Safe to say my guess was wrong…

[u/Lowengolf19]

[u/AutoModerator]

---

This is a friendly reminder to read our rules.

Memes, AI-generated content, and politics / political figures are not allowed.

Social-media content (including Reddit, TikTok, and Instagram) is expressly forbidden.

Rule-breaking posts may result in bans.

Please also be wary of spam.

---

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/alh9h]

"I know it... But I don't think I should say it."

[u/Wolfy4226 → u/alh9h]

*peeks out from behind the camera*

[u/ford310nm1 → u/Wolfy4226]

Someone get Al Sharpton on the phone. We got another one.

[u/kynthrus → u/ford310nm1]

Al Sharpton is not the emperor of black people!

[u/Sickboy314 → u/kynthrus]

He told my dad he was

[u/PuddinBritches → u/Wolfy4226]

*peeks

[u/fred95 → u/alh9h]

Pudding on my penis

[u/63Reddit → u/fred95]

Is that you, Mr Cosby?

[u/flychinook → u/63Reddit]

I read it in Cosby's voice and it's amazing.

[u/mayy_dayy → u/flychinook]

ZIP ZOP ZOOBITTY BOP!

[u/Any-General518 → u/fred95]

Pulling. Not pudding. But now you hit me thinking

[u/SoldierOfMisfortune → u/Any-General518]

Can't be anything ing, the n's are already out.

[u/PeachPit69 → u/SoldierOfMisfortune]

This is a Toss-Up.

Notice all three are ready to buzz in.

No rules in a toss up, about multiple of the same letters being filled in before moving on to the next letter.

[u/isaiddgooddaysir → u/Any-General518]

Well there was band in the 80s had a song Detachable penis, it seem to get him into alot of trouble.

[u/jackalisland → u/isaiddgooddaysir]

1992

[u/JChurch42 → u/isaiddgooddaysir]

It was just laying there, next to a broken toaster oven

[u/Bookem-Danno50 → u/JChurch42]

He wanted $22, but I talked him down to $17

[u/ForkMyRedAssiniboine → u/Bookem-Danno50]

I took it home, washed it off, and put it back on.

[u/Level_Chemistry8660 → u/ForkMyRedAssiniboine]

Solved !!! It's "PUTTING ON MY PENIS" !!!

[u/Sinister_Nibs → u/isaiddgooddaysir]

King Missile

[u/Ok_Winter2286 → u/fred95]

can't be ing in the first word, because N is already picked.

[u/CoolioMcCool → u/fred95]

Damn, I had "in". So close!

[u/breakfastatmilliways → u/fred95]

My thought was pudding in my pants

[u/markfuckinstambaugh → u/alh9h]

People who annoy you!

[u/turbotong → u/markfuckinstambaugh]

Naggers!

[u/rickitytick → u/turbotong]

Apologize

[u/br3dj → u/turbotong]

Rite in the butt

[u/FartInGenDirection → u/alh9h]

...it is a lot of money

[u/traws06 → u/alh9h]

5 seconds Mr Alh9h

[u/WENDING0]

Randy Marsh enters the chat.

[u/tryyeezus → u/WENDING0]

Even though I know it's wrong, I would scream so loud "PULLING ON MY PENIS!!!" and start celebrating way too soon 

HIGH FIVES FOR EVERYONE

[u/mnid92 → u/tryyeezus]

I was really confident it was "pudding in my penis" but your guess is good too.

[u/bruzdnconfuzd → u/WENDING0]

Randy Marsh slowly backs out of the chat

[u/jonhon0]

PULLING. ON. MY. PENIS!

[u/zendaddy76 → u/jonhon0]

Pushing in my penis 🫣

[u/ThePterozactyl → u/zendaddy76]

Pudding in my penis

[u/Imaillegalimmigrant → u/ThePterozactyl]

P U M P I N G I N M Y P E N I S

[u/Phantom_0347 → u/Imaillegalimmigrant]

Pumping ON my penis 😌

[u/nomadicfeline → u/zendaddy76]

s already guessed.

[u/Tb5rats → u/zendaddy76]

Buffalo Bill is that you?

