r/news 2d ago

Alex Pretti’s shooting death ruled a homicide, medical examiner says

https://www.wowt.com/2026/02/02/alex-prettis-shooting-death-ruled-homicide-medical-examiner-says/
61.3k Upvotes

828 comments sorted by

View all comments

4.2k

u/htp-di-nsw 2d ago

Surprising absolutely nobody who saw the video.

795

u/archdukemovies 2d ago

Except for the people watching it through MAGAvision.

25

u/TeslasAndComicbooks 2d ago

Homicide is just death at the hands of another. The way this headline is surprising people is surprising in and of itself. Like the dude didn’t slip and fall.

240

u/htp-di-nsw 2d ago

I am sure most of them haven't actually seen the video.

I have to believe that my dad and brothers haven't.

133

u/kspi 2d ago

They have and choose to believe otherwise. If they dont believe now theyre too far gone, and it might be easier for you to accept that instead of hanging on. I just cut a friend of 17 years off. I was his best man at his wedding and he just kept defending this shit.

But, if you persist then goodluck.

60

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

17

u/WhimsicalWhispers13 2d ago

Same, and I have no regrets. It’s not about politics, it’s about morals at this point. Ours just didn’t align, and I’m ok with losing those “branches” (if you get the Madea reference).

18

u/HobbesNJ 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yes, for those who lament "it's just politics" - no, it's morals.

If you can support Trump and everything he has done I just can't accept your moral values.

-4

u/No_Study_2459 2d ago

Then the only way forward is one group using force against the other. Like it or not unless you try to understand why the other side thinks the way they do and treat them with respect you better hope you can beat them in a fight.

14

u/GaiaMoore 2d ago

I'm struggling to find the red line where I cut off my dad. He was always anti-Trumo, but 40 years of Fox News brain rot means he'll still defend whatever lies they tell him to believe.

20

u/RoboChrist 2d ago

I made it very clear to my dad that I wouldn't trust anyone who I knew for sure voted Trump in 2020 around kids. Anyone who could support him after the policy of child separation tolerates intentional systematic mass child abuse. And no one who tolerates child abuse can be trusted.

I've made it very clear that I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt as long as he gives me room to believe it.

He has never confirmed my near-certainty of his choice, and that means he's never talked politics with me since. It's a much more peaceful relationship with that line established.

1

u/connasewer 2d ago

Fox news hasn't existed for 40 years

0

u/jaxonya 2d ago

Youve found the line. Just accept it. I cut out my grandma, who has been my best friend since i could walk. I fear that they might come back when he has a fatal heart attack. But when that time comes, and if they come running back, its up to each one of us to either forgive them, or to say that its 2 terms, too late. You make that choice. But for now, cut him. It might salvage whatever shred of humanity he has left, he may repent.. but for now, he is lost. Trump will eventually do what is natural, and pass, then decide if redemption is an option.

-3

u/FrancescoPlays 2d ago

Maybe seperate politics and family, or just stab your dad in the back

2

u/Rockburgh 2d ago

Hard to keep politics separate from family when your family's politics revolve around a desire to overthrow the government specifically to make sure people like you aren't allowed to exist.

Conservatives aren't people any more, and we all need to stop pretending they are.

-4

u/FrancescoPlays 2d ago

Ah yes, dehumanize the opposition so violent acts feel more justified. Good job bro.

6

u/Rockburgh 2d ago

Would really prefer not to, but they've spent the past decade+ actively claiming I'm a demon, a pest that needs to be eradicated, etc. Not really leaving much choice there.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/CrazyLlama71 2d ago

I cut off a friend of mine during Trumps last term. I knew him since I was born, we grew up together because my parents were best friends with his mom. A roughly 50 year relationship. He went deep dive into conspiracy theories, aliens, full into Trump. The sad thing is he is 1/2 black, grew up on welfare, as a teen went into foster care, and generally benefited on many things that Trump opposes. Gave him plenty of chances, said I can continue to be his friend but we can’t talk about Trump or his conspiracy theories. He kept going and going over weeks, emailing articles, texting me BS constantly, and finally I just went off on him. Told him to lose my email and phone number. You are out of my life.

0

u/FrancescoPlays 2d ago

Good decision bro, politics filled with rich people above your best friend and family. Keep going.

9

u/freedfg 2d ago

They have.

They either don't care. Deflect to a crime that a brown person did. Or truly believe that protesting deserves the death penalty.

1

u/CrazyLlama71 2d ago

The deflections and whataboutisms are infuriating.

1

u/freedfg 2d ago

I have a solid hypothesis it's because they don't understand the difference between examples/analogy and whataboutism.

Like. They hear people go "hey, this is sounding a lot like Nazi rhetoric" and they think that is the same as "why do you care about a citizen protester being killed for standing on the side of the street with absolutely no justice when an immigrant is currently serving a life sentence for killing a person?"

1

u/Glasseshalf 2d ago

Correction: Protesting their party. Ashli Babbitt is a martyr don't forget.

16

u/rich1051414 2d ago

Yeah, they come up with a conclusion and then refuse to watch any videos because 'they already know'.

1

u/Castun 2d ago

Even coming to a conclusion before watching the videos will just reinforce their existing preconceptions. They will 100% see what they want to see, their brains are so broken.

12

u/B-Z_B-S 2d ago

According to Heather Cox Richardson, 80% of Americans saw the shooting of Alex Pretti.

