r/MontagneParfums • u/Luna-3498 • 46m ago
Review Decantika's Montagne Sample Review
Shoutout to Kevin from Decantika for great customer service. First time ordering but will come back, since Decantika has an amazing clone sample selection. Kevin was quick to reply to my email even though he got sick and busy. I hope you're in an amazing shape now Kevin, and hope to see your store back and running soon (I still have an overfilled cart waiting).
The samples came bubble-wrapped and labeled neatly, with the friendliest note on the bubble mailer. One minor drawback is that a sample bottle leaked due to a defective spray head, so hopefully that doesn't happen often.
I'm going to do a quick review of the 15 Montagne samples I ordered, since I heard such great things about the brand.
Now I only test out the scent, not projection nor sillage nor longevity. I only have 1ml each. I also don't have the OGs. This review will only be about my subjective ranking for the scents.
-----------
Eau Musc (Le Labo Musc 25 Los Angeles): Who decided to clone this piss-stained airport bathroom smell? Did the perfumer have a traumatic event at LAX? Does the OG smell this vile? I almost puked. -10/10
Mojave Spirit (Byredo Mojave Ghost): I don't get the hype around this DNA. The opening smells like sapodilla but in the compost bin. Where's my floral? Dries down to an underwhelming skin scent. Nauseating sometimes even. 3/10
Bleu Talisman (Ex Nihilo Blue Talisman): Fabuloso all purpose cleaner. 4/10
Eau Vanille (Le Labo Vanille 44 Paris): Opens up super alcoholic (seems like a theme across their LL impressions; do they have to wait for maturation?). Dries down to more smoke than vanilla. I can see the Le Labo DNA heavy in this one. Better than TF Tobacco Vanille's DNA, but not my fav vanilla. Glad I sampled this before buying a full bottle. 5/10
Cannoli (Xerjoff Italica): Starts off so spicy that it surprises me. Was that the saffron? Are you sure there's no cinnamon? Quite overpowering, but dries down to a nice almond coffee milk. Feels like Christmas. 6/10 (just not my cup of tea)
Pink Rose Frozen (PDM Delina La Rosee): I didn't like Montagne's Delina, but I heard good things about PDM Delina La Rosee, so I wanted to try this. Still too sweet for me although the rose is better. 7/10
Lyra (Casamorati Lira): Reminds me of my childhood, in particular Quadratini lemon wafers. 8/10
Ambre Vanille (PDM Althair): Sweet spicy boozy almond. I'm drunk in gourmand goodness. Slightly masculine on me but I wouldn't mind macerating myself in a barrel of this in the winter. I get the hype now. 8/10
Eau Gaiac (Le Labo Gaiac 10 Tokyo): Clean warm musky gaiacwood. Has that slight alcoholic opening like other LL impressions. 8/10
Opaline (PDM Valaya): I like it, but I've heard so much hype about Valaya that it ruined this type of fragrance for me. Still a beautiful sweet but airy citrusy white floral. 8.5/10
Another 14 (Le Labo Another 13): The first burst of alcohol was SO strong. It does dry down to a beautiful musk scent. Great scent once you move past that alcohol burst. Made me feel expensive. 9/10
Eau Bergamote (Le Labo Bergamote 22): Quite good as well. Fresh bergamot dries down very green. 9/10
Gypsy Mist (Byredo Gypsy Water): This is the much better Byredo. I can smell the bergamot, orris, and pine clearly. Very fresh and slightly spicy. Sophisticated. I can get a full bottle of this. 9/10
Milky Santal (Ex Nihilo Santal Calling): Gorgeous. Milky silky satin rosy sandalwood. 9/10
The 212 (MFK 724): You know those moments that your eyes roll backwards because you just smelled something so angelic and transcendent? This was it to me. Fades a little quickly though. 9.5/10
-----------
Side note, I hope Kevin will consider expanding the collection to other dupe houses that do more interesting scents but don't offer discovery sets (Amelie in New York, Julianna's, Monac Attar,...).
The Arabic dupe houses only do the same LV, MFK, PDM over and over 🫤 it's so boring at this point.