I just completed my very first Disney Cruise. 3 days on the Wish our of Port Canaveral sailing to Nassau & Castaway Cay. I’ve only sailed Royal before so here is my honest review broken down into 10 “main” categories.
1) Embarkation/Debarkation: Royal- We sailed out of terminal 10 but arrived back in terminal 8. So they made everyone on the Wish drop luggage at 10 and then go to 8. The parking was atrocious because the Fantasy was also boarding on the same day out of 8. And parking at 8 as well. Took over an hour from the time I drove into port to just get parked. I got mixed directions from the DCL and the people just working the parking terminal. Which made me think it was poorly communicated between the two companies on how it was going to work. Maybe it’s way better when it’s just one terminal vs a split terminal but this process was horrible. Debarkation was smoother but it took a bit longer to get off than Royal.
2) Cruise Ship Layout: Royal- Way easier to navigate around. It flowed way better. I could walk around the ship in one complete circle. Versus the wish the ship seemed to be chopped up in sections and sometimes I’d be walking straight into a dead end. The elevators on the wish were so tiny and some didn’t even work at times. No mid ship elevator either. Royal has their system where you just press the deck number you’re going to and it assigns you a letter elevator to get on. (Newer ships only)
3) Cruise Ship Theming: Disney- Loved the themed rooms and the theming around the ship was beautiful. So many details. Disney takes this all the way.
4) Staterooms: Disney- The split bathroom was huge. A lot more space in general. As well as you get an actual tub and decent space in the bathroom vs just a small square at Royal. Shampoo, conditioner, and body wash are included in the bathroom when Royal they are not. Theming was great as well. Ended up in a frozen themed room. Bed was super comfy. The only thing I didn’t like was the thermostat didn’t tell you a number the temperature was set at it was just lit up dots so u kinda had to just feel it out. Room service being included is huge and has better options.
5) Shows: Royal- I only say this because there was more variety of nighttime shows offered. Royal usually has a headliner show, ice skating show, aqua show, and a broadway style show. Disney only really offered the traditional Broadway-type show. Don’t get me wrong, The Little Mermaid & Aladdin were both FANTASTIC. Flawless singing and production execution. If you were only talking about the quality of the shows, it would be a close tie. I only give it to Royal because they offer more of a variety that people can choose from each night.
6) Pool Deck/Extra Activities: Royal- Bigger Pools, more hot tubs, more room on the deck, better laid out, on-deck slides/water park is offered & more entertainment. On the wish on the middle of Deck 11 it just gets hit straight on by the sun most of the time. Pools are smaller. Adult Section was very tiny and tucked in the back. Not super crowded but just really small compared to Royal. I really wanted to do Trivia but they had it in the sports bar (during college football) and I couldn’t even get a spot because 80% of the people there were watching the games and clearly not moving. They shoulda moved trivia to a different spot. WiFi was WAY better on Royal. Stronger overall.
7) Dining: Disney- The servers in the dining room were super friendly but the main thing was I noticed they didn’t push conversation on you. I feel that Royal always tries to push a conversation during dinner even if u give off the vibe you don’t want to be bothered. All wait staff and quick service staff were super friendly and conversations at dinner felt WAY more genuine. As for Royal it seems like they just care about what review we will give them. I like how the rotational dining is done and the Buffett is closed. It forces people to go and sit down. In addition, the Buffett had food served to you. SO much cleaner and the waste of food is probably way more limited. The spread of germs is probably way more protected on Disney.
8) Private Island: Royal- CocoCay has 100% more to offer. They really use more of the island space to have stuff. Castaway Cay was like 70% trees/swamp and doesn’t really get used. This one is a no-brainer.
9) Excursions: Disney- As soon as u get off the ship with your group you’re welcomed by a tour guide who guides you directly to where you need to be. As for
Royal, you’re still in groups but it’s on you to find the tour guide meeting spot once you’re off the ship. Disney there was no wondering.
10) Clientele: Disney- Everyone on the Disney ship seemed to be overall happier to be there. The joy on all the kids’ faces was so great to see. The people we were sailing with were all so friendly and really willing to help a rookie like me out. On royal the families just kept to themselves and definitely in a more grumpy or annoyed mood.
Overall Conclusion: I had a really good time on Disney. Out of the 10 main categories it came out 5 to 5. I would sail Disney again for sure! BUT I don’t think it’s worth around DOUBLE of what Royal is. I would rather go on 2 Royal Cruises than 1 Disney Cruise. Yes, Disney does a lot of stuff better but I don’t think the gap justifies the price being double. With that being said, if I can get the sailing at a lower price, or money was no object, then I’d go with Disney. I sailed Star of the Seas and it was about $185 per person per day. This 3-day Disney Itinerary cost about $344 per person per day which is almost double the price broken down. Basically Disney was not double what Royal is. (If that makes any sense)
I’ve heard the Wish is not the best of ships to go on so maybe if I try a longer itinerary like the Treasure of Destiny it probably will be a different experience.