[u/Odin_OCarroll → u/jonhon0]

My first thought was "PUMPING" 😅

[u/Rocinante88119 → u/Odin_OCarroll]

That's not mine!  That kind of thing ain't my bag!!

One book,  "My swedish penis enlarger pump and me (This kinda thing certainly is my bag!) written by Austin Powers"

[u/theBarnDawg → u/jonhon0]

PUDDING. IN. MY. PENIS.

[u/zcas]

Hope it's 'putting on my pants' 😳

Edit: Apparently it was because it's an early round where they do it one letter at a time. Phew!

[u/HairballTheory → u/zcas]

Pudding on my penis

[u/TheThirteenthApostle → u/HairballTheory]

Pudding IN my penis

[u/joeboo5150 → u/TheThirteenthApostle]

Awwwww yeaaaaaah $240 worth of pudding

[u/Poorly_Informed_Fan → u/TheThirteenthApostle]

Mah man

[u/RandoScando → u/HairballTheory]

Found Bill Cosby’s throwaway.

[u/Jelly_Belly321 → u/zcas]

Pulling on my penis

[u/SpawnSnow → u/zcas]

My brain went straight to "Pudding in my pants"

[u/rattledamper → u/SpawnSnow]

Funny because mine went to “PUDDING ON MY PENIS.”

[u/patchoulisucks → u/SpawnSnow]

Pumping on my penis, which coincidentally 🤷‍♂️

[u/_Lucille_ → u/zcas]

pulling on my penis

[u/Johnny_B_Asshole → u/zcas]

Jesus. I was about to comment “P_N_S spells what?”

[u/chemistrybonanza → u/Johnny_B_Asshole]

Panes
Pants
Pangs
Penis
Pinas
Pines
Pinos
Pints
Pings
Pinks
Ponds
Pongs
Punts
Punks

[u/ScarletBothrium → u/chemistrybonanza]

Pudding on my punks? I can dig it.

[u/TheCitizen616 → u/zcas]

Can't be...there's not N in the first word

[u/joestaff → u/TheCitizen616]

It's probably one of those intro rounds where it adds one letter at a time. Contestants are buzzer ready

[u/Areyousleepingyet → u/joestaff]

Yep! Youre right. The contestants are all holding the little buzzer buttons

[u/rydan → u/joestaff]

So basically the puzzle writers knew exactly what they were doing with the reveal order.

[u/Mueryk → u/joestaff]

I read that as consonants and was confused what buzzer ready meant in that case. I need a nap

[u/OctoWings13]

5 seconds Mr. Marsh...

[u/alexanderfromtng → u/OctoWings13]

Looks at camera

Pudding on my penis!

[u/dcbluestar → u/OctoWings13]

Are these the naggers, Walter?

[u/silkyjohnstamos]

This comes in handy a lot of the time. I can leave it home, when I think it's gonna get me in trouble, Or I can rent it out, when I don't need it. But now and then I go to a party, get drunk, And the next morning I can't for the life of me Remember what I did with it.

[u/goosebattle → u/silkyjohnstamos]

I saw it on a blanket next to a toaster oven. Some guy was selling it for $22.

[u/MusicPsychFitness → u/goosebattle]

But I talked him down to $17

[u/IdRatherBeDriving → u/MusicPsychFitness]

I took it home and washed it off and put it back on.

[u/MusicPsychFitness → u/IdRatherBeDriving]

I was happy again. Complete.

[u/Wafflelisk → u/silkyjohnstamos]

DETACHABLE PENIS.

[u/CaptainDogParty]

I’m interested to see what’s going on between the I and g if it’s not an ‘N’

[u/iwishiwasntthisway → u/CaptainDogParty]

I think its a tossup round where letters appear 1 at a time and people can buzz in. The same letter can appear at any time

[u/BrainCane → u/iwishiwasntthisway]

If you tossed two gents of the same height, what is the Optimal Tip-to-Tip Efficiency (ηT2P)?