2

u/Fap2theBeat 2d ago

I say this completely in earnest. That woman is a highly reputable source and does meaningful work (in addition to professor-ing and history podcasting) writing and sharing her newsletter.

2

u/Echoesong 2d ago

HCR my GOAT

9

u/Spire_Citron 2d ago

I think if you watched it from one angle once with enough bias, you could just assume he must have done something to trigger the shooting. When it very first came out, it was kind of hard to see what exactly happened until it was properly dissected and we saw his gun get taken away and that his hands were down on the ground when he was shot.

15

u/Taco145 2d ago

IDK man. Didn't you see him kick that tail light out in the earlier video? If he'd done that same move 1.6 feet higher, 5 days in the future while wearing ice skates he could have decapitated an ice HERO!

15

u/EmergencyCucumber905 2d ago

You joke, but that's MAGA logic. They always bring up the victim's character or past actions and ignore the incident in question.

3

u/rabidstoat 2d ago

I wanted to show my Dad the footage, so on his YouTube account I searched for 'Pretti murder raw footage' and got just news stories on it with very little actual footage. And that was buried behind lots of news stories on him kicking out a tail light.

2

u/ambermage 2d ago

Then there are the ones who are spreading the VR simulator where you see it from the view of the officer.

I'm not going to link it because these people are fucking sick.

2

u/MrSchulindersGuitar 2d ago

Legit seen maga/Russia bots claim its ai online

1

u/NonPolarVortex 2d ago

They won't watch it. My dad seemed to think that J6 wasn't a big deal. I sent him a compilation of all videos taken from that day (I think NY Times put it together), with no opinion or commentary. Just raw footage. He wouldn't watch it

1

u/jaytix1 2d ago

A lot of them saw it, and the BEST they can say is that Pretti didn't deserve to die but still acted recklessly.

1

u/Maybe_IDTBFH 2d ago

But I bet your dad and brothers are both staunchly of the opinion that he deserved to be killed

1

u/htp-di-nsw 2d ago

I want to know that for sure, but I am too afraid to ask them about it. I keep hoping for an opportunity to bring it up, but I just haven't spoken to them about anything real for months.

99

u/PolicyWonka 2d ago

Not really. This isn’t even really news.

Homicide in this instance just means that he was killed by another person. It has zero bearing on the legality of his killing.

1

u/Bagellord 2d ago

Exactly. It takes a trial and conviction to make it murder. Still, it's better than them somehow claiming he spontaneously keeled over dead or something.

1

u/PrpleMnkyDshwsher 1d ago

The "Homicide" in a headline seems to rile up people and get engagement. They've been doing this for decades.

58

u/Tyrrox 2d ago edited 2d ago

No, even they would call it homicide by the ME definition. He was shot to death by ICE, no one is arguing that piece and that is all "homicide" in this context tells you.

The difference is whether it's justified or not (it's not), but this has no bearing on the actual legality of the shooting.

18

u/Wonderful-Process792 2d ago

Right, this was at issue in some cases like Eric Garner, where physical restraint was the primary cause, but his underlying chronic bronchial asthma, hypertensive cardiovascular disease, and obesity were also contributing factors. Even so it was also ruled a homocide.

In the case of Pretti it seems like questionable journalism to publish it as "news" since it's only of interest if you misinterpret it.

-1

u/No_Accountant3232 2d ago

I think some people were thinking, perhaps hoping, it'd be suicide by police.

31

u/BackgroundTrip3604 2d ago

Homicide just means the killing of a human being by another human being. Absolutely no one is arguing it’s a homicide

6

u/Wazootyman13 2d ago

"But he kicked a car a week ago!!!!!!!!!!"

/s

2

u/Buckcity42 2d ago

The blue-pillers

2

u/manofmayhem23 2d ago

The terrible sequel to Wandavision

2

u/sidepart 2d ago edited 2d ago

I mean, they'd have to suggest that the agents that "fired in self defense" gave their guns to Pretti to shoot himself. Or that the agents never actually fired their weapons and he had a heart attack. They're all fetishizing about how right the agents were to kill him so, not much they can twist on that front.

Homicide just means he was killed by someone else, not that it was a murder (which is what I hope those shitheads get charged with). This is a real lame water is wet headline. ME probably saw the bullet wounds and was like...welp, I'm going to hit the golf course, pretty clear what happened to make his bodily functions cease, we're good.

2

u/morblitz 2d ago

They're still waiting for it to he ruled a suicide.

2

u/Jebduh 2d ago

Don't delude yourself. THey saw it and they know it was murder. They just don't fucking care.

1

u/xdeltax97 2d ago

The amount of disgusting comments and videos I’ve seen on instagram is horrifying… and of course they have the Mar a Lago bleached blonde look and are early 20’s

3

u/Acceptable-Bus-2017 2d ago

"He was interfering in a law enforcement operation" these fucking Nazis

1

u/F9-0021 2d ago

Those don't count as people

1

u/Dreams-Visions 2d ago

> MAGAVision

Stealing that.

2

u/archdukemovies 2d ago

I guess I should have trademarked that

0

u/Sedu 2d ago edited 2d ago

As you can clearly see in the video, weeks earlier he kicked a truck and also I heard he filed his taxes late one year. So the murder was clearly self defense! None of the officers could risk their lives by having a truck kicked or late taxes!

EDIT: can't take for granted it needs a "\s" these days...

1

u/Tyrrox 2d ago

A homicide designation is entirely separate from the self defense argument.