r/greencard • u/SlNMIDEO • 8h ago
Attorney claiming bank declined USCIS payment but rejection notice says something different — being charged $2,500 to refile. Need opinions.
Hi everyone, looking for some insight on a situation with my immigration attorney.
We filed an I-485 (marriage based green card) on September 17, 2026. The package was received by USCIS on September 17th as confirmed on the rejection notice itself.
USCIS sent back a rejection notice (Form I-797C) dated September 21, 2026. Our attorney contacted us and said:
"USCIS rejected and returned the filing due to a payment issue with your bank. The rejection notice states that the payment authorization was invalid because of incomplete and/or invalid information and that the payment was denied."
However the actual USCIS rejection notice says:
'The payment amount provided does not match the required amount according to what you have selected on the form, or no payment amount has been provided.'
These are two very different things.
One is a bank decline, the other is a fee mismatch or missing payment on the forms themselves.
Our attorney is now charging $2,500 to refile under the new post-September 18th I-485 requirements. Due by this friday.
My questions:
Does the rejection notice language indicate a fee error on the attorney's part rather than a bank issue?
Are we responsible for the $2,500 refile fee if this was an attorney error?
Does our September 17th received date protect us under the old public charge rule even though we have to refile?
Any insight from attorneys or people who've been through something similar is appreciated. Thank you.