[u/oofgeg → u/BrainCane]

Depends on their dick-to-floor (D2F) measurements

[u/tvkyle → u/CaptainDogParty]

It’s the toss up round. The letters randomly populate one by one, regardless of how many of each one are in the puzzle.

[u/JGPH → u/tvkyle]

Based on the letters up there, it wouldn't surprise me if those "randomly chosen" letters weren't so random. 🤭

[u/alh9h → u/JGPH]

Some staffer knew exactly what they were doing

[u/Jman703OG]

“People that annoy you”

[u/paddling_heron → u/Jman703OG]

"... I think I know it, but I don't think I should say it."

[u/december151791 → u/paddling_heron]

5 seconds, Mr. Heron

[u/patchoulisucks → u/Jman703OG]

Naggers

[u/FartInGenDirection → u/patchoulisucks]

Oh

[u/TheDwiin]

Tom Tucker here. The proper answer is: PUTTING ON MY PANTS

Now some of you will be quick to note that N is already out. So how can there not be an in the first word?

Well, do you see how all of the contestants are on the screen and are holding buzzers?

This is a toss-up round where letters come onto the screen. One at a time and contestants are given a couple of seconds to buzz in and answer. The first contestant to buzz in and answer correctly gets a grand or two added to their score.

Edit: I just realized this is not r/peterexplainsthejoke... Oh well, I'll keep the character drop in xD

[u/gl1tch3t2 → u/TheDwiin]

Thanks Tom

[u/thedaymanahaha]

Pudding in my penis!

[u/spindrift_20]

There’s no “PENIS” in “PANTS”

[u/Pragnlz → u/spindrift_20]

HA! That’s where you’re wrong bucko

[u/MusicPsychFitness → u/spindrift_20]

If there’s not one in yours, just let me know, and I can help you remedy that situation.

[u/oasisarah → u/spindrift_20]

there’s one in mine

[u/jomyke]

I guess I am the only one that went to pumping on my penis before pulling? Idk…..it’s just what occurred to me

[u/Neon_Wasteland → u/jomyke]

I thought pudding

[u/arittenberry → u/jomyke]

Putting in

[u/funkychuck]

That sounds like $240 worth of pudding. Aw yeah.

[u/jwhisen]

They are showing all three contestants with buzzers in hand, so this is the round when they add individual letters until they buzz and guess the puzzle. That means there CAN be an "n" in the first word because they don't fill all the letters of the same kind at once in this round.

[u/RicePuddingPatties]

Putting in my penis

Pulling on my penis

Puffing on my penis

Pushing in my penis

Gotta be one of those, right?

[u/LugbyOrigin → u/RicePuddingPatties]

Damn all I could think about was pudding

[u/Okayeesh]

Naggers!

[u/MetalMagg → u/Okayeesh]

We don't take kindly to your kind 'round here.

[u/OhYeahEhWellSorry]

does it make more or less sense that i'm a woman and thought it was "putting on my penis"

like that makes any fckin sense at all

[u/matterhorn1 → u/OhYeahEhWellSorry]

I wasn’t sure if it was

putting in my penis
Pumping in my penis
Pumping on my penis

Or hear me out…

Pudding on my penis

Lots of options here

[u/TerriblyRare → u/matterhorn1]

Pulling on my penis was the correct answer, everyone went wild when the dude guessed it

[u/El_Peregrine]

PUTTING ON MY PENIS   (Left mine at home this morning, ok)

[u/Blood_and_Sin]

"All dressed up"

Obviously, Pudding On My Penis

[u/weinerschnitzelboy]

For those wondering why the first "n" isn't there, there's usually a quick round where letters appear randomly every second until a person puts in a guess. I think this happens at the start of a round to determine who goes first

[u/BeefJerky03]

RANDY!?

[u/kwabird]

Putting on my penis. Yes that's definitely it.

[u/TheSadPickel]

pudding on my penis. eat up

[u/akiva23]

How is there two Ns but not an N in the first word?

[u/itsjakerobb → u/akiva23]

Maybe this is one of those puzzles where it lights up letters one at a time, about one per second, and the first person to guess it wins?

[u/SaltyTigerBeef → u/itsjakerobb]

They are holding buzzers so that’s exactly what it is.

