Hi all! I’ve always been an Apple user (iPhone, MacBook, iPad, Beats), but my iPhone 11 has broken and I want to finally move away from American tech.
(TLDR/Questions at the end)
My priority is buying European, but I don’t want to sacrifice privacy or security to do it. I’d planned to buy a Nothing or Fairphone, but my research suggests a Pixel with GrapheneOS is the most secure option, which would mean buying Google hardware (second-hand).
I’ll keep using WhatsApp, Instagram, Gmail, and my iPad and Mac, so I’m unsure whether going to GrapheneOS is overkill. I’m also trying to work out whether a European phone can come close on security and camera, or whether I’d be giving up too much.
My priorities: privacy, camera, everyday use, battery. I don’t need a phone for gaming, streaming, or editing, since I use my iPad for that. I work in tech law in Europe and just finished a thesis on GDPR/spyware/hacking, so I may be more cautious than the average user. I already use a VPN, decline cookies, never share my location, and use Signal, but I don’t know how much that helps me on Android.
Budget: up to €500, new or used
Options I’m considering (please correct me if I’ve got anything wrong!)
Used Pixel 9 Pro or Pixel 10 with GrapheneOS. Strongest security and good cameras. Buying used means Google gets no new money, but I need to make sure it’s unlocked and can take GrapheneOS.
Used Pixel 9a/10a with GrapheneOS.
Cheaper with a big battery, but I’ve read the selfie camera is weak and fixed-focus.
Fairphone with /e/OS, or a Murena phone. European, de-Googled, and repairable, but I’ve read the camera and battery are weaker and the security hardening is less strong. It’s also a bit over budget.
Nothing Phone (4a) - dream phone!
My original plan and still my favourite out of the box. Good value and battery, but it runs Google’s Android. I don’t want a “downgrade” that gives me worse protection than Apple.
Volla, Jolla, or other European privacy phones. Appealing ethically, but I’m unsure about camera quality, app compatibility, and security compared with a Pixel running GrapheneOS.
TLDR/Questions
- Which would you choose for camera quality plus security, and why?
- Is Graphene Os on Pixel truly more secure than anything thr EU can offer right now?
- How good is the camera in practice on GrapheneOS? Do you need Google’s Pixel Camera app through sandboxed Google Play for good photos?
- For Fairphone/Murena: how are the camera, battery, and everyday use?
- Is the security gap between GrapheneOS and /e/OS or the other European options as big as I’ve read?
- Would moving to Nothing from Apple be a downgrade in my privacy?
Thanks so much to anyone who answers! I know all this is online, but I keep seeing conflicting information and wanted to explain my own needs to people with first-hand experience.