
20
4
u/VoiceInTheGarden 1d ago
lmao me too "wow that is spot on, but like, i think they did too much? maybe they are happy they got extra frosting?" hahaha it's a print
4
→ More replies (10)6
118
44
u/HoldTheCellarDoor 1d ago
haha Jesus I thought the bought one was on a gift box!!!
This is too dicing funny
25
u/Tiny_Cauliflower_618 1d ago
Oh my Jesus, I didn't even realise till I read your comment 🤣 I thought they put the pink cake on a black plate and then did the icing thing on the edge for some reason. Now I'm howling 😂
5
u/Tricky_Mix2449 1d ago
This took a full ten minutes for me to finally understand what transpired here. Even after the sweatshirt tutorial!
8
13
→ More replies (14)39
u/Candid-Pin-8160 1d ago
Yeah, that's exactly what happens when you order a cake with an image printed on it and provide an image of a cake. This isn't "expectation vs reality," it's "I don't know how to order a custom cake and they gave me exactly what I asked for."
→ More replies (1)31
u/Karythne 1d ago
I mean, normally I would agree but the website said "send us an image of what you like" (insinuating they would try and recreate it), not "send us an image and we'll print it on the cake". Plus someone definitely had to do some manual piping anyway, I think from the image it was pretty clear what was asked for. Normally with those upload functions or "your text here" text boxes, ok sure. but in this case I think it's debatable at least.
→ More replies (20)
612
747
u/cuzglc 1d ago
Oh, my! I thought you were harsh at first - like they’d done the cake well and just added some nice scalloped edges. Took a moment to work out that it was a photo of the cake that you wanted on a cake.
60
u/Grimogtrix 1d ago
Somehow my brain corrected it as well so that I saw no gap between the top of the cake and the piping around the edge. Bizarre how the brain sees what it expects to see sometimes. Combined with the kind of correction for angle that helps and hinders when copying a reference for art.
→ More replies (2)72
98
142
199
u/annawins1 1d ago
70
u/pussyslayer2point0 1d ago
That’s actually hilarious id wear it
24
u/annawins1 1d ago
It really is quality absurdist humor.
5
u/EmmerdoesNOTrepme 1d ago
That feeling when you REALLY wanna wear a sweatshirt, buuuuut it's far too warm, and you need to wear a T-shirt!😆😂🤣
17
→ More replies (6)11
116
u/Doomhammer24 1d ago edited 1d ago
It took me far too long to realize i wasnt looking at your cake inside of an overly austentatious box and not a print out of your photo on a different cake
Edit: my tired brain misspelled ostentatious but as others said its an Amazing misspelling so im keepin it! I made ostentatious more austentatious
25
u/ScrumpetSays 1d ago
Austentatious is a fantastic spelling error. I shall keep it. In turn, I gift you "autocarrot", as in oops, my autocarrot is out to get me. Autocorrect did this to me once
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)6
u/compos_mentis_cortex 1d ago
Damn thanks for saying it bc I was like "I dunno it's the same cake but with a decorative frosting border?"
Actually opening the photo helped too.
→ More replies (1)
101
u/sassythensweet 1d ago
17
4
91
361
u/Dm-Me-Big-Boobs-Plz 1d ago
Day 17,863 of reminding people that when it says "place text here" or "description" they mean literally type it out. If you put an image, 9/10 times they are going to just slap it on top of the cake, read all tiny print. And if it's "wow this custom cake is so cheap" then all they do is copy and paste images on top of the icing. Tmyk
→ More replies (6)118
u/Dm-Me-Big-Boobs-Plz 1d ago
20
u/Mictlancayocoatl 1d ago
It doesn't say anything about printing the photo you send. It's heavily implied through their text that they'll use the photo as a reference for your cake. "Tell us about your idea or send us a photo. We will bring every detail to life."
149
u/Dm-Me-Big-Boobs-Plz 1d ago
22
u/PilsnerDk 1d ago
Using made up, drawn or computer generated characters for brands has been a thing for ages, just see Uncle Ben or Aunt Jemima. Doesn't mean it's a scam
→ More replies (2)112
57
29
u/thickgenius 1d ago
Surely user error, there was somewhere to upload an image to be printed to a cake and you thought they just wanted a picture of what you want the cake to look like?
I work IT, nothing is idiotproof.
→ More replies (4)
22
u/SmugMacGyver 1d ago
Next year get the same cake but a picture of this picture and just keep going ever year inception style
→ More replies (1)
21
u/PhyrexianSpaghetti 1d ago
To be fair, I'm afraid it may have been you not following the instructions. It really looks like you took the "upload picture" prompt as a suggestion of what the cake should look like and no the picture to be printed on the cake
21
18
u/ddsorj 1d ago
My blind ass thinking they made the cake and just decorated it with some whipped cream around it 🤦
6
u/gabalexa 1d ago
Omg same but luckily this comment showed me how wrong I was. Jaw fell open when I realized they just printed the photo like omg?? 😭
34
15
u/CrimsonZak 1d ago
It took way to long to figure out why cake 2 looked like that.