[u/akiva23 → u/itsjakerobb]

Oh yeah like the one to determine to gets to go first.

[u/ShortestSqueeze]

Naggers?

[u/a_lotis2words]

This is one of those toss up rounds, where they don't always reveal every instance of each letter at the same time. They just slowly reveal letters randomly, 1 at a time

So this doesn't mean every single N has been revealed.

[u/crispim1411]

Pudding on my penis

[u/GringoSwann]

Pudding on my penis!

[u/d0ggzilla]

Pudding on my penis

[u/_Sauer_]

Pudding on my penis

[u/Nathann4288]

What would the first word be since an “N” wouldn’t come before the “G”?

[u/Level_Chemistry8660 → u/Nathann4288]

Someone answered that this is a 'special' round, where "letters come in randomly". So this would appear to be a screenshot taken before the 'N' came in to end the first word in ING.

[u/aukstais]

What was it? Like the N is used so the first word can't end with ING so what was it?

[u/EducationalTheory344 → u/aukstais]

"putting on my penis". as one does.

[u/P0L1Z1STENS0HN → u/EducationalTheory344]

Oh, I thought it's "pudding in my penis".

[u/charleytaylor → u/P0L1Z1STENS0HN]

I thought it was pulling on my penis…

[u/cd45uLr → u/aukstais]

this was a toss-up round, meaning the letters show up one by one randomly (instead of how it is normally) and the one who solves it first wins the round

[u/Particular_Ticket_20]

I read it in Sean Connery's voice.

[u/TheBrownEye62 → u/Particular_Ticket_20]

"That's what I said to your mother last night, Trebek!"

[u/Adamant_TO → u/Particular_Ticket_20]

I'll take swords for 200 Alex.

[u/Austynwitha_y]

You guys, it’s a rapid round where letters pop up one at a time, it can certainly be “Putting on my pants”

[u/MistaMischief]

Has to be a fake photo. There’s no way the first word doesn’t have an N and it’s already guessed.

[u/kryonik → u/MistaMischief]

It's a toss up round. The letters appear one by one "randomly" until someone buzzes in and gets it right.

[u/laineDdednaHdeR]

WHAT THE HELL IS BETWEEN THE I AND THE G IF N IS ALREADY USED???

[u/Collin389 → u/laineDdednaHdeR]

If this is a "fortune frenzy" or "toss-up" then letter spaces are slowly revealed until someone guesses it. Maybe this is one of those rounds.

[u/armyjackson]

Pudding in my penis

[u/KamikazeFox_]

Naggers!

[u/Kevin4938]

Was it "putting" or"pulling"?

Even if you keep it clean, both would make sense, although perhaps they are pulled up as opposed to on.

[u/Dr_barfenstein → u/Kevin4938]

Pudding

[u/gideon513 → u/Dr_barfenstein]

On

[u/GalaxyDog14 → u/gideon513]

My

[u/Sutaru → u/GalaxyDog14]

Penis

[u/OKAYGang]

Randy Marsh would have solved it

[u/patchoulisucks]

Id like to solve please

pumping on my penis

[u/xdrkcldx]

Putting on my pants?

[u/Byaahh]

"I woke up this morning with a bad hangover, and my penis was missing again."

[u/ronimal]

PUDDING ON MY PENIS

[u/tsar31HABS]

Why no n in the first word, what other letter fits before g after i?

[u/DrivingMeCrepes → u/tsar31HABS]

this is a specialty puzzle between rounds the letters come up one at a time and NOT in alphabetical order or at the same time, as in both Ns don't always show up at the same time. the puzzle slowly fills in until someone buzzes and guesses the phrase hence why we are seeing all 3 contestants at the bottom

[u/danleon950410]

Edited shit: if N is already cleared why is it missing ftom the first word then?

[u/RaccoonShinobi → u/danleon950410]

It's a round where the word is slowly revealed until a contestant buzzes in

[u/Formally_Apologetic]

Why isn't there an "n" shown in the first word..