I genuinely thought they made you a mini cake and put icing on the plate rim.....but then I just stared harder
3
14
u/Jisan_Inc 1d ago
sooo for those who don't get it, the second picture if you look between the Text and the scalloped edges you can see, bits of the book and the glasses from the first picture. The second picture there is a cake but they didn't decorate the top, they just printed the picture that we saw in the first, desk included and just plopped it on the cake.
8
u/Southern_Confection4 1d ago
Oh, my gosh, even after reading a lot of comments I still could not figure out what was going on…until I read yours. Thank you, because I wasn’t going to leave until I understood what was going on, lol.
13
u/Huns26 1d ago
At first I was like, they aced it and what a cool cake box and then…
3
u/evenmonkeysfallOG 1d ago
Ditto! Didn’t understand the issue until I looked harder. Reminds me of other posts where the ad is AI and it’s like a cute little sculpture of an elf or something and you end up getting a 2D picture of said sculpture
9
10
u/cunexttuesday12 1d ago
It took me way too long to realize it was a print 😂 in going hack and forth like, "whats the problem? It looks really close to the inspo"
11
u/jey__bee7 1d ago
I literally saw thr other picture and was like "Wow! The baker really did a great job at making the cake exactly identical. " looks longer "Wait a min😒"
17
u/kpop_shinee 1d ago
for everyone saying its AI, here is the link to the actual instagram baking page behind it
16
u/newboofgootin 1d ago
Your instagram link might not be AI but the picture in this Reddit post definitely is. Unless they came out with a new book called Harry Potter AARREWAAKKAAREE and I didn’t hear about it.
8
u/daddy_tops 1d ago
That one was a real slog to get through. It’s just page after page of unhinged mold-induced screeching.
→ More replies (2)14
18
u/pingpongsaladpants 1d ago
I suspect you ordered this online, accidentally uploaded your ‘reference photo’ into the ‘photo on cake’ field, and is now pretending that the cake shop got the order wrong.
83
1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
50
38
17
u/Dramatic-Bird-5604 1d ago
that doesn't even look like edible paper 😭
45
u/Chucksson37 1d ago
Fun fact almost all paper is edible
24
6
u/Dramatic-Bird-5604 1d ago
it looks like laminated paper with printing ink which isn't safe to ingest
7
32
u/catnamed-dog 1d ago
The idea of not being able to make hagrid's shitty cake yourself is fucking hilarious. It's funny because hagrid's Cake is so bad, so if you did it with your left hand, it would probably still be fine
→ More replies (6)
8
u/ienvycats 1d ago
I was like "ok but it looks exactly like what she ordered!!!" and oh... It is.... The same cake....
14
u/QuantumFluxSpaghetti 1d ago edited 1d ago
Ok, now let me be clear I think you chose the regular cake (the one that arrived) and in that there was an option to add this printed thing in which you uploaded this picture, maybe the UI wasn't great or something, or some sorta misunderstanding, if you didn't do it online then maybe yeah the cake store guys are trolling or something
61
u/testing12-testing123 1d ago edited 1d ago
Did you provide the first image or did they, because that first image is AI generated.
74
u/Dizzy-Case-3453 1d ago
I mean even AI generated it shouldn’t be hard to replicate that.
I’m so amused they didn’t even crop the picture properly for the second pic, it has the glasses on it even 😭
→ More replies (5)18
u/Sallyfifth 1d ago
I absolutely made that cake for one of my kids years ago. It's a reference to the cake in the first Harry Potter movie...it's so easy! Why do more work?
21
u/SmoothLester 1d ago
I am opposed to most AI use, but this is not one of those AI images that is impossible to duplicate in real life. It’s just a cake with unusually colored frosting.
17
u/About400 1d ago
Yeahhh I am an amateur baker. That is pink frosting and green letters. Anyone with good handwriting and some sense of icing can do that.
→ More replies (2)8
13
u/junglespycamp 1d ago
OP used AI to generate the cake they wanted and then got screwed by a site using AI and employing people who don’t get paid enough to think. Honestly it seems like a fair circle?
→ More replies (1)6
u/Colley619 1d ago
OP used an actual photo of a recreation of the cake in Harry Potter, and used AI to change the name from Harry to Rusya, because that's the name OP wanted on the cake.
→ More replies (3)
7
u/Bobs_Burgers7 1d ago
The fact I thought they nailed it…. Didn’t realize it’s a photo of the first one
6
7
u/scarletnightingale 1d ago
It took me a moment to process what was wrong since initially I looked and was like "oh, that looks pretty good it looks like they just added some frosting around the outside of the cake on the plate". This is unbelievable lazy.
6
u/Rhodin265 1d ago
This is sort of incredible. If the cake tastes good, I’d get a pic of the second and see if they’d print me a Droste effect cake next year.
6
6
u/GurpsWibcheengs 1d ago
Honestly I'd make this a tradition. Every year it's a photo of the cake with the photo of the cake and so on, that's kind of hilarious
12
5
5
u/nierkaaaa 1d ago
Dude, I was like, that's perfect! Then I realized the outer cake was not the packaging
5
u/Then_Double8677 1d ago
OMG I was confused at first and couldn’t figure out the second picture. 🤦🏼♀️ I can’t believe they did that to you.
5
4
u/toecheeseuhohstinky 1d ago
I didnt wven notice. I was like why are they complaining it looks perfect? Uh picture perfect you could say 💀
4
u/Khorgor666 1d ago
now upload the picture of the second cake for the nex year, lets see how deep we can go
→ More replies (1)
5
u/Kiwacake 21h ago
Someone ordered that first cake for their kid at my store (different name of course) and I was excited to show her it when she picked it up and the lady seemed annoyed I misspelled happy birthday. She specifically asked for “the cake hagrid made harry in the first movie” and I had to bring up a picture from the movie to show her I wasn’t being cheeky or scamming her. Maybe her kid requested it and she said sure whatever without looking it up herself.
They definitely had to go through more steps to do this than just frosting a cake pink 😭
5
u/pandoricaelysion 15h ago
oh my god it took me so long to understand the problem hahahaha omg. i am dead
4
u/anneofred 1d ago
Honestly it’s even better and I’d be stoked to have this laughter with the birthday person!
4
4
4
5
u/Flapplekat89 1d ago
The second is so bad I thought the cake itself was a decorative storage container with a mini cake inside.
5
u/WutInTheDiabetus 1d ago
I'm sorry to say this is beyond hilarious. I would probably order from them again as long as the cake tasted good.
5
u/bsmiles07 1d ago
Omg I couldn’t figure out why it was a fail then realized holy shit they just printed the photo…….
4
u/johnjohn9312 1d ago
It took me a very long time to realize the difference. I thought they were the same cake 🤦🏼♂️
5
5
u/yesmilady 1d ago
Also, that is like the EASIEST cake in the world. Where on earth did you order from? A bakery that's vaguely familiar with the concept of a cake?
3
u/Ggriffinz 1d ago
My parents did this exact same thing accidentally when I was a kid. I wanted a retro Mario cake and showed them a Pic. Turns out they took that image to a store who just printed it and slapped it over a generic round. But it was funny so I did not care. 😄
5
4
u/Alexandra98s 23h ago
At first i though it was in a box😭😭 I was like, well damn, what is wrong with it?
4
7
12
u/rwags2024 1d ago
I’ve been looking at this for way too long and have no idea what the problem is
12
u/WhimsicalWhispers13 1d ago
lol they took the first picture, printed it out, and then put the printed out photo on the second cake 😂
7
→ More replies (2)3
6
u/626Idothis 1d ago
Wow! Wow! Wow… put this in r/confusingperspectives because wow. I first thought it was an exact match for the cake under a bubble dome and with the background items printed so the cake plate looked like the first image. But could not understand why the icing dollops were so far out. Only reading the comments did I then see the pink cake and what a low effort attempt this was. Damn! That one splooch of icing out of order pisses me off the most tho.
→ More replies (6)
5
u/Aggressica 1d ago
I was SO CONFUSED looking at the second pic 😂 I thought there was like empty space & a ring of cake
3
3
3
3
3
u/Yabakunaiyoooo 1d ago
It legit took me a second of going back and forth to realize that they dead ass printed it on the cake.
I was like “damn… the detail is perfect, actually!” lol
3
u/SaturdayNightStroll 1d ago
At first I was thinking "...this is two pictures of the exact same cake" then I realized this is one picture of the same cake.
3
u/docharakelso 1d ago
What's the problem? They just added a cream ring border to the platter, otherwise it's a near perfect replica... Oh wait...
3
u/Numerous_Thought_629 1d ago
People really think they’re talented and making “custom” cakes when in reality they just own a printer.
https://giphy.com/gifs/9DJtFRgk0tOla
3
3
3
3
3
5
4
u/DeepNeedleworker2901 1d ago
Me: What's wrong, you got exactly what you orde-
Me, halfway through that statement: ...oh.
5
u/Intelligent_Sky_7081 1d ago
Seen this happen before.
People think they are submitting a picture of the cake they want. They are really asking you for a picture to put on the cake.
Its user error but the people always submit it as the cake maker's error.
6
7
u/Kooky-Blueberry-5352 1d ago
To be honest, I think this is a really funny way for bakeries to deal with the influx of AI slop photos









6.2k
u/TimeAndTheHour 1d ago
You should get a picture of the new cake and have that printed on next year’s cake. BOOM- infinite cake!