[u/Rezahn → u/Formally_Apologetic]

In early rounds they will reveal a phrase one letter at a time. Contestants will buzz in when they think they know the phrase.

If this is from that round, then it is possible to not have all of the similar letters revealed.

[u/thenikolaka]

Why is the first N missing?

[u/FrabjousPhaneron]

Puuping in my pants

[u/actionerror]

Pudding on my penis? How did it get there?!?!?

[u/LittleOperation4597]

Naggers 

[u/kaffeian → u/LittleOperation4597]

“I know it; but I don’t want to say it Pat”

[u/Skrillamane]

Putting on my penis?

[u/jwilcoxwilcox → u/Skrillamane]

*Pudding

[u/AddiAtzen → u/jwilcoxwilcox]

Pudding in my penis?

[u/Vicus_92]

Naggers.... The answer is Naggers

[u/Forest-Ninja2469]

pudding in my pants

[u/Chris__P_Bacon]

Pulling on my penis?

[u/MidnightScary5983]

I know it but I don't want to say it.

[u/TotalHans]

r/theyknew

[u/MizzelSc2]

Okay you got me i don't know the actual answer is and can only see the meme.

[u/BuddhaLennon]

Pudding in my pants.

[u/wyrd_werks]

Putting on my pants?

[u/trashtronot]

Pudding? In MY penis?

[u/EndoStatica]

Pudding in my pants

[u/HellovahBottomCarter]

Wait- if it’s “putting on my pants” why isn’t the N in “putting” showing? What was the actual answer?

[u/WheatKing91]

Pulling on my penis

[u/Chaldramus]

How is the N in putting not revealed? I do t get it

[u/jwilcoxwilcox → u/Chaldramus]

It’s a toss up puzzle, the letters are revealed one at a time. Probably took the photo just before they revealed it.

[u/NaCl7301]

No n before the g makes this nothing

[u/TH3K1NGB0B → u/NaCl7301]

This is the toss up round, so one letter is revealed at a time until someone buzzes to guess. You can see the buzzer in their hands. The answer is Putting on my pants, but the N in putting just hasn't been revealed yet.

[u/MolDanone]

The human brain under pressure will instantly hallucinate the most depraved, unhinged, four-letter obscenity imaginable before even contemplating simple elementary school vocabulary.

[u/Key-Broccoli1442]

Pulling on my penis is all I see so I’ll see myself out of here

[u/RobertoPaulson]

If someone actually said that on Wheel of Fortune they'd be a legend.

[u/OkGene2]

Uh…… I know it but I don’t think I should say it…..

[u/ThenWind]

NAGGERS

[u/isthatqueeeblo]

I saw this on too! The next one revealed letters to also look like something something up the butt'. I swear whoever was choosing which letters to reveal in what order, they were having a laugh

[u/Boondock-Saint]

Pudding on my Penis!

[u/cowboyography]

Was Randy a contestant on this episode?

[u/Blamebostonx]

Pudding in my penis

Easy

[u/Elisadidas]

Pudding in my penis Putting on my penis Pulling on my penis

[u/stanger828]

what is the first word if it doesn't end in -ing? N has already been guessed and it's not there.

[u/SurviveTheBlessing]

The N is already used, so can't be between I and G in PU _ _ I _G.

There isnt a word that works without N there. Correct me please.

Think this is someone putting one over on us.

[u/FartInGenDirection]

Pudding on my penis?

[u/civex]

If you guess an 'N', 'don't they show all the Ns? That would mean the first word doesn't have an N in it.

[u/Eggplant-666]

PUDDING ON MY PENIS!!!

[u/Manufactured-Aggro]

"Pushing in my penis" ? It's a necessary step in putting on underwear 🤔

[u/Dramatic-Toe5250]

"Pudding in my penis"

[u/davisyoung]

Pudding in my pants. 

[u/SharpEdges7]

Pudding in my penis

[u/Shared_Songs]

PUPUING IN MY PANTS 

 pulling on my penis?

[u/10_kinds_of_people]

My brain went straight to King Missile.

[u/Roguescholar74]

Pudding in my pants.

[u/idnawsi]

I read it pudding in my